1 / 28

Human Rights (2)

Human Rights (2). UN structure and monitoring bodies. Review:. Treaties that cover human rights create duties and responsibilities for a government to protect, promote and fulfill the human rights of its people.

arthur-espinoza
Download Presentation

Human Rights (2)

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Human Rights (2) UN structure and monitoring bodies

  2. Review: • Treaties that cover human rights create duties and responsibilities for a government to protect, promote and fulfill the human rights of its people. • The United Nations (UN), a multilateral decision-making organization comprised of 191 member nations, is the key international body responsible for safeguarding human rights worldwide. • There are six major human rights treaties negotiated by the UN member states that expand upon rights first guaranteed in the landmark 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights

  3. the International Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Racial Discrimination(in force 4 January 1969) the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (CCPR)(in force 23 March 1976) the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights(in force 23 March 1976) the Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women(in force 3 September 1981) the Convention Against Torture(in force 26 June 1987) the Convention on the Rights of the Child(in force 2 September 1990). Since 1948 …the human rights treaty system encompasses the following treaties

  4. UN Human Rights Commission – (this replaced by Human Rights Council) Functions: • Setting human rights standards( did it implement them?) • Holding an annual public debate on human rights violation( who sat on the Commission – how often did they meet) • Appointing special rapporteurs, special representatives, experts and workinggroups to study themes or country situations. Today 16 countriesand more than20 thematic procedures are in place • Criticism: • Some of the world's most abusive regimes ….won seats on the Human Rights Commission and used them to insulate themselves from criticism."

  5. Human Rights Council • T he Commission's members were pre-selected behind closed doors and then "elected" by acclamation. By contrast, the new members of the Council had to compete for seats, and successful candidates needed to win the support of a majority of all member states, in a secret ballot. • importance of ending double-standards, a problem which plagued the past Commission

  6. Human Rights Council • A new universal periodic review mechanism will offer the Council - and the world - the opportunity to examine the records of all 191 member states of the United Nations. This is a dramatic development with the potential to improve human rights throughout the world. • the Council will meet throughout the year -three times for a total of 10 weeks • Council seats have been allocated on a regional basis as follows: Latin America 8; Western Europe 7; Eastern Europe 6; Africa 13; Asia 13. • all of these changes will amount to very little unless the members of the new Council are prepared to look beyond their immediate political interests and embrace the cause of human rights victims worldwide. That will require principled leadership from every one of them.

  7. International Court of Justice (1946) Functions: • To settle in accordance with international law the legal disputes submitted • to it by states • To give advisory opinions on legal questions referred to it by international • agencies

  8. Tripartite Mechanism for ILO Convention for Protection of Worker’s Rights • Governments, employers and trade unions

  9. International Criminal Court (agreement to set it up 1998) Proposed Functions: • Bring cases against individuals for war crimes, genocide and crimes againsthumanity • Increasing state responsibility for infringement of human rights • Contributing to an international order that demands respect for human rights

  10. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (1993)High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mr. Sergio Vieira de Mello(2002 – 2003. died tragically in Iraq, 19 August 2003 as Special Representative of the Secretary General) Functions: • Providing states with advisory service and technical assistance on request • Enhancing international cooperation in human rights • Engaging in dialogues with governments aimed at securing respect for all humanrights • Promoting effective implementation of human rights standards 60th Session of the Commission on Human Rights: 6 week session opened 20 Jan, 15 March – 23 April 2004, Geneva

  11. Acting High Commissioner, Bertrand Ramcharan, http://www.unhchr.ch/pdf/Issue%20Nr%201+.pdf

  12. The High Commissioner Ms. Louise Arbour was appointed High Commissioner in July 2004; Ms. Kyung-wha Kang joined the Office as its Deputy High Commissioner in January 2007. heads the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR). The post of High Commissioner was established in December 1993 by a General Assembly resolution, in accordance with a recommendation contained in the Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action. The resolution specifies that the High Commissioner is the principal United Nations official responsible for United Nations human rights activities, and that the High Commissioner performs his/her duties under the direction and authority of the Secretary-General. The resolution gives the High Commissioner the broad mandate to promote and protect all human rights: civil, political, economic, social and cultural.

  13. José Ayala-Lasso United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights(5 April 1994 - 15 March 1997) Mary Robinson, UNHCHR 1997 - 2002

  14. Treaty Monitoring Bodies: CERD (est 1969) CCPR/HRC (1976) CESCR (est 1985) CEDAW (est. 1982) 28th Session 13-31 Jan, 03. CAT(est1987) CRC (1991) The treaty bodies are composed of members who are elected by the states parties to each treaty (or through the UN Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) in the case of CESCR). In principle, treaty members are elected as experts who are to perform their functions in an independent capacity. http://www.crlp.org/pub_art_tmb_3.html

  15. Treaty monitoring bodies • Each committee employs two primary methods to ensure that states observe their human rights treaty obligations. • Issue General Comments or Recommendations • Review State Protection of Human Rights • Some of the committees have an additional mandate pursuant to the relevant treaty to utilize the following two methods to hold governments accountable to human rights violations. • Examine Individual Complaints • Investigate Mass Violations

  16. Distr.GENERAL CCPR/C/SR.1846 19 July 2000 Summary record of the 1846th meeting : Ireland. 19/07/2000. CCPR/C/SR.1846. (Summary Record)Convention Abbreviation: CCPR HUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTEE Sixty-ninth session SUMMARY RECORD OF THE 1846th MEETING Held at the Palais Wilson, Geneva,on Thursday, 13 July 2000, at 3 p.m. CONSIDERATION OF REPORTS SUBMITTED BY STATES PARTIES UNDER ARTICLE 40 OF THE COVENANT (continued) Second periodic report of Ireland The meeting was called to order at 3.05 p.m. CONSIDERATION OF REPORTS SUBMITTED BY STATES PARTIES UNDER ARTICLE 40 OF THE COVENANT (agenda item 4) (continued) Second periodic report of Ireland (CCPR/C/IRL/98/2; CCPR/C/69/L/IRL) 1. At the invitation of the Chairperson, Mr. McDowell, Ms. Anderson, Mr. Barrett, Mr. Flahive, Mr. Ingoldsby, Mr. Rowan, Ms. McSweeney, Mr. Hanrahan and Mr. MacAodha (Ireland) took places at the Committee table.

  17. HRC : Ireland, some examples • In 1993, before the paramilitary cease-fires, the UN Human Rights Committee said there was no justification for the continued use of the non-jury Special Criminal Court and criticised emergency legislation here. • Mary Robinson: Recent report of the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights gave no grounds for complacency in Ireland. It found that the relevant UN Covenant had not been fully incorporated in domestic legislation, and was rarely, if ever. invoked before the courts. (May 1999) • State may be forced into limiting defamation awards (july 2000) • Ireland may be forced by the European Court of Human Rights to limit excessive defamation awards, the Attorney General, Mr Michael McDowell, admitted to the UN Human Rights Committee • The Government will send an interim report on the Offences Against the State Act to the UN Human Rights Committee later this week (July 2001) • The Government is forwarding the report in response to a finding of the UN Human Rights Committee that one aspect of the Act, where the DPP can refer a case to the Special Criminal Court on the basis of a certificate, violated the UN Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

  18. CRC • UN committee recommends ombudsman for children (Jan 1998) • An ombudsman for children and a national child-care authority for Ireland have been recommended by the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child. Its report is highly critical of Ireland's record on child care. In a report issued yesterday, following its hearings on the situation in the Republic, the committee also called for a ban on slapping children • Result:The Ombudsman for Children Act, which sets out the role and powers of this Office, was agreed by the Dail and the Seanad in 2002 In November 2003 the job for Ombudsman for Children was advertised; Emily Logan became Ireland’s first Ombudsman for Children in March 2004.

  19. CRC: China • The report alleges that thousands of children are being allowed to die every year from medical neglect and starvation in China's state run orphanages, with the tacit approval of senior political leaders," the statement went on. • UNICEF quoted its executive director, Ms Carol Bellamy, saying that such actions would clearly contravene the Convention on the Rights of the Child, which China has ratified.

  20. First Generation Rights • These encompass political and civil rights • Early statements on ‘human rights’ focused on rights like • freedom of speech and assembly and the rights to take part in the government of his country, directly or through freely chosen representatives

  21. Second Generation rights • These relate to economic, social and cultural rights and featured in the Declaration (Art. 22) • Some argue, these are not rights, they are merely unenforceable individual or group entitlements • they are not justiciable • They are aspirational, abstract; they cannot be the subject of either affirmative state obligation or of immediate realization and enforcement • ‘for a human being to be considered whole, they must be able to enjoy both civil and political rights, as well as economic, social and cultural rights… human rights … become the bedrock of a wholesome and integrated approach to sustainable human development’ • 1993 Vienna Declaration: explicitly reaffirms the indivisibility, inerdependence and interrelatedness of the two categories of human rights (http://hdr.undp.org/docs/publications/background_papers/Oloka-Onyango2000.html)

  22. Third Generation Rights • These build on the collective dimension and concern the rights of ‘peoples’ • Banjul Charter ( 1981) entered into force1986 • Peoples have the right to ‘freely dispose of their wealth and natural resources’ ( art. 21(1)); the individual has a duty ‘to serve his natural community by placing his physical and intellectual abilities at its service’ and ‘to preserve and strengthen positive African cultural values inhis relations with other members of the society…’ (Art 29 (2) & (7) ) • This instrument lays the foundation for a human rights system in Africa, relying on African documents and traditions rather than UN declarations and covenants

  23. Banjul Charter - what makes it different • it is different from the European and Inter-American human rights systems in several respects: • the Charter recognizes duties as well as rights; • it codifies peoples’ as well as individual rights; • and protects economic, social, and cultural rights in addition to civil and political rights.[79

  24. Banjul Charter: some criticism • “claw-back” clauses • permit the routine breach of Charter obligations for reasons of public utility or national security and confine many of the Charter’s protections to rights as they are defined and limited by domestic legislation. • lack of effective enforcement mechanisms; weak institutional structure • …it has not functioned in practice to guarantee or protect their rights…

  25. ‘The Banjul Charter’ • Human rights are guaranteed in the political constitutions of almost all independent African States; several aspects of he Charter provide evidence of a general acceptance of the normative standards enshrined in the international instruments • 9non-discrimination, equality of all persons, fundamental freedoms and liberties) • Banjul Charter: ‘a paper tiger’ • violence and human rights abuse has exploded in the African continent in the 1990s • Political persecution of critics, political opponents, journalists, and human rights activists is also a flagrant practice in many African states • Endemic state corruption also leads to systematic abuse of social, economic, cultural, and environmental rights of large majorities

  26. The African Court of Human Rights • 8 June 1998, members of the OAU meeting in Burkina Faso voted to initiate the process for the creation of an African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights • the protocol for the proposed court requires the ratification of fifteen OAU member States

  27. Cultural Relativism • This is the argument about the extent to which ostensibly universal standards of human rights should be tempered by the local cultural situation that prevails in the distinct regions of the world • This tension is apparent in the text of the African Charter • ‘Universalists’ versus ‘relativists

More Related