90 likes | 287 Views
SHAMED. Southern Hebrides Against Marine Environmental Designations Castlebay, Isle of Barra 26 th January, 2011. CONSULTATION Nov 2008 informal consultation Aug 2009 SNH submit scientific report to Scot Gov 29th Oct 2010 Minister announces formal consultation. PROCESS.
E N D
SHAMED Southern Hebrides Against Marine Environmental Designations Castlebay, Isle of Barra 26th January, 2011
CONSULTATION • Nov 2008 informal consultation • Aug 2009 SNH submit scientific report to Scot Gov • 29th Oct 2010 Minister announces formal consultation
PROCESS UK Procedure (1) SNH submits scientific advice to Scot Gov (2) site becomes a draftSAC (3) Scot Gov moves to public consultation and site becomes a possibleSAC
PROCESS Mingulay Procedure (3) May 2008 Scot Gov decides to publicly consult on Mingulay without having received a scientific case (2) Jan 2009 SNH refers to Mingulay as a dSAC before scientific case is put to Scot Gov (1) Aug 2009 SNH submits scientific advice to Scot Gov
PROCESS Mingulay pSAC Procedure * flawed Selection * what type of REEF?
PROCESS Mingulay pSAC Procedure * flawed Selection * what type of REEF? * how much is enough? * who draws the lines?