250 likes | 452 Views
Corporate governance is: A mechanism that encourages efficient use of resources and equally demands responsibility for managing these resources (Sir Adrian Cadbery)A set of internal mechanisms to lead the company and control it (OECD)The system of interaction of a company's management, board of directors and shareholders designed to ensure maximization of the company's value and that all financial stakeholders receive their fair share of the company's earnings (Standard
E N D
1. Governance Services
Standard & Poors
2. Corporate Governance Score Measuring corporate governance performance
3. Investors are the CGS target audience
4. CGS can
Push the share price and liquidity up by providing additional assurance to investors
Decrease the cost of debt and equity, diversify the sources of funding
Reduce the costs of D&O insurance policies
Help to improve the image for clients and investors; build up reputation and corporate history
Provide companies with benchmarks for internal change
particularly if an enhanced comparative analytical report is produced in the framework of Corporate Governance Evaluation, or CGE Reasoning behind a companys decision to receive a CGS
5. 200 institutional investors (collectively responsible for some USD 2 trillion of assets under management)
85% - put corporate governance on a par with financial indicators when evaluating investment decisions
78% - willing to pay a premium for a well-governed company
Premium for good corporate governance may be as high as 40% (see graph on the next slide)
Global Investor Opinion SurveyMcKinsey & Co. (July 2002)
6. Global Investor Opinion SurveyMcKinsey & Co. (July 2002)
Average premium investors would pay for a well-governed company by country and region
7. Corporate Governance and Equity Prices
9. Relation between CGS and value: Deutsche Bank study, 50 emerging-markets companies
13. S&P Corporate Governance Score a global instrument
14. Interpretation of Scores
15. List of public Corporate Governance Scores (CGS) in Russia
16. List of public Corporate Governance Scores (CGS) and Governance Assessments (GA) assigned outside Russia in 2001-2005
18. CGS evaluates the effectiveness of co-ordination mechanisms between management, board of directors and shareholders
19. Key analytical issues:1. Ownership structure and external influence Transparency of ownership
Disclosure of beneficiaries of large blocks, including their external interests
Management shareholdings
Group structure, affiliate parties
Concentration and influence of ownership and external stakeholders
Clear and balanced influence
Existence of conflicts of interests of different shareholder groups (cross-subsidization, transfer pricing)
If that exists, how it is balanced (decisions on related party transactions)
Influence of external stakeholders (federal government, local authorities)
20. Key Analytical issues (cont.):2. Shareholder rights and stakeholder relations Shareholder meetings and voting procedures
Ease of access
Quality of materials provided
Voting procedures and discussions
Ownership rights and takeover defenses
Guarantees of ownership rights
Dividend policy and discipline
Mechanisms impeding change of ownership
Stakeholder relations
Social policy
Ecological policy
Labor relations
21. Key Analytical issues (cont.):3. Transparency, Disclosure and Audit Content of public disclosure
Financial reporting standards, completeness of disclosure
Non-financial information (assets, strategy)
Analysis of risks
Management and director remuneration
Auditor compensation
Non-financial reporting (GRI standards)
Timing of, and access to, public disclosure
Timeline
Ways of disclosure, non-discriminating access
Timeliness of event-driven commentaries
The audit process
Auditor selection process
Scope of services provided by the auditor
Independent oversight (Audit Committee)
Internal controls
22. Key Analytical issues (cont.): 4. Board structure and effectiveness Board structure and independence
Balance of interests
Independent directors
Skill mix and personal qualities
Committees
Role and effectiveness of the board
Oversight and audit (related-party transactions, material transactions, investments)
Strategic planning
Risk management policies (incl. non-financial risks)
Evaluations of efficiency, management nomination procedures
Director and senior executive remuneration
Adequacy of director remuneration policy; evaluation procedures
Principles and forms of remuneration (BSC, KPI system)
23. Russian companies CGS and their components
24. Selected comparative governance data on Russian companies