50 likes | 66 Views
Important information on submitting essays before the deadline, criteria for point deductions, preferred topics, and evaluation standards for economic argumentation. Choose from paper summaries, book analyses, or policy topics.
E N D
Information about essays • The deadline for essays: MARCH 16, 2008 • Missing the deadline costs 2 point per day • Send the essay to me. I try to confirm receiving your essay in 24 hours. Include your name and the course title (using the wrong title costs you 1 points) etc. • Essay: 3-10 pages. • You can choose your topic in so far it is loosely related to the subject matter of the course • Can be part of your thesis or seminar work
Try to be as coherent and clear as possible • Preferably use economic argumentation, correct economic and legal concepts • - e.g. Inappropriate title of the course: -1 points • Do not use jargon if not needed
Suggestion 1: Summarize a scientific paper on IPRs. Tell me the paper with your own words. Evaluate the analysis and results critically in the light of real world or other literature. • Note that the technical level of scientific papers vary a lot. Choose a level that suits to you. But the more challenging paper you choose, the easier it is to gain points • Journal of Economic Perspectives is non-technical and excellent (e.g. Spring 2005 issue) • American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings are relatively non-technical, relatively excellent and extremely short • Law and management journals are often non-technical. The same applies to Research Policy
Suggestion 2: Summarize a book or larger body of work • The books by Jaffe & Lerner, Rivette & Kline are non-technical and excellent, and short for a book. • You can also summarize a chapter from Scotchmer’s book that is not required for the exam. • A recent (September 2006) special issue in Journal of Economic Surveys could also work • A recent WP on the objectives of the EPO by Guido Friebel et al. www.idei.fr
Suggestion 3: Choose a policy or management topic. Analyze it in the light of literature and real-world/empirical evidence • Pool with suggestion 1. Search for a suitable paper of the topic and summarize it. • Pool with suggestion 2. Search for a suitable larger body of work dealing with the topic and summarize it. • e.g.: • - Piracy and music industry. Special issue in Journal of Law and Economics, April 2006. Summarize one paper from there (option 1) or the whole issue (option 2) • - Open source: Lerner & Tirole, JIE-02, JEP-05, Lakhani & Von Hippel ResPol-03, Evans&Wolf Harvard Business Review -05 , Maurer&Scotchmer-06, etc….