1 / 48

4 th International Symposium on Flood Defence May 6-8, 2008 Sydney, Australia Ryusuke Hashimura

USING THE CENTRAL PRESSURE METHOD TO FORECAST DAMAGE LENGTH OF MARITIME STRUCTURES CAUSED BY TYPHOON 9918. 4 th International Symposium on Flood Defence May 6-8, 2008 Sydney, Australia Ryusuke Hashimura Department of EcoDesign Sojo University, Japan.

azure
Download Presentation

4 th International Symposium on Flood Defence May 6-8, 2008 Sydney, Australia Ryusuke Hashimura

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. USING THE CENTRAL PRESSURE METHOD TO FORECAST DAMAGE LENGTH OF MARITIME STRUCTURES CAUSED BY TYPHOON 9918 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence May 6-8, 2008 Sydney, Australia Ryusuke Hashimura Department of EcoDesign Sojo University, Japan

  2. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Figure shows the Location of Kyushu Island of Japan

  3. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE shows 8 coasts in Kumamoto and Nagasaki Pref.

  4. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE 1: Track of Typhoon 9918 presented by JMA (Values in figures are the wind speed and time (hours)/date). Typhoon 9918 struck the Kyushu Island in the western part of Japan.

  5. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE 1: Track of Typhoon 9918 and probability circle (values in figures are the central pressure (hPa) and time (hours/date)). The area circled by the solid line shows the storm area, in which the wind speed forecasted by JMA exceeded 25m/s. The dotted circle is the storm area in which the wind speed exceeded 15m/s.

  6. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE 1:Track of Typhoon 9918 The long-dashed circle is probability (70%) circle of the center of the typhoon at 09:00 on September 24th.

  7. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The maximum anomaly was estimated to be about 3m at a northern part of Yatsushiro west coast. The inundation height was equivalent to about 2.2m above H.H.W.L (Highest High Water Level).

  8. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence • FIGURE 4: • The anomalous storm surge was induced in the closed seas of the western region of the Kyushu Island (Figure 2) by Typhoon 9918.

  9. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE shows damage case due to the anomalous storm surge and wind waves caused by Typhoon 9918 at the northern part of the west coast of Yatsushiro Sea (Figure 2).

  10. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE shows damage case due to the anomalous storm surge and wind waves caused by Typhoon 9918 at the northern part of the west coast of Yatsushiro Sea (Figure 2).

  11. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE shows damage case due to the anomalous storm surge and wind waves caused by Typhoon 9918 at the northern part of the west coast of Yatsushiro Sea (Figure 2).

  12. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE shows damage case due to the anomalous storm surge and wind waves caused by Typhoon 9918 at the northern part of the west coast of Yatsushiro Sea (Figure 2).

  13. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE shows damage case due to the anomalous storm surge and wind waves caused by Typhoon 9918 at the northern part of the west coast of Yatsushiro Sea (Figure 2).

  14. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence FIGURE shows damage case due to the anomalous storm surge and wind waves caused by Typhoon 9918 at the northern part of the west coast of Yatsushiro Sea (Figure 2).

  15. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The maximum anomaly was estimated to be about 3m at a northern part of Yatsushiro west coast. The inundation height was equivalent to about 2.2m above H.H.W.L (Highest High Water Level).

  16. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The calamitous damage due to the storm surges and wind waves caused by Typhoon 9918 were reported by Kumamoto Prefecture Government. • 16 people were killed, 62,772 houses destroyed or damaged, 1,883 houses flooded and the cost of damage was about US$1 billion. • Especially, Typhoon 9918 caused extensive inundation by the significant storm surges. • In the northern part of the Yatsushiro west coast 12 people were killed by the storm surge. • The actual total damage length of damaged maritime structures facing the west coast of Yatsushiro, denoted by L, is 8048 m. This is the largest damage length of maritime structure cases in at least the last 50 or more years.

  17. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The damage of structures means breaching of dikes, cracking of seawalls, overturning of breakwaters, shift of breakwaters, removal of rubble from groins etc. The total damage length is the sum of the length of damaged part of structures in each region (coastline) for each typhoon. The damage length of maritime structures attributed to Typhoon 9918 was estimated using the Central Pressure Method (Hashimura, R., 2006(b)). The Central Pressure Method uses a vulnerability index for the given coast and typhoon passage. This index is based on the damage caused by 43 typhoons in the 15 years.

  18. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The damage length is estimated as follows: The damage length is estimated based on the path of typhoon 9918 as determined from the typhoon’s location and direction of movement at a latitude of 30º N. The vulnerability index of maritime structures at the coast is given from the path of typhoon and the coast. The damage level, which is shown by the damage length, is estimated using the vulnerability index and the central pressure of the typhoon at a latitude of 30º N. The Central Pressure method utilizes an index of vulnerability of a coast for a typhoon passing a specified path (in each course), which was derived from the damage induced by 43 typhoons during past 15 years.

  19. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The 43 typhoons, which passed through an area delineated by a latitude of 30º and 35ºN and a longitude of 127º and 132º E, between 1980 and 1994 were divided into 13 groups (course) based ontheir paths (Figure 3).

  20. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Figure 3 Historical typhoon paths (courses)

  21. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Table 1 shows the 13 categories based on the direction of movement and the longitude of the position of the typhoons for each path at a latitude of 30º N. D is measured clockwise from north.

  22. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The longitude of the position of Typhoon 9918 at a latitude of 30ºN was 128.3ºE. The direction of progress was 22.5º clockwise from north. Therefore, Typhoon 9918 can be classified as a No. 4 Typhoon based on the classification in Table 1.

  23. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The vulnerability index of maritime structure at the coast is given from the path (course) No. (shown in Figure 3 or Table 1) and the coast (shown in Figure 4). The damage length, which is shown by the length of damaged part of the damaged structures is estimated by using the vulnerability index and the CP ( Central Pressure) of typhoon at a latitude of 30ºN. The CP method utilizes an index of vulnerability of a coast for a typhoon passing a specified course (path), which was derived from the damage induced by 43 typhoons during past 15 years.

  24. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence 3.1 The relation between the central pressure of typhoon and the smoothed damage length The damage length for each coast is defined as the summation of the length part of maritime structures damaged by each typhoon in the coast, which is given by Equation [1]. [1] Y = (P/T)×100 where Y is the smoothed damage length, P is the damage length caused by each typhoon for each coast and T is the total damage length by all typhoons for this particular coast. The smoothed damage length indicates the contribution to the total damage length for the coast by each typhoon.

  25. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Table shows smoothed damage length The typhoons ordered based on 1) the path No. of typhoon, 2) the maximum wind speed near the typhoon center in the same path No. 3) the central typhoon pressure at a latitude of 30ºN in the same path No.

  26. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The smoothed damage length is expected to increase rapidly with an increase in the maximum wind speed (Hashimura, 2002). This trend can be expressed by Eq.[2] [2] Y = exp [{(V – m) In 10}/10] V is the maximum wind speed near the typhoon center, Yis the smoothed damage length. The values of m are selected to equal the smallest maximum wind speed observed. Based on the classification of JMA, the value of m for the first 7 ranks are 17, 25, 29, 33, 37, 41 and 44ms-1.

  27. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Applying regression analysis to the data in Figure, the Equation is obtained:

  28. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Substituting Equation [3] into Equation [2] yields: Y = exp [{(–3.01×10-3 P2 + 5.36P – 2339 – m) ln10 } / 10 ] The symbols represent the different coasts.

  29. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Y = exp [{(–3.01×10-3 P2 + 5.36P – 2339 – m) ln10 } / 10 ] The lines a to g show the theoretical values predicted using Eq.(4), with the values of m varying from 44 to 17. The numerical values, 1 to 6, shown outside of the figure, denote the six areas delineated by the lines b to f.

  30. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Table 3 shows the number of areas in which the plotted point is located. When no damage occurs, the number is not shown.

  31. The number given in Table 3 is termed the “sensitivity value” for Central Pressure of typhoon based on the damage length. The sensitivity value indicates the vulnerability to the individual typhoons. It should be noticed that a typhoon with the largest smoothed number of damage cases at the coast does not always has the largest sensitivity value. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence

  32. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence TABLE 3: Maximum sensitivity values for the smoothed damage length Table 4 shows the maximum sensitivity value for each path at the individual coasts. This table indicates the vulnerability index for an individual typhoon path at each coast. The central pressure of Typhoon 9918 was 935 hPa at a latitude of 30ºN. Based on Table 3, the maximum sensitivity value for the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea for path No. 4 is 4.

  33. 4. THE APPLICATION OF THE PATHS TO TYPHOON 9918 Region 4 is located between lines c and d. The smoothed damage length, Y, is obtained from Equation [4] for a sensitivity value of 4 and a central pressure of typhoon, 935 hPa. The maximum smoothed damage length, Y, is 49.0, which was obtained by substituting m = 29 for line c. Similarly, the minimum smoothed damage length, Y, is 19.5, which was obtained by substituting m = 33 for line d.

  34. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Therefore, the range for the smoothed damage length along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea for Typhoon 9918 lies between 19.5 and 49.0. The total damage length along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea during the last 15 years was L = 6,715 m. The damage length for Typhoon 9918 is estimated to be from 19.5% to 49.0% of 6,715 m, that is, from 1,309 m to 3,290 m. The estimated damage length was a small compared with the actual length (L = 8,047 m).

  35. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence On the other hand, comparing the track of Typhoon 9918, shown in Figures 1 with the 13 tracks (courses) given in Figure 3, the path of Typhoon 9918 is considered similar to the paths No. 3, 5, 6, 7, or 8. Based on Table 3, the maximum sensitivity value along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea for path No. 3 is 3. Performing a similar calculation yields the range for the damage length for Typhoon 9918 as 7.8% to 19.5% of 6,715 m, that is, from 521 m to 1,309 m. These values are smaller than the actual length (L= 8,047 m).

  36. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Based on Table 3, the maximum sensitivity value along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea for path No. 5 is 1. Performing a similar calculation yields the maximum damage length for Typhoon 9918 as 3.0% of 6,715 m, that is, 201 m. These values are much smaller than the actual damage length (L = 8,047 m). The maximum sensitivity value for path No. 6 is 1. Thus, the result is the same as assuming a path No. 5 case. The maximum sensitivity value for path No. 7 is 0.

  37. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Based on Table 3, the maximum sensitivity value along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea for path No. 8 is 6. The smoothed damage length, Y, is obtained from Equation [4] for the sensitivity value 6 and the central pressure of typhoon, 935 hPa. The minimum smoothed damage length is 117.5, which was obtained by substituting m = 25 for line b. Thus, the minimum damage length for Typhoon 9918 is estimated to be 117.5% of 6,715 m, that is, 7,890 m. This length is quite similar to the actual length (L = 8,048 m). The actual length is in the region 6.

  38. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence 5. Discussion The application of path No.3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 to Typhoon 9918 shows that the estimated values of total damage length of maritime structures along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea differ greatly. It was shown that the estimated damage length along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea is largely affected by the changes in the path of the typhoon.

  39. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence In Figure, the left vertical axis shows the seal level and right vertical axix shows the scale for meteorological tide. Figure 5: Example of Tidal elevation of Typhoon 9119 at Misumi St.

  40. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence Under normal circumstances, the maximum meteorological tide does not occur at the same time as the maximum astronomical tide (Figure 5).

  41. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The third column (Peak before) indicates the peak sea level and the time (day, hour, and minute) when the maximum astronomical tide occurred before the maximum meteorological tide occurred. The fourth column (MMT) indicates the maximum meteorological tide and the time (day and hour). The fifth column (Sea L.) is the sea level when the maximum meteorological occurred.

  42. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The sixth column (Peak after) indicates the peak sea level and the time (day, hour, and minute) when the maximum astronomical tide occurred after the maximum meteorological tide occurred. In Table 4, “below” is used to indicate that the maximum meteorological tide value was below 30 cm.

  43. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence For Typhoon 9117, which followed path No. 4, the maximum meteorological tide occurred 3.5 hours before the second maximum astronomical tide. The sea level at this time was rather low, 436 cm. Thus, it can be assumed that the damage caused by Typhoon 9117 was not due to the storm surge. There is no other typhoon that followed path No. 4. For Typhoon 9918, although the maximum meteorological tide occurred 2 hours before the second maximum astronomical tide the sea level was rather high, 608 cm. For this reason when using path No. 4 conditions, the estimated damage length is too small compared to the actual length.

  44. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence The sea level at the maximum storm surge induced by Typhoon 8513, which followed path No.8, was high, 605cm. The maritime structures along the western coast of Yatsushiro Sea suffered serious damage caused by the storm surge and the wind waves during the high tide. For this is the reason, when using path No. 8 conditions, the estimated damage length (L=7,890 m) for line b of Typhoon 8513 is a little bit small compared with the actual damage length (L=8,048 m).

  45. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence In fact, for both Typhoon 8513 and 9918, the sea level at the maximum meteorological tide was high (608 cm for Typhoon 9918 and 605 cm for Typhoon 8513) (Table 4). The estimated damage length is larger than the estimated damage length for path No. 4. The reason is that the real path of Typhoon 9918 was different from the course of Typhoon 8513, which followed path No.8. The maximum wind speed of Typhoon 8513 did not decrease after passing a latitude of 30°N,while the maximum wind speed of Typhoon 9918 decreased after passing 30°N (Figure 1).

  46. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence 7. Conclusions # In 1999, Typhoon 9918 struck Kyushu Island, which is in the western part of Japan, causing enormous damage to maritime structures. # The damage length to maritime structures caused by Typhoon 9918 was estimated using the Central Pressure Method (Hashimura, R., 2006(b)), and compared with the actual damage length. # When path No. 4 conditions, which were determined by the position and the direction of the typhoon at a latitude of 30° N, were applied, the estimated damage length was a small compared with the actual length.

  47. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence # Compared to the actual length, the estimated damage length for path No. 3 conditions was small; # for path No. 5, 6, and 7 conditions, the estimated damage length were extremely small, # while for path No. 8 conditions the estimated damage length was close to the actual damage length.

  48. 4th International Symposium on Flood Defence # This can be explained by noting that, except for path No. 8 typhoons, no serious storm surges were observed for path No. 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 typhoons, while Typhoon 9918 had a substantive storm surge.

More Related