240 likes | 586 Views
Understanding Collateral Requirements in Relation to Self-Insurance. 2006 Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar September 12, 2006. Introduction. Why collateral is required How collateral is determined Collateral stacking – what and why
E N D
Understanding Collateral Requirements in Relation to Self-Insurance 2006 Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar September 12, 2006
Introduction • Why collateral is required • How collateral is determined • Collateral stacking – what and why • How insurance program structure affects operations and collateral • Types of collateral • Other Key considerations before selecting the insurance program structure and collateral • Questions
Why Collateral? • Credit Risk for Insurer • Statutory Requirements • Rating Agency Considerations
Who Best to Take Credit Risk? • Casualty Insurer? • Bank?
How Collateral Requirement Determined? For Financial Reporting Year (Balance Sheet) • Estimate of Ultimate Loss – Paid to Date What Impacts This Calculation? • Actual Loss Results to Date • Loss Development Methodology • Development Factors Used
How Collateral Requirement Determined? For Budget Year (Fiscal Plan) • Loss Forecast What Impacts This Calculation? • Historical Loss Experience • Loss Forecast Methodology • Development Factors Used
Collateral Stacking • What is collateral “stacking”? - Collateral stacking is the accumulation of required collateral across multiple effective periods. • Why is collateral “stacked”?- Paid loss emergence patterns- Accrued loss emergence and “IBNR” losses
Collateral Stacking (cont.) • Example 1 – No growth and no inflation scenario • Example 2 – No growth and 4% inflation scenario • Example 3 – 3% growth and 4% inflation scenario
Biggest Impact on Collateral? Actual Loss Results
Insurance Program Structures Impact • Common Insurance Program Structures- Guaranteed cost- Deductible- Self-insured retention- Retrospectively rated contracts- Captive insurance company
Insurance Program Structures Impact (cont.) • Balance Sheet and Income Statement Impact • Working Capital Impact • Credit Capacity Impact • Compliance considerations
Types of Collateral • Letter of Credit • Cash • Surety Bond • Trust Account • Promissory Note
Insurance Program Collateral Impact Deductible
Considerations • Cash Position • Effective Tax Rate • Ability to Retain Risk • Capacity and Cost of Collateral • Financial Strength
Questions? Tom Fuller Liberty Mutual Sr. Risk Management Consultant 314-843-0600 x214 thomas.fuller@libertymutual.com Marn Rivelle KPMG LLP Senior Manager, Actuarial Services 213-533-3340 marnrivelle@kpmg.com