50 likes | 69 Views
Explore how misplaced reliance and varying interpretations affect legal rulings. Discover strategies for navigating conflicting court opinions and evolving public policy in complex legal cases.
E N D
CHAPTER 13COUNTERANALYSIS COUNTERANALYSIS TECHNIQUES-- CASE LAW
TECHNIQUES--CASE LAW • RELIANCE MISPLACED--KEY FACT DIFFERENCE • RELIANCE MISPLACED--RULE OF LAW/PRINCIPLE DOES NOT APPLY
TECHNIQUES--CASE LAW • COURT OPINION SUBJECT TO DIFFERENT INTERPRETATION • RULE/PRINCIPLE ADOPTED IN OPINION RELIED ON IS NOT UNIVERSALLY FOLLOWED
TECHNIQUES--CASE LAW • OPINION PRESENTS SEVERAL SOLUTIONS--ONE URGED IS NOT MANDATORY OR IS NOT BEST CHOICE
TECHNIQUES--CASE LAW • POSITION RELIED ON NO LONGER REPRESENTS SOUND PUBLIC POLICY • OTHER RELEVANT CASES DO NOT SUPPORT POSITION ADOPTED IN CASE