1 / 19

WHAT NOW?

This text explores the spread and evolution of democracy in Latin America, examining the different phases and challenges faced. It also analyzes the role of the United States in relation to Latin American democracy. The text raises important questions about the quality and prospects for consolidation of democracy in the region.

aschreiner
Download Presentation

WHAT NOW?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. WHAT NOW? Democracy and U.S.-Latin American Relations

  2. APPROACHING THE QUESTION • The Taming of Democracy • The Pink Tide: Making Democracy “Dangerous” Again • Looking Ahead: Prospects for Consolidation

  3. READINGS • Smith, Democracy, Epilogue

  4. QUESTIONS • What explains the spread of democracy in Latin America? • What kind of democracy? What quality? • What’s new about the current phase of democratic change? How does it compare to prior periods? • What role (if any) for the United States?

  5. Dimensions of Democracy, 1900-2000

  6. INITIATION OF DEMOCRACY • Era of oligarchic democracy (1900-1939) • Elite-led experiments in democracy: • Top-down mobilization, esp. of middle classes • Competition among elites • Co-optation of potential opposition • Weak ideological dimension: focus on politics, not economics

  7. DANGERS OF DEMOCRACY The Onset of Mass Politics, 1940-77: • Popular mobilization • Specters of revolution • Grand policy schemes • Strong states Targets of Threat • Socioeconomic elite • Middle classes • Military • United States

  8. THE TAMING OF DEMOCRACY • Making Democracy Safe, 1978-present: • Transitional pacts • De-mobilization of labor and peasantry • Fear of extremism • Evaporation of political left • Ideological vacuum • Declining strength of state • Thus: spread and duration of electoral democracy

  9. DANGERS REVIVED? • Democracy as Protest/The Pink Tide (1998-present): • Leftist ideological orientation • Concern with poverty, social justice • Rebuilding state strength • Resistance to Washington Consensus • Condemnation of USA/Bush administration: • Aspiration for “Bolivarian dream” • Q:What good is a democracy that isn’t dangerous?

  10. PENDULUMS OF HISTORY • 1900-1939: democracy not “dangerous,” orchestrated by elites • 1940-1977: democracy becomes dangerous, with mass mobilization and calls for sweeping socioeconomic reform • 1978-present: democracy initially “tame” not dangerous, with neoliberal consensus • 1998-present: democracy dangerous again, with rise of new Left

  11. LOOKING AHEAD I Interim Developments: • 43% “democrats,” 30.5% “ambivalent,” 26.5% “nondemocratic” • Economic growth (reducing poverty + inequality) • 9/11 and its aftermath The Problem of Consolidation: • Longevity? Of what? • Deepening • From illiberal to liberal democracy? Or not?

  12. LOOKING AHEAD II • The greater the frustration within the population, • The greater the sympathy with anti-establishment movements, • The more extensive the general participation in elections, • The more clearly defined the partisan or ideological alternatives, and • The more effective the role of representative institutions…

  13. The more divisive will be debates over policy content in Latin America, • The greater the likelihood of nationalistic and/or anti-establishment policies, • The greater the resistance to demands from the United States, and • The greater the probability of policy conflicts with Washington. • Thus: the greater the degree of democracy in Latin America, the greater the degree of inter-American tension and disagreement.

  14. CHALLENGING AMERICAN MYTHS • The Cherished Assumption—freely elected leaders will support U.S. policy • The Western Hemisphere idea—the new world is distinct from old, will forge common front in international arena • Democracy rationale for “regime change”—free elections as protective shield • The hegemonic presumption—the United States can dictate political life in Latin America

  15. U.S. VISIONS FOR LATIN AMERICA • Democratic—with tilt to right or center-right • Prosperous—with commitment to free-market policies and ties to United States • Unified—under U.S. leadership • Peaceful—in view of unanimity • Deferential—following U.S. lead in global arena

  16. REALITY CHECK • Democracy = broad ideological spectrum, from “left” to “right” • Prosperity = mixed economies; rejection of Washington Consensus, FTAs, and FTAA • Ideology = diversity rather than unity • Outlooks = anti-U.S. attitudes strong and growing among large share of population • Alliances = rejection of U.S. leadership and rules of the game

  17. ROLES FOR THE UNITED STATES? • Focus on politics—beyond the war on terror, beyond free trade; recognize exceptional nature of current opportunity • Adopt long-term view of national interest • Hands off! Do not intervene in elections or encourage overthrows of elected leaders • As opportunities arise, bolster institutions and “deepening” of democracy in Latin America • Re-examine The Cherished Assumption

  18. The end.

More Related