1 / 10

Where to put the Armor?

Where to put the Armor?. Math Olympiad 2011 Northwest Missouri State University Neil Hatfield. The Problem. The United States Air Force is experiencing a problem…they are losing air craft on missions. USAF knows that the loss of planes is not due to pilot error or malfunction.

allene
Download Presentation

Where to put the Armor?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Where to put the Armor? Math Olympiad 2011 Northwest Missouri State University Neil Hatfield

  2. The Problem • The United States Air Force is experiencing a problem…they are losing air craft on missions. • USAF knows that the loss of planes is not due to pilot error or malfunction. • The loss of planes is due to the planes being shot down. • You (and your team) have been hired to solve this problem.

  3. The Job • You and your team will need to • Develop a research question that will help you solve the USAF’s problem. • Design and “employ” a plan for data collection • Note: the USAF (me) may or may not be able/willing to give you the data you want, but will give you the data that we can. • Analyze and summarize your data. • Interpret your results • Make sure to answer your team’s research question. • Make a recommendation to the USAF for where to put the armor. Keep in mind, we’re on a budget.

  4. Recommendations

  5. And the Answer is…. Where there are not any bullet holes. But that’s counter-intuitive!

  6. So where’s the Problem(s)? • Formulating the question(s)? • Designing and Employing Data Collection? • Analyzing and Summarizing the Data? • Interpreting the Results and Answering the Question?

  7. Data Collection • Where did our data come from? • Planes that were shot, but were able to return to base. • The data is statistically biased towards the planes that survived! • What we really want to know about are where the planes that did not return were shot.

  8. Adjusting for Bias • Let’s do some reasoning • If a part of a plane got shot… • And the plane made it back… • Then… • That part needs no additional armor. • So what about the spaces between the shots?

  9. Historical Background • Patrick Blackett • Director of Operational Research for the British Navy, 1942-1945 • He and his team solved this very problem. • Convoy Survival • Depth Charges

  10. What To Take Away • Thinking critically costs us nothing. • Not thinking critically can cost. • Common Sense isn’t always the best, or right, thing to do. • Data is dirty…what we get to work with may or may not help us answer the question.

More Related