1 / 8

Gender-Related Indicators: Issues for Advocacy, Policy, and Research Stephan Klasen

Gender-Related Indicators: Issues for Advocacy, Policy, and Research Stephan Klasen University of Göttingen Germany OECD Workshop May 24, 2007. Three Uses of Gender-Indicators. National and international advocacy regarding gender issues Simple and transparent

aysha
Download Presentation

Gender-Related Indicators: Issues for Advocacy, Policy, and Research Stephan Klasen

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Gender-Related Indicators: Issues for Advocacy, Policy, and Research Stephan Klasen University of Göttingen Germany OECD Workshop May 24, 2007

  2. Three Uses of Gender-Indicators • National and international advocacy regarding gender issues • Simple and transparent • Comparable across space and time • Powerful advocacy messages • Guide to policy-makers regarding priority gender issues • Disaggregated and comprehensive • Covering actionable policy areas • Useful for direct monitoring purposes

  3. Three Uses • Gender data for Research on Gender Issues • Need underlying causal variables • Long time series useful • Data quality issues quite crucial • Comparability across space and time important;

  4. Advocacy Indicators • UNDP‘s Gender-Related Measures currently don‘t fulfill this function: • GDI often misinterpreted as gender gap measure, problems with earned income component, hard to interpret, highly intransparent; • GEM also too complex and dependence on income levels (rather than gender gaps in incomes) • Currently implementing alternatives based on review process in 2006 (see Journal of Human Development 2006); • Other measures (e.g. WEF Gender Gap Index, Africa Gender Index, or Social Watch Index) useful but also generally too complex and rather intransparent; • Conceptual problems: • Compensation versus Cumulation; • Ratio of Rates versus Female Shares; • Averaging of Ratios (arithmetic versus geometric means) • Weigthing Procedures

  5. Proposals to Revise GDI-GEM • GDI: to be replaced with geometric mean of three component gender ratios (life expectancy, education, and labour force participation); • GEM: Use income shares rather than income levels and also use geometric mean of female-male ratios of three components; • Create separately distribution-sensitive well-being measures (including gender inequality as one distributional issue);

  6. Gender Indicators for Policy • Considerable success of MDG3 indicator; • Needed: actionable gender disaggregated measures; • Problem: Many areas simply no data • Distribution of resources within households; • Gender distribution of wealth within households; • Gender-disaggregated input into agricultural production and small enterprises • Gender-based violence • No internationally (or inter-temporally) comparable data on female labour force participation, unemployment, or wages • Sometimes available but not used;

  7. Gender Data for Research • Need data that help develop causal models of gender inequality (across space and time); • OECD database a very useful starting point (but no time series!); • Need to take historical evolution of gender-based institutions much more seriously (and try to find quantitative measures for it); • Comparable data on gender-disaggregated economic data would surely help !

  8. Conclusion • A modest proposal: • Let‘s fix the advocacy problem once and for all with a simple transparent gender gap measure; • Focus our attention on gender gender-disaggregated data in actionable policy arenas; • Try to get time series of internationally comparable economic data by gender • Work on ways to measure and explain historical evolution of institutions of equity or inequity.

More Related