E N D
1. AFA Asthma Research SymposiumClinical Therapeutics: children Peter van Asperen
Macintosh Professor of Paediatric Respiratory Medicine
Head, Department of Respiratory Medicine
The Children’s Hospital at Westmead
2. Clinical Therapeutics: childrenWhat we have learnt from research? Oral corticosteroids for acute asthma
- effect of phenotype/age on response
Leukotriene antagonists for intermittent wheeze
- regular versus intermittent use
Combination therapy
- current evidence for its role versus its use in paediatric asthma management
3. Oral Corticosteroids for Acute AsthmaEffect of Phenotype/Age on Response ED & in hospital Oral Corticosteroid (OCS)
- OCS effective for children hospitalised for asthma
(Smith et al Cochrane Review 2003)
- OCS effective for ED treatment of acute asthma
(Rowe et al Cochrane Review 2001)
- OCS not significantly different to placebo for ED treatment of pre-schoolers with viral induced wheezing ( Panikar et al NEJM 2009)
Parent initiated oral corticosteroids (PIOCS)
- PIOCS not effective for childhood intermittent (viral) wheezing
(Oomen et al Lancet 2003;Vuillermin et al Cochrane Review 2006)
- PIOCS effective for 6-14 yr olds with acute asthma – symptoms, HR utilisatn & school absence (Vuillermin et al BMJ 2010)
4. Leukotriene Antagonists for Intermittent WheezeRegular Versus intermittent use Regular LTRA’s (Bisgaard et al AJRCCM 2005)
- RDBPCT Montelukast 4&5 mg over 12 mths in 549 2-5 yr olds
- exacerbations M (1.60/pt/yr) vs P (2.34/pt/yr) [p<0.001] & OCS use (p<0.05)
Intermittent LTRA’s (Robertson et al AJRCCM 2007)
- RDBPCT Montelukast 4&5mg (min 7 days) in 201 2-14 yr olds
- significantly reduced HC utilisation (OR 0.65 95%CI 0.47,0.89)
- significantly improved patient & parent QOL (p<0.0001)
Intermittent LTRA’s (Bacharier et al JACI 2008)
- RDBPCT Mont 4mg vs Bud 1mg bd vs Placebo for 7 days in 238 1-5 yr olds
- no diff EFD’s, HC utilisatn or OCS but active Rx reduced severity
Short course LTRA’s verus Prednisolone (Schuh et al J Ped 2010)
- RDBNIT Mont 4,5 or 10mg vs Pred 1mg/kg for 5 days in 130 2-17 yr olds D/C from ED following initial treatment
- Treatment failure in 7.9% Pred gp vs 22.4% Mont gp (95% CI 2.4%-26.5%)
MCRCT maint. LTRA vs interm. LTRA vs placebo (TBA)
5. Combination Therapy in Paediatric AsthmaCurrent Indications & Prescribing LABAs can be prescribed in children in combination with ICS (sal > 5 yrs; form > 12 yrs) if poor control
limited evidence of efficacy & safety
FDC 40% of prescribed preventer meds in 2-14yr olds
40% FDC scripts not preceded by ICS or FDC 2yrs prior
60% 4-14yr olds initiated on FDC-1 script in 12mths
50% 4-14 yr olds continuing FDC-1-2 scripts in 12 mths
20% pre-schoolers with Dx asthma receive FDC (Phillips et al MJA 2007; 187:10)
6. Combination Therapy in Paediatric Asthma Evidence for Efficacy(Cochrane Review 2009 Issue 3 CD 007949) Total of 25 trials representing 31 control-intervention comparisons involving 5,572 children who met inclusion criteria
Mean age 10 yrs male predominance – no studies < 4yrs
Two interventions examined
- ICS + LABA vs ICS (same dose) (n=24)
- ICS + LABA vs ICS x 2 (n=7)
Majority of patients inadequately controlled on ICS (19/24 & 6/7)
Primary outcome - exacerbation requiring systemic steroids
Secondary outcomes – hospital admission, symptoms, reliever use, QOL, lung function & adverse events
7. Combination Therapy in Paediatric Asthma Evidence for Efficacy(Cochrane Review 2009 Issue 3 CD 007949) ICS + LABA vs ICS (same dose)
- 24 control-intervention comparisons in 4,625 children
- no diff exacerbations (RR 0.92[0.60,1.40] n=8), hospitalisations (RR1.65[0.83,3.25] n=6), symptom free days, reliever use, QOL or adverse events
- improved FEV1 0.08 (0.06,0.11) litres n=9
ICS +LABA vs ICS x 2
- 7 control-intervention comparisons in 1048 children
- no diff exacerbations (RR 1.50[0.65,3.48] n=3), hospitalisations
(RR 2.21[0.74,6.64] n=2); insufficient data for other 20 outcomes
- improved am PEF 7.55(3.57,11.53) L/min n=4 & pm PEF 5.5(1.21,9.79) n=3 and better growth 1.2(0.72,1.7) cm/yr n=2
8. Combination Therapy in Paediatric Asthma BADGER Study(Lemanske et al NEJM 2010) RDBCOS in 182 (480 enrolled) children aged 6-17 yrs with asthma uncontrolled on FP 100mcg bd
2-8 wk run in followed by random order 16 wk Rx with FP 250 bd, FP 100/50 bd, FP 100 bd + M 5/10mg
LABA step up significantly more likely to provide best response (prednisolone use, ACD &FEV1) but many children responded best to ICS or M step up - need to monitor & adjust therapy
Asthma control only predictor of response – better controlled more likely to respond best to LABA
Long term safety of LABA not addressed
10. Clinical Therapeutics: childrenWhat further research is required? MORE PAEDIATRIC CLINICAL TRIALS
- Wheeze phenotype & genotype specific trials
- LABA/Combination therapy trials
- Novel Medications - parallel paediatric trials
OPTIMISING MEDICATION USE
- Medication prescribing
- Medication adherence
- Medication delivery
OTHER THERAPEUTIC INTERVENTIONS
- CAM, Allergen Avoidance/Exposure, Education
- Asthma Prevention - Immunomodulation, Virus protection