160 likes | 293 Views
GENETIC ANALYSIS OF THE TOMMY AND MINE CANYON SITES IN CONTEXT OF SOUTHWEST POPULATIONS. Meradeth Snow, Kathy Durand, David Glenn Smith. mtDNA Briefly…. 5 Native American haplogroups: A, B, C, D, and X Defined by mutations identified by: RFLP analysis Direct sequencing.
E N D
GENETIC ANALYSIS OF THE TOMMY AND MINE CANYON SITES IN CONTEXT OF SOUTHWEST POPULATIONS Meradeth Snow, Kathy Durand, David Glenn Smith
mtDNABriefly… • 5 Native American haplogroups: • A, B, C, D, and X • Defined by mutations identified by: • RFLP analysis • Direct sequencing
Previous aDNA Research in the Southwest • Shearin et al. 1989 • Horai et al. 1991 • hap B • O’Rourke et al. 1996—11 samples • 3 hap B, 1 hap A, 1 hap C • 2 other, and 4 N or D • Carlyle, 2000 & 2003—27 samples • 26 hap B, 3 hap A, 5 hap C, and no D • 4 other
Previous aDNA Research in the Southwest • Regional continuity of the general Southwest mtDNA pattern: • high haplogroup B • low to moderate levels of A and C • no haplogroup D • Maintained in modern Pueblo groups such as the Zuni and Jemez. (Lorenz and Smith 1996; Kaestle and Smith 2001)
Methods • Extractions carried out in the aDNA Molecular Anthropology Lab at UC Davis. • Bones and teeth both yielded DNA • RFLP analysis to determine haplogroup. • Sequencing results obtained.
RFLP Results • Sites were distinct at the 0. 00005 level.
MC 0.05 Fremont TS Anasazi Zuni 0.00 c[,2] Apache Jemez -0.05 Navajo -0.3 -0.2 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 c[,1] RFLP Results
Preliminary Sequencing Results • Mine Canyon Haplogroup A samples • Possible Athapaskan connection? • mutations at specific sites: • nsp 16331 • nsp 16192 • All Mine Canyon hap A samples do not have these mutations
Preliminary Sequencing Results • Did have three other mutations: • nps 16257 (C→T) • nps 16263 (T→A) • nps 16360 (C→T) • 4 Zuni hap A samples have these same unique mutations. (Kemp, 2006)
Discussion • Not all sites maintain the general Southwest mtDNA pattern.
Discussion • Regional variability may be due to: • Sampling error… • Mine Canyon—7 out of 12 • Carlyle’s data—3 out of 38 • Drift (chance) • Founder’s effect or • Reduction in population size
Discussion • Haplogroup D • Often absent in the Southwest. • Was present at the Tommy Site, and possibly other sites. • Low frequency may have influenced previous identification.
Discussion • Haplogroup A • RFLP frequency similarities between the Mine Canyon site and the Athapascans. • High frequency of hap A • Sequences demonstrate cultural continuity. • Zuni hap A’s
Future Reseach • Further analysis of the sequence data for the remainder of the samples. • HVII sequence analysis, particularly of the hap A samples. • Sex identification of unidentifiable samples. • Correlation with the remainder of the analyses presented here.
Acknowledgments • Many thanks to the other students, previous students, and employees at the UC Davis MAL: Wendy Garnica, Debbie George, Sree Kathaswamy, Brian Kemp, Jessica Satkoski, Kari Schroeder, Monalyn Umali, and Venkat. Thanks!