1 / 15

The Joy and Pain of Chapter Titles

The Joy and Pain of Chapter Titles. Mary Strouse ILUG July 25, 2009. “End users rely on and expect enhanced content including summaries/abstracts and tables of contents.” -- Executive Summary “Search results must be relevant and the relevance must be obvious.” -- Key Findings

aspen-palmer
Download Presentation

The Joy and Pain of Chapter Titles

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Joy and Pain of Chapter Titles Mary Strouse ILUG July 25, 2009

  2. “End users rely on and expect enhanced content including summaries/abstracts and tables of contents.” -- Executive Summary “Search results must be relevant and the relevance must be obvious.” -- Key Findings Online Catalogs : What Users and Librarians Want (OCLC 2009) http://www.oclc.org/reports/onlinecatalogs/summary.htm

  3. Varieties of Contents Data

  4. Identifying Which Books Have Tables of Contents • No contents signal in Webpac • Record browse format (Classic/Pro) ex.1 • Brief citation format (Classic/Pro) ex.2 • Contents signal in Encore ex.3A & ex.3B • Vendor format (970) only • Appears only if table of contents is present

  5. Keyword Searches (Webpac) • Result always a list of book titles • Brief Citation ex.4 • Record Browse (Classic) ex.5 • Sorting • Open keyword -- RightResult • weights words in main title, direct order ex.6 • Keyword in title, etc. – default sort ex.7 • Chapter titles only if indexed in title ex.8 • Terms not limited to a single chapterex.9A • (use near search to refine) ex.9B

  6. Keyword Searches (Encore) • Result always a list of book titles ex.10 • Sorted by relevance (default) ex.11 • Begins as an open keyword search • Use search results facet to limit to title, etc. ex.12 • Search terms not limited to a single chapter ex.13A • (refine by tag cloud) ex.13B

  7. Title Searches • Chapter titles included in search results • Requires 505 |t and/or 970 |t indexed in title • Introduction, etc. can be excluded (using 970 second indicator) • Initial articles automatically ignored • Chapter titles not identified in results • Display of book vs. chapter title inconsistent • Index browse - controlled by browse or browse_t • record browse (system-sorted) – controlled by browse_t • Custom sorts and limits – controlled by briefcit.html

  8. Which Title Displays? When search matches multiple index entries • Default display = index browse (system sorted) • Indexed title displays ex.14Aex.15A • May be book title, alternate title, analytic entry, or contents (970/505 |t) • Source of title (book/chapter) not indicated • Not affected by Display_245 • Display of 970 subfields controlled by browse_t • Limiting/Sorting switches to record browse (brief citation) ex.14B & ex.15B

  9. Which Title Displays? When • Search matches single index entry, or • User selects single entry from index, or • Results limited/sorted in any way Display format is • Record browse (Classic) ex.16 • Display_245 operative • Display of 970 subfields controlled by browse_t • Brief citation (Pro/Classic) ex.17 • Display of 970 subfields controlled by Fieldspec:vbt in briefcit.html Book title, not indexed title, displays • Apparent duplicate entries ex.18A & ex.18B

  10. But Wait! The Chapter Title Option In briefcit.html, if fieldspec:vbT, both indexed (chapter) and book title are shown ex.19 • Only applies to title index searches • Affects all variant/analytic titles ex.20 • Browse_t controls indexed title display • Loss of control over subfields fieldspec:vbT245abhnpl the same as fieldspec:vbT #105894, #107034

  11. Author Searches • Chapter authors can be indexed • Requires 970 |f (personal names) indexed in author • Does not apply to 505 |r • 970 |d (corporate author) and |e (editor) contain mixed authorized/unauthorized forms • Chapter titles not identified in results ex.21 • Chapter, not book title displays regardless of sort/limit ex.22 • Chapter title option (Fieldspc:vbT) does not apply

  12. Email/Download Issues When record is emailed or downloaded: • Contents (505) included only if defined in export format (endnote, procite, etc.) • Contents (970) fields suppressed to protect vendor data • No contents signal/link back to full record in brief export format Relevance of results to search may be lost

  13. Recommendations: Display • Identify chapter titles in index browse • Extend fieldspec:vbT or similar option to author and keyword search results • Honor 245 subfields specified in fieldspec=vbT • Add contents signal to brief citation with link to full TOC display (a la Encore)

  14. Recommendations: Download • Allow export of chapter titles from limited number of records for legitimate individual scholarly use • Contents signal/link back to full TOC in brief export format • Customizable message informing user that table of contents will not be downloaded

  15. Thank You! Mary M. Strouse Head of Technical Services Judge Kathryn J. DuFour Law Library, Catholic University of America strouse@law.cua.edu

More Related