140 likes | 262 Views
Chapter 17: Censorship. Should censorship be used in any circumstances? What about obscenity or hate speech? Does censorship destroy art, or does some measure of restraint actually make art better?
E N D
Chapter 17: Censorship • Should censorship be used in any circumstances? What about obscenity or hate speech? • Does censorship destroy art, or does some measure of restraint actually make art better? • What are some ways that the public could have more of a say in what gets put on movie screens?
Chapter 17: Censorship • Case 75: The Voice of America • Case 76: Fencing the Net • Case 77: Frontal Assault • Case 78: Life Stinks
Case 75: The Voice of America • Facts – Empirical Definition • Values • Principles • Loyalties
The rapper, Eminem, has become extremely popular. But is his message socially responsible? • Do artists such as Eminem have a responsibility to society? • Should artists have to be accountable? • What can artists to to present a better message to their audience without compromising their art?
Case 75: Additional links Eminem.com – The rapper’s website. The Paradox of Eminem: Will the Real Slim Shady Please Stand Up? – A look at Eminem – His life, work, and the controversy surrounding him. Eminem Photo Gallery – A gallery of Eminem pictures. The Eminem Syndrome – Article on Eminem’s negative social influence on society. The Voice of America – Rolling Stone article on Eminem and how his music is sweeping, and defining, America.
Case 76: Fencing the Net • Facts – Empirical Definition • Values • Principles • Loyalties
Several acts in the past years have tried to control what children can view in public places. They have met with much resistance. • Does the government have a right to censor if it is in the best interest of the children? Or should the parent decide what the best interest is? • How could Rawls curtain be used to obtain a fair result for everyone?
Case 76: Additional links Watchdogs launch attack on filter law – Report on the challenges to the Children’s Internet Protection Act. Children’s Internet Protection Act – Actual text of the act. Censorship in a Box: Why Blocking Software Is Wrong for Public Libraries – The ACLU’s position on filtering software in libraries. American Library Association Is No Friend of Our Children – Supports CIPA and accuses the American Library Association of not having the best interests of children at heart.
Case 77: Frontal Assault • Facts – Empirical Definition • Values • Principles • Loyalties
Stormfront is a white supremacist site. This site and others like it are a new way of spreading hate to the world. • There is not doubt that hate speech is a terrible thing, but should hate sites be censored? • What is the best way to overcome hate speech and vehicles used to spread this message, such as Stormfront?
Case 77: Additional links Stormfront – The white supremacist’s homepage. Father and son team on hate site – Article on Don Black, his son, and their website, Stormfront. Don Black: White Pride World Wide – Article that exposes Don Black and his website as hate mongers. Internet and First Amendment – Does not support hate speech but also does not support censoring hate speech on the internet.
Case 78: Life Stinks • Facts – Empirical Definition • Values • Principles • Loyalties
Many people criticize how movies have become far more objectionable. At left are some of the ones that draw criticism. • How could the golden mean be used to ensure a reasonable solution to this conflict over the content of movies? • How can we avoid returning the the old production code, yet at the same time please those who say movies are to extreme?
Case 78: Additional links Censorship in Hollywood – A history of censorship in Hollywood. The Motion Picture Production Code of 1930 – Text of the production code that governed Hollywood for years. Of Black Centaurettes, Twin Towers, and Political Correctness: The Question of Censorship – An extensive history of film censorship and its pros and cons. ‘It Is So Sad to Just Accept’ – One controversial filmmaker’s views on censorship in Hollywood. Guarding against 'Hollywood' Values – Article that blasts Hollywood for its non-family friendly values.