1 / 24

Quantifier Exchange

Quantifier Exchange. What to do when a - precedes a quantifier. Quantifier Exchange. 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A $x(Hx>-Ix) GOAL. Quantifier Exchange. 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O.

bena
Download Presentation

Quantifier Exchange

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Quantifier Exchange What to do when a - precedes a quantifier.

  2. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A $x(Hx>-Ix) GOAL

  3. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O

  4. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) -(Ha>-Ia) 3 $O ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O ILLEGAL! Rules apply to main connectives only!

  5. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  6. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- Not all people are tall = Some people are not tall

  7. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -#x = $x- Not some people are tall = all people are not tall

  8. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  9. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE The part after the quantifier stays the same. ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  10. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE ??? TILT ??? #x without & next! ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  11. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE ??? TILT ??? #x without & next! Not to worry! We have -(Hx>-Ix) here. ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  12. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  13. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  14. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  15. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O What to do with this step? ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  16. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O 8) Ha&Ia 5 AR ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  17. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O 8) Ha&Ia 5 AR 9) Ha 8 &O 10) Ia 8 &O ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  18. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O 8) Ha&Ia 5 AR 9) Ha 8 &O 10) Ia 8 &O 11) Ga 6, 9 >O 12) -Ia 7,11 >O ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  19. Quantifier Exchange 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O 8) Ha&Ia 5 AR 9) Ha 8 &O 10) Ia 8 &O 11) Ga 6, 9 >O 12) -Ia 7,11 >O 13) Ia&-Ia 10,12 &I 14) $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-13 -O Quantifier Exchange: -$x = #x- -#x = $x-

  20. A Fancy Trick 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O How to use -(Ha>-Ia)? ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O

  21. A Fancy Trick 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O 8) Ha>-Ia 6,7 CH ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O A>B B>C A>C CHain

  22. A Fancy Trick 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O 8) Ha>-Ia 6,7 CH ?&-? ?,? &I $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-? -O

  23. A Fancy Trick 1) $x(Hx>Gx) A 2) $x(Gx>-Ix) A 3) -$x(Hx>-Ix) PA 4) #x-(Hx>-Ix) 3 QE 5) -(Ha>-Ia) 4 #O 6) Ha>Ga 1 $O 7) Ga>-Ia 2 $O 8) Ha>-Ia 6,7 CH 9) (Ha>-Ia)&-(Ha>-Ia) 8,5 &I 10) $x(Hx>-Ix) 3-9 -O

  24. QE Strategy It is a good idea to apply rules in the following order: QE #O $O For more click here

More Related