120 likes | 240 Views
‘Where did all the flowers go?’ What happens to students between high school and university?. Matthew Absalom The University of Melbourne. Languages in education. Things we know: Large attrition rates at ‘junctures’ Year 7/Year 8 Year 10 Low overall participation rates at Year 12 (~4.5%)
E N D
‘Where did all the flowers go?’ What happens to students between high school and university? Matthew AbsalomThe University of Melbourne
Languages in education • Things we know: • Large attrition rates at ‘junctures’ • Year 7/Year 8 • Year 10 • Low overall participation rates at Year 12 (~4.5%) • Downwards trend in higher education • More than 90% of students study a small group of languages: Chinese, French, German, Indonesian, Italian, Japanese
Languages at University • 90-95% of 1st year students do not study a language • Of these >50% may be beginners • In 2007, only 2 of our 39 universities offered no ‘modern’ languages • 24 languages offered across sector • Most institutions offer 4 languages • Greatest number offered around 15 • Ja (34), Ch (27), Fr (24), It (23), Ge (20), Ind (20)
Motivation & learning • Motivation • Intrinsic (e.g. interest, enjoyment, intellectual stimulation, difficulty) ~ Integrative • Extrinsic (e.g. vocation, travel, peer/family expectations, media, marks) ~ Utilitarian or instrumental • Learning • High levels of intrinsic motivation required to promote deeplearning and educational achievement
The study • Online survey of commencing first year students in range of subjects in the Faculty of Arts at The University of Melbourne • Ethics approval • 198 responses • Preliminary study • Estimates: 102 had dropped languages by VCE
Why continue to year 12? • I thoroughly enjoyed the language and culture • I've always felt a need to be able to speek in at least one other language. • loved learning the language and being able to speak it • felt i was good at it and would score well love languages and french culture, enjoyable subject plus bonus marks • Possible high scores, since it gets scaled up by at least 10 marks. • It will be important in the future (in terms of career opportunities), as China overtakes USA. Challenge and Enjoyment • Enjoyed learning the language, and the cultural studies • Exchange to France in year 11 for 6 weeks enhanced language skills and desire to become competent. I knew that one day I wanted to become bilingual, and so I pursued my languages through to the end of VCE. I also really enjoyed studying them and wanted to make sure I did subjects I enjoyed during the stressful time of VCE. Love staying with a host family in switzerland and wish to return thereHelp with vce score
Why stop? • I was only allowed by my school to select one language to continue with. • I felt I had other recourses to study this language outside of school. bad teachers Not intensive enough, no pathway made • Moving overseas • Not enough subjects once uni prerequisites were filled Too difficult and not interested Too much time commitment with language classes. My school didn't stream so as a weaker member of the class I fell behind and felt overlooked. Poor teaching quality, lack of connection to culture. • I moved schools to one that did not offer Indonesian and I did not feet like beginning again. • The previous teacher of the subject was irritating, and I would have been unlikely to continue anyway if she had been teaching the class. I stopped studying Italian in my third year of secondary school because of poor relations with the teacher and conflicting timetables with other electives. • I dropped Chinese because it was a compulsary subject for which I had no interest • The teacher ignored those who didn't understand the language and concentrated on the more able students, leaving the rest of us like me confused and even more bored.
Implications • We need to understand what motivates our learners • This study: • strong intrinsic motivation plus certain extrinsic motivators (VCE score/career) led to retention • Clear effect of in-country experience (positive) • Blockers: the ‘system’, learner diversity, teacher quality and relationship, lack of intrinsic motivation • Cohort effect
Next steps • Revisit the questionnaire (ask whether students are enrolled in a language!) • Second round looking at school age students as well as those entering university • Include other faculties and, possibly, other universities (cohort effect)