1 / 20

The earliest phases of Super Star Clusters – a high spatial resolution view

The earliest phases of Super Star Clusters – a high spatial resolution view. Daniel Schaerer (Geneva Observatory, OMP Toulouse) Leticia Martin-Hernandez (Geneva Observatory) Marc Sauvage (CEA Saclay/Paris) Els Peeters (NASA Ames) Motivation: * importance for extragalactic studies

beryl
Download Presentation

The earliest phases of Super Star Clusters – a high spatial resolution view

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The earliest phases of Super Star Clusters – a high spatial resolution view Daniel Schaerer (Geneva Observatory, OMP Toulouse) Leticia Martin-Hernandez (Geneva Observatory) Marc Sauvage (CEA Saclay/Paris) Els Peeters (NASA Ames) Motivation: * importance for extragalactic studies * SSC formation / properties Questions Results from mid-IR + radio observations Future studies  Martin-Hernandez et al. 2005, A&A 429, 449 + paper submitted

  2. Mid-IR spectra and spectral diagnostics of (UC)HII regions and galaxies ISO spectra: Galactic (UC)HII regions Peeters et al. (2002) Starbusts galaxies and AGN e.g. Sturm et al. (2001)  Fine structure lines (ionised ISM) -> PAH features -> Dust continuum

  3. Mid-IR spectra and spectral diagnostics of (UC)HII regions and galaxies « Global » PAH strength or [NeIII]/[NeII] line ratio (+others) used e.g. as diagnostics of: - starburst versus AGN nature - IMF (upper limit), SF duration Genzel et al. (1998) Thornley et al. (2000)

  4. Mid-IR spectra and spectral diagnostics of (UC)HII regions and galaxies BUT: « Global » PAH strength or [NeIII]/[NeII] line ratio (+ other) potentially flawed by large aperture and related effects! - strong spatial variations of PAH features (destroyed close to ionising sources) - different contributions to low excitation lines (diffuse ISM, HII regions, SSCs) - strong dominance of few/individual SSCs in some cases  Interpretation of « global » large aperture spectra non trivial.  Modeling as single HII region (with « average » ionisation parameter) inadequate

  5. Mid-IR spectra and spectral diagnostics of (UC)HII regions and galaxies ISO SWS: ~14x20’’ apertures  Interpretation of « global » large aperture spectra non trivial.  Modeling as single HII region (with « average » ionisation parameter) inadequate Need for high spatial resolution observations !

  6. Earliest phases of SSC Hidden, ultra-dense, optically thick (radio) clusters now recognised as precursors of « normal » SSCs (Kobulnicky, Johnson, Beck, Turner… 1999 + later) Open questions: * Stellar content ? * IMF ? Best probes for upper mass cut-off of IMF! * Ages ? lifetimes ?  Most direct diagnostics: fine structure emission lines + photoionisation modeling Kobulnicky & Johnson (1999)

  7. NGC 5253 (prototypical starburst) * Magellanic irregular * Distance~3. 25Mpc (1’’=16pc) * UV-optical: many clusters + diffuse light * (mid)-IR + radio emission dominated by single source!  hidden SSC / supernebula UV (HST) Near-IR and radio (VLA) Turner & Beck (2004) mid-IR (Keck) Gorjian et al. (2001) Near-IR (HST) Alonso-Herrero et al. (2003)

  8. The supernebula in NGC 5253 * Brα/Brγ: 0.8-2.0 mag extinction – AV~18 mag * Brγ line and free-free flux: ~2000 O7V stars in 0.8 pc radius ~7000 O7V in central 20 pc * Very high resolution radio data: core size ~99 x 39 mas! (1.8x0.7 pc FWHM)  size constraint for modeling (cf. below)! Smaller than core radius of Galactic Globular Clusters * Kinematics (radio rec.lines, Brγ ): vobs ~75 km/s FWHM - Too small to be related to expansion - If virialised motions: vobs ~< vescape(cluster)  gravitationally bound cluster !? Mass ~(5-30)x105 Msun! radio (VLA) Keck Turner & Beck (2004), Turner et al. (2003)

  9. TIMMI2 mid-IR observations of the supernebula in NGC 5253 ESO: TIMMI2@3.6m longslit spectroscopy (1-1.2’’ slit) * Source unresolved with 1.1’’ – negligible slit losses Bulk of « high »-excitation emission ([ArIII], [SIV] – 27.6, 34.8 eV) observed in large apertures are from supernebula  Only ~20% of [NeII] (21.6 eV) from SSC – rest « diffuse » flux ratio TIMMI2/ISO aperture 1. Martin-Hernandez et al. (2005) 0.

  10. Photoionisation modeling of supernebula in NGC 5253 * Observational constraints: - outer radius from radio [Rout =0.8 pc] - electron density from radio continuum: ~5*104 cm-3 (~UCHII) - composition: ~1/3 solar (optical spectra, also Ne/H of SSC) - Bracketα flux (equivalent to fixing Q0 - Lyc flux) - mid-IR lines (excitation) from TIMMI2 (supernebula) and ISO (upper limits) - NICMOS/HST: EW(Paschenα)  cluster age ~0-6 Myr * Starburst + photoionisation model (Cloudy+Starburst99) -- varying parameters: - cluster age, IMF (slope: Salpeter+, Mup=100, 50, 30 Msun) - ionisation parameter U= Q0/(4πRin2εnHc)constrained by ε≤1 (filling factor), i.e. x≤(1-b/R3outn2e)1/3 where x=Rin/Rout  Rin<0.6 pc, and 0.6≤ε≤1

  11. Photoionisation modeling of supernebula in NGC 5253 – main results Fiducial model predicts TOO high excitation ! Solutions: a) age ~5-6 Myr and standard IMF (Mup=100 Msun) b) low upper mass cut-off (Mup<50 Msun) + young age (<4 Myr) in agreement with lack of SN signatures

  12. Photoionisation modeling of supernebula in NGC 5253 – main results Fiducial model predicts TOO high excitation ! Solutions: a) age ~5-6 Myr and standard IMF (Mup=100 Msun) b) low upper mass cut-off (Mup<50 Msun) + young age (<4 Myr) Other possibilities: - outer radius ~4.5 pc – OK but ~6 x radio size! - steeper IMF – NO - metal enrichment: OK if solar (but 1/3 observed !) - internal dust: opposite effect! NO - matter bounded vs ionisation bounded nebula: opposite effect! - Density gradients: impossible to reconcile all mid-IR lines

  13. Photoionisation modeling of supernebula in NGC 5253 – implications a) age ~5-6 Myr and standard IMF (Mup=100 Msun): « old hidden cluster » - possible to confine region for that long ? self gravity ? (Tan 2004) - but absence of SN puzzling! Have to hide ~100 SN/Myr after >~ 3 Myr - generally embedded SSC phase estimated to ~10-15% of O star lifetime (e.g. Kobulnicky & Johnson 1999) b) low upper mass cut-off (Mup<50 Msun) + young age (<4 Myr): - so far no indication for low Mup! - due to strong gravitational potential ? Other explanations?  Unique object ? General result ??

  14. Other TIMMI2 observations – NGC 3256 TIMMI2 (Martin-Hernandez et al. 2005) Radio (Neff et al. 2003) NGC 3256, LIRG with double nucleus (D=37Mpc, 1’’=176 pc) - 5’’ separation – mid-IR spectrum of N and S: * resolved + probably multiple SSCs  inappropriate for photoionisation mdeling * PAHs detected in both

  15. Other TIMMI2 observations – He 2-10 Radio + N-band Vacca et al. (2002) BCD, WR galaxy (D~9.0 Mpc, 1’’=43.6pc) * 5 compact optically thick ultra-dense HII regions (Kobulnicky & J 1999, Johnson & K 2003) * N-band emission follows radio (Vacca et al. 2002) * mid-IR line emission resolved (>~1.1’’) and extended * PAHs present in regions A and C * radio regions partly multiple (NACO/VLT: Cabanac et al. 2005) TIMMI2 (Martin-Hernandez et al. 2005) V (HST) + N-band Vacca et al. (2002)

  16. Other TIMMI2 observations – II Zw 40 Compact dwarf galaxy (D=9.2Mpc, 1’’=44.6pc) * radio: presence of 1 compact (<1’’) but multiple opt.thick HII region * mid-IR spectrum: slightly resolved Bulk of 12 μm flux (IRAS) from <1.1’’! * ~all [SIV] from compact region  photoionisation model for this region… * No PAH features Radio: Beck et al. (2002) IRAS flux

  17. Other TIMMI2 observations – II Zw 40 Photoionisation model for compact region in II Zw 40 using TIMMI2 and ISO line fluxes + radio size: * too high excitation predicted, as for NGC 5253 supernebula!  same tentative conclusion on IMF and age ! Multiplicity: conclusions likely unchanged

  18. The importance of high spatial resolution * NGC 3256, NGC 5253: 70-80% of [NeII] emission (low excitation) from large aperture (diffuse, non SSC) * Higher excitation lines emitted in more compact regions (as expected…) * 1 compact (<~1.1’’) source containing (likely) all large aperture flux (ISO/SWS): II Zw 40 * similar analysis for PAH features … Martin-Hernandez et al. (2005)

  19. …more/better observations need 8m telescope  VISIR/VLT High spatial resolution study of young starbursts/ hidden SSCs with VISIR and radio. Comparison with larger aperture observations (Spitzer, ISO): - Schaerer, Brandl (Spitzer), Martin-Hernandez, Sauvage, Schmitt (VLA)

  20. Conclusions * mid-IR fine structure line observations provide sole probe of stellar content (IMF, age …) of embedded super star clusters (SSCs) * high spatial resolution observations (and size measurements) crucial for interpretation and photoionisation modeling of embedded SSCs * TIMMI2/ESO observations (+radio) of embedded SSC in NGC 5253: indications for a) “old age” (~5-6 Myr) + standard IMF or b) low upper mass cut-off (Mup<50 Msun) + young age * Possible other such case: SSC in II Zw 40 * More systematic study of embedded SSCs ongoing with VISIR/VLT, Spitzer + radio … * Spectral diagnostics using large aperture observations: mix emission from physically unrelated areas/components (diffuse ISM, SSC …) – BEWARE !

More Related