210 likes | 379 Views
Sea Level Rise and Extreme Events. Bangkok, October 2012. Climate Change Projected to Cause Sea Levels to Rise. Warmer seas will expand (IPCC 2007) Likely effect 40-100 cm by 2100 Melting ice on land can also raise sea levels (IPCC 2007)
E N D
Sea Level Rise and Extreme Events Bangkok, October 2012
Climate Change Projected to Cause Sea Levels to Rise • Warmer seas will expand (IPCC 2007) • Likely effect 40-100 cm by 2100 • Melting ice on land can also raise sea levels (IPCC 2007) • Big concern is Greenland which could cause sea levels to rise several meters
Primary Impact is Coastal Infrastructure • Rising seas will inundate coastal infrastructure and coastal land • Primary loss is infrastructure • Adaptations • Soft and dynamic ecosystems based responses • Move infrastructure inland • Build hard structures (walls) to protect • Raise structures
Economic Analysis • Comparing value of lost infrastructure (inundation) with cost of protection (sea walls), economic analysis suggests it is worthwhile protecting dense urban developments (Yohe et al 1996) • Economic, environmental and social costs/benefits of rural lands will need to be examined; potential trade offs in protecting urban/rural land; equity issues • Faster SLR, earlier adaptation needed and more frequent and more costly improvements
Example: Location with High Economic Value Infrastructure/Low economic value lands • Compare value lost from inundation to cost of sea walls • Examine urban buildings, beaches, marshes, and mangroves • Suggests worth protecting buildings and high valued beaches • Not worth protecting low valued beaches, marshes, and mangroves if sea level rise over 0.6m
Extreme Events • Storms: tropical cyclones, extra tropical storms, thunderstorms, tornadoes, hail • Extremes: flooding, drought, heat waves, cold spells • Lead to economic damages (USD) and deaths • Climate change may exacerbate impacts
Projecting Changes in Extreme Event Outcomes • As GDP and populations increase, the damages from many extreme events will increase- more in harm’s way • As income increases, deaths are likely to fall- society and people take precautions
Projecting Climate Change Impact on Extreme Events • Unclear how climate change will alter local storms • Higher temperatures and precipitation will increase mean values • Unclear how climate change will alter the distribution of precipitation and temperature around the new mean • Some evidence that intensity of tropical cyclones will increase
Tropical Cyclones • Examine 4 climate models in 2100 • Examine how climate scenarios affect tropical cyclones • Calculate damage per cyclone • Estimate change in damage
Estimate Climate Impacts • Calculate future baseline damages (current climate) • Calculate future damages with future climate • Subtract baseline from future damages with future climate to get net climate impact
Climate Change Damages in AsiaFrom Tropical Cyclones in 2100 Billion USD/yr
Increased Intensity • Not clear that the frequency of tropical cyclones will change • Some support for increasing intensity of largest storms • Currently, 10% worst storms cause 90% of damage from tropical cyclones • With climate change, 10% worst storms may cause 93% of damage
Conclusions SLR • Moderate sea level rise is extremely likely but can be relatively cheaply adapted to over time • Sea level rise from 2-5 meters, although less likely, would be more difficult to manage and would require a combination of defense and retreat
Conclusions-Extreme Events • Frequent small storms are reasonably easy to manage with early warning systems and moderate precautions (building codes, hard structures) • Cat 4-5 tropical cyclones are more difficult • Costly to protect against powerful storm • Low benefit since they occur locally only once in 100 or 1000 years
Extreme Events Continued • Food aid has been a very successful adaptation to droughts reducing deaths dramatically • Deaths from most extreme events are falling as countries get wealthier