650 likes | 1.11k Views
Current status of adjuvant HER2 targeting therapy Valentina Guarneri, MD, PhD Istituto Oncologico Veneto IRCCS University of Padova. Outline. Trastuzumab plus chemotherapy: the gold standard for HER2 positive early breast cancer
E N D
Current status of adjuvant HER2 targeting therapyValentina Guarneri, MD, PhDIstituto Oncologico Veneto IRCCSUniversity of Padova
Outline • Trastuzumab plus chemotherapy: the gold standard for HER2 positive early breast cancer • Improving on cardiac toxicity: different regimens and different treatment durations • Improving on treatment efficacy: dual blockade and new anti-HER2 agents • Toward personalized cancer medicine: challenging the gold standard for specific patient subgroups
Outline • Trastuzumab plus chemotherapy: the gold standard for HER2 positive early breast cancer • Improving on cardiac toxicity: different regimens and different treatment durations • Improving on treatment efficacy: dual blockade and new anti-HER2 agents • Toward personalized cancer medicine: challenging the gold standard for specific patient subgroups
Meta-analysis of adjuvant trastuzumab trials: Disease-free Survival MojaL, et al. The CochraneLibrary 2012, Issue4
Meta-analysis of adjuvant trastuzumab trials: Overall Survival MojaL, et al. The CochraneLibrary 2012, Issue4
DFS : ∆ 11.9% at 6y ∆ 11.5% at 10y OS : ∆ 5.5% at 6y ∆ 8.8% at 10y
Sequentialadministration Concurrentadministration Trastuzumab up to 1 yr BCIRG 006 DC x 6+ H AC x 4 D x 4+ H Joint analysis of NSABP B31 & N9831 AC x 4 T x 4 + H N9831 Sequential arm wT x 12 AC x 4 HERA Adjuvant CT (Any) RT FIN-HER D/N+H x 9 wks FECx 3 FEC/ED x 6 RT PACS 04 Are all trastuzumab adjuvant trials the same? Randomization Trastuzumab start T= paclitaxel; D= docetaxel
Overall Survival stratified by concurrent or sequential administration MojaL, et al. The CochraneLibrary 2012, Issue4
Outline • Trastuzumab plus chemotherapy: the gold standard for HER2 positive early breast cancer • Improving on cardiac toxicity: different regimens and different treatment durations • Improving on treatment efficacy: dual blockade and new anti-HER2 agents • Toward personalized cancer medicine: challenging the gold standard for specific patient subgroups
High competing mortality risk score Low competing mortality risk score Cancer ahead pub 2010
Congestive heart failure (CHF): all studies. Moja L, et al. The Cochrane Library 2012, Issue 4
BCIRG 006: Adjuvant Breast Cancer Node Positive and High Risk Node Negative 4x AC60/600 mg/m2 4x Docetaxel 100 mg/m2 ACT HER2+ (central FISH) N+ or High risk N- N=3,222 pts ACTH 1 Year Trastuzumab 6 x Docetaxel 75 mg/m2 +Carboplatin AUC 6 TCH 1 Year Trastuzumab
Slamon et al. SABCS 2006. Abstract 52. Slamon D, NEJM 2011.
CHF by trastuzumab duration Moja L, et al. The Cochrane Library 2012, Issue 4
DFS by trastuzumab duration Log (Hazard ratio) HR weight HR (IV,random, 95%CI) Moja L, et al. The Cochrane Library 2012
Overall survival stratified by duration of trastuzumab treatment Moja L, et al. The Cochrane Library 2012, Issue 4
PHARE* Trial results comparing 6 to 12 months of trastuzumab in adjuvant early breast cancerXavier Pivot, Gilles Romieu, Hervé Bonnefoi, Jean-Yves Pierga, Pierre Kerbrat, Thomas Bachelot, Alain Lortholary, Marc Espié, Pierre Fumoleau, Daniel Serin,Jean-Philippe Jacquin, Christelle Jouannaud, Maria Rios, Sophie Abadie-Lacourtoisie, Nicole Tubiana-Mathieu, Laurent Cany, Stéphanie Catala, David Khayat, Iris Pauporté, Andrew Kramar. • Protocol of • Herceptin® • Adjuvant with • Reduced • Exposure • *lighthouse in French
Study design trastuzumab up to 12 months trastuzumab 6 months R Stratification 1. ER pos / neg 2. Chemo: conco/ seq stop trastuzumab Clinical exam LVEF … 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 30 mos Mammography Up to 60 mos… R: Randomizationafterinformed consent
Statistical Methods • Non inferiorityrandomized trial • 2% variation in terms of absolutedifference of recurrence • The 95% CI HR marginsshould not cross the 1.15 boundary • 1040 DFS events required for 80% power at 5% level or 4 years of accrual and at least 2 years of follow-up • HR were estimated from the stratified Cox model • Accrualtarget: 3400 patients
Primary endpoint scenarii A Equivalent B Superior C D Non Inferior E Inferior .85 1 1.15 1.3 1.45 1.6 HR
Cardiac toxicity * Investigatorreportedevents (composite withclinical and LFEV finding) ** Based on more than > 25,000 assessments
DFS Events 42.5mos. median Follow-up
Disease Free Survival 97.0 93.8 90.7 87.8 95.5 91.2 87.8 84.9 EventsHR95%CIp-value H 12m 176 H 6m 219 1.28 (1.05 – 1.56) 0.29 * Cox model stratified by ER status and concomitant chemotherapy
42.5mos. median FU Overall Survival 99.9 98.7 96.9 95.0 99.3 97.2 95.2 93.1 EventsHR95%CIp-value H 12m 66 H 6m 93 1.47 (1.07 – 2.02) * Cox model stratified by ER status and concomitant chemotherapy
Primary endpoint scenarii A Equivalent B Superior PHARE trial C D Non Inferior E Inferior .85 1 1.15 1.3 1.45 1.6 HR
Trastuzumab duration effects in patient subgroups in the PHARE*trial • Protocol of • Herceptin® • Adjuvant with • Reduced • Exposure Xavier Pivot, Gilles Romieu, Hervé Bonnefoi, Jean-Yves Pierga, Pierre Kerbrat, Thomas Bachelot, Alain Lortholary, Marc Espié, Pierre Fumoleau, Daniel Serin,Jean-Philippe Jacquin, Christelle Jouannaud, Maria Rios, Sophie Abadie-Lacourtoisie, Nicole Tubiana-Mathieu, Laurent Cany, Stéphanie Catala, David Khayat, Iris Pauporté, Andrew Kramar. SABCS 2012 • *lighthouse in French
Subgroup Results ER- status & Sequentialmodality Other groups
R 9 mos 3 mos 6 mos 12 mos Trastuzumab 8 mg/kg loading dose 6 mg/kg q 3 wks AC60/600 or EC90/600 Docetaxel 100 FEC (600/60/600) Trastuzumab 4 mg/kg loading dose 2 mg/kg weekly :LVEF measurement Short-HER: study design PI: PF Conte RT/HT Sample size 1250 pts RT/HT 18 mos EUDRACT-2007-004326-25, NCT00629278
Enrollment as of May, 2013 • 1176 patients • Arm A (Long) 586 patients • Arm B (Short) 590 patients
Outline • Trastuzumab plus chemotherapy: the gold standard for HER2 positive early breast cancer • Improving on cardiac toxicity: different regimens and different treatment durations • Improving on treatment efficacy: new anti-HER2 agents and multiple dual blockade • Toward personalized cancer medicine: challenging the gold standard for specific patient subgroups
TEACH Trial • Eligibility • HER2+ Local IHC3+ or FISH +ve • Resected Stage I-IIIc primary BRCA • No prior trastuzumab • Neo-/adjuvant chemotherapy (CMF, anthracycline, or taxane) • Appropriate endocrine therapy • Stratification • Time from diagnosis ≤4 vs >4 yrs • Lymph node +ve vs -ve • ER+ and/or PgR+ vs ER–/PgR– R A N D O M I Z E Lapatinib 1500 mg qd × 1 yr N=3147 Aug 2006-May 2008 33 countries Placebo qd × 1 yr 4 yr Diagnosis • Disease-free survival (DFS):local, regional, distant recurrence,contralateralBRCA,other 2nd primary cancers,death from any cause Goss, SABCS 2011
TEACH Primary Endpoint: K-M Plot of DFS inITT Population—Time From Randomization Lapatinib HR 0.83 (0.70-1.00); p=0.053a Placebo Median Follow up: 4 years 0.0 • No improvement in OS demonstrated with use of lapatinib:HR: 0.99 (95% CI: 0.74-1.31; P = .966) Goss, SABCS 2011 ap value based on 2-sided stratified log-rank test
TEACH: Forest Plot of DFS for Subgroups in ITT Population L=lapatinib; P=placebo. Goss, SABCS 2011
Dual anti-HER2 blockade (neoadjuvant studies) Phase III NeoALLTO study Phase II CHER-LOB study
Dual Anti-HER2 blockade significantly increases the pCR rate 60 Exploratory p=0.0187 50 40 46.7% 30 20 25% 26.3% 10 0 Arm A: CT + T Arm B: CT + L Arm C: CT + T + L pCR (breast & axilla) Guarneri V et al, J Clin Oncol 2012 Baselga J et al. Lancet 2012