1 / 33

Late-Time Cosmic Acceleration: Dark Gravity ( arXiv:0807.1640) Francisco S. N. Lobo,

Late-Time Cosmic Acceleration: Dark Gravity ( arXiv:0807.1640) Francisco S. N. Lobo, Centro de Astrofísica da Universidade de Lisboa. Spanish Relativity Meeting - ERE 2010 Gravity as a Crossroad in Physics Granada 6-10 September. Late-Time Cosmic Acceleration:

bayle
Download Presentation

Late-Time Cosmic Acceleration: Dark Gravity ( arXiv:0807.1640) Francisco S. N. Lobo,

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Late-Time Cosmic Acceleration: Dark Gravity (arXiv:0807.1640) Francisco S. N. Lobo, Centro de AstrofísicadaUniversidade de Lisboa Spanish Relativity Meeting - ERE 2010 Gravity as a Crossroad in Physics Granada 6-10 September

  2. Late-Time Cosmic Acceleration: Dark Gravity (arXiv:0807.1640) Francisco S. N. Lobo, Centro de AstrofísicadaUniversidade de Lisboa Universe is undergoing an accelerated expansion! Represents new imbalance in the gravitational field equations Cause? Remains an open and tantalizing question

  3. 1. LCDM fits data well… but we cannot explain it • it’s the simplest model • compatible with all data so far • no other model is a better fit • but …. theory cannot explain it

  4. 1. LCDM fits data well… but we cannot explain it • it’s the simplest model • compatible with all data so far • no other model is a better fit • but …. theory cannot explain it • why so small? (note a difference of 120-orders-of-magnitude. EMBARRASSING!!!) • and … why so fine-tuned?

  5. Alternatives to LCDM: 0.2 or Dark Gravity? 0.75

  6. Dynamical Dark Energy in General Relativity “quintessence”, etc… 0.2 0.75

  7. Dark Gravity – Modify GR on large scales • 4D: scalar-(vector)-tensor theories [e.g. f(R)] • higher-D: braneworld models [e.g. DGP] 0.2 or Dark Gravity? 0.75

  8. Dark Energy dynamics:

  9. Dark Energy dynamics: Dark Gravity dynamics:

  10. Modified (dark) gravity Is GR wrong on large scales ?i.e. acceleration via the weakening of gravity Example from history: Mercury perihelion – Newton + ‘dark’ planet ? no – modified gravity! Today: Modified Friedman equations (schematic)

  11. 2. f(R) gravity Action: Gravitational field equations (vary action with g):

  12. 2. f(R) gravity Action: Gravitational field equations (vary action with g): Effective Einstein equation: with Conservation law:

  13. Ricci scalar is a dynamical degree of freedom: a new light scalar degree of freedom eg. at low energy, 1/R dominates

  14. Ricci scalar is a dynamical degree of freedom: a new light scalar degree of freedom eg. at low energy, 1/R dominates This produces late-time self-acceleration • but the light scalar strongly violates solar system constraints • all f(R) models have this problem • way out: ‘chameleon’ mechanism, i.e. the scalar becomes massive in the solar system - very contrived!!

  15. 2.1 R-matter couplings in f(R) gravity Action:

  16. 2.1 R-matter couplings in f(R) gravity Action: Gravitational field equations:

  17. 2.1 R-matter couplings in f(R) gravity Action: Gravitational field equations: Using the generalised Bianchi identities, one has a corrected conservation equation:

  18. 2.1 R-matter couplings in f(R) gravity Action: Gravitational field equations: (Perfect fluid) Non-geodesic motion: with an extra force:

  19. 2.1 R-matter couplings in f(R) gravity Action: Gravitational field equations: (Perfect fluid) Non-geodesic motion: with an extra force: Intriguing result:Field eqs. depend on matter Lagrangian. Different choices:

  20. 2.2 Late-time cosmic acceleration f(R) gravity may lead to an effective dark energy. Consider the FLRW metric, and a perfect fluid, the generalised Friedmann equations: Where the curvature terms are given by: Late-time acceleration: !!

  21. 2.2 Late-time cosmic acceleration e.g. vacuum , effective EOS A. Consider , generic power law Results: , Suitable choice of n leads to and late-time acceleration

  22. 2.2 Late-time cosmic acceleration e.g. vacuum , effective EOS A. Consider , generic power law Results: , Suitable choice of n leads to and late-time acceleration B. Another example :

  23. 3. Gauss-Bonnet gravity • Considering higher-order gravity, motivation consistent with several “quantum gravity” candidates • String/M-theory predict unusual gravity-matter couplings • Couple a scalar field with higher order invariants • String/M-theory predict scalar field couplings with the Gauss-Bonnet invariant important in the appearance of non-singular early time cosmologies • Apply these motivations to the late-time Universe!

  24. 3.1 Action of Gauss-Bonnet gravity: Canonical field: ; phantom field Gauss-Bonnet invariant:

  25. 3.1 Action of Gauss-Bonnet gravity: Canonical field: ; phantom field Gauss-Bonnet invariant: FLRW metric, gravitational field equations:

  26. Equation of motion for the scalar field: Define an effective equation of state: - Exponential scalar potential and scalar-GB coupling: - Scale factor: - Scalar field: EOS: , if ,

  27. 3.2 Modified Gauss-Bonnet gravity (interesting alternative gravitational theory): Introduce two auxiliary scalar fields, A and B: 1. Vary with B A=G 2. Vary with A B=f´(G)

  28. 3.2 Modified Gauss-Bonnet gravity (interesting alternative gravitational theory): Introduce two auxiliary scalar fields, A and B: 1. Vary with B A=G 2. Vary with A B=f´(G) Taking into account the following definitions: Final action: Gauss-Bonnet action, without the kinetic term!

  29. 4. Dark gravity from braneworlds? String theory - our 4D universe may be moving in 10D spacetime ST unifies the 4 interactions

  30. DGP – the simplest example 4D brane universe in 5D bulk Friedman on the brane early universe – recover GR dynamics late universe – acceleration without DE gravity “leaks” off the brane therefore gravity on the brane weakens passes the solar system test: DGP GR The background is very simple – like LCDM

  31. … too good to be true 5D analysis of perturbations shows - there is a ghost in the scalar sector of the gravitational field - ghost  negative sign in kinetic term (negative energy densities) The ghost makes the quantum vacuum unstable This ghost is from 5D gravity * It is not apparent in the background Recent work: claimed that a higher codimension generalization of the DGP model is free of ghost instabilities Recent work: DGP ruled out due to structure formation(?!)

  32. 5. Summary:The simplest models fail • f(R) and DGP – simplest in their class – simplest modified gravity models • both fail because of their scalar degree of freedom: • f(R) strongly violates solar system constraints • DGP has a ghost in 5D gravity • Either GR is the correct theory on large scales • Or Modified gravity is more complicated THEORY: find a ghost-free generalized DGP ? PHENOMENOLOGY: model-independent tests of the failure of GR ?

  33. Some conclusions • Observations imply acceleration • Theory cannot satisfactorily explain it • Simplest model LCDM is the best we have • GR with dynamical DE – no natural model • Modifications to GR – dark gravity: * theory gives no natural model * simple f(R) model “fails” solar system test * simplest braneworld model DGP has a ghost • Theorists need to keep exploring * better models * better observational tests (model-independent?)

More Related