130 likes | 471 Views
Temporary Configuration Changes. Tony Hathcock Duke Energy - Oconee June 18-20, 2007 Charleston, SC. How do you modify your plant outside of the formal engineering change program?. Types of Changes. Temporary Alterations : Installed for SSC’s that are out of service per Maintenance Rule
E N D
Temporary Configuration Changes Tony Hathcock Duke Energy - Oconee June 18-20, 2007Charleston, SC
How do you modify your plant outside of the formal engineering change program?
Types of Changes • Temporary Alterations:Installed for SSC’s that are out of service per Maintenance Rule • Temporary Engineering Changes (Temp Mod):Formal Engineering Change package with a removal date • Temporary Configuration Changes:pre-engineered approved design configuration changes controlled by a procedure or program for simple and routine activities for in-service SSCs.
Guiding Principle All changes must be analyzed prior to installation for their design requirements.
Background INPO continues to identify weaknesses with temporary change control at various sites.
Background • INPO PO&C CM 2.8 “The physical configuration of the plant meets design and license basis. The configuration is consistent with procedures, drawings, and other documentation” • INPO PO&C CM 3.6 “Temporary modifications are reviewed periodically for continued need and to identify changes that are inconsistent with the licensing and design requirements. Temporary modifications are normally removed within a refueling cycle.”
INPO Engineering Digest 2006-01 Featured Topic: “Temporary Modifications” A formal temp mod is considered “burdensome” for simple and routine activities. “To counter this, organizations have created stand-alone procedures, processes, or engineering documents sometimes referred to as ‘mini-processes’ or ‘exemptions’…”
Duke Energy Initiatives Oconee AFI in 2002: Undocumented plant changes. • Analyzed and documented as a permanent modification • Removed • Many were controlled by existing processes and procedures • Oconee developed site directive - roadmap to existing processes, based on a similar Catawba directive
Duke’s New Fleet Procedure • provides guidance for temporary configuration changes • lists existing siteprocedures and programs that allow temporaryconfigurationchanges.
Temporary Configuration Changes Temporary Configuration Changes require: • Engineering evaluation of design • Configuration controls by procedure for • installation • operation • removal • SSC is tagged per procedure.
Examples • Installation of temporary power • Drop Cords • Installation of temporary cables (data, video, and communication) • Installation of welding cables • Test leads and temporary electrical jumpers • Temporary RP equipment • Rubber hoses (for fire protection) • Hose attachment to service connections
Examples • Online leak sealing • Leak Repair • Catch Containments to control leaks • Drains and Vents • Temporary Structures • Rigging and temporary supports • Lead shielding • scaffolding • portable measurement and test equipment • electrical cabinet doors left open & unattended
Breakout Discussion • Provide examples of your procedures and programs • Identify utilities that have good programs where such changes are: • clearly identified and tracked • clearly traceable to thesupporting evaluations • Identify program weaknesses such as: • interim abandoned equipment • temporary changes made permanent (e.g., shielding, scaffolding, etc.)