1 / 41

Observation of a threshold enhancement in the p  invariant mass spectrum

Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 , 112002 (2004) Cited 28 times. Observation of a threshold enhancement in the p  invariant mass spectrum. H.X. Yang ( BES Collaboration ) IHEP yanghx@mail.ihep.ac.cn Oct.28 - Nov.01, 2006, Guilin. Outline. Introduction Features of signal and event selection

bianca-atkins
Download Presentation

Observation of a threshold enhancement in the p  invariant mass spectrum

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 112002 (2004)Cited 28 times Observation of a threshold enhancement in the p invariant mass spectrum H.X. Yang (BES Collaboration) IHEP yanghx@mail.ihep.ac.cn Oct.28 - Nov.01, 2006, Guilin

  2. Outline • Introduction • Features of signal and event selection • Reliability of the result • Summary

  3. Introduction

  4. The Beijing Electron Positron Collider L ~ ~51030 /cm2s at J/ peak Ecm~2-5 GeV

  5. BESII Detector VC: xy = 100 m TOF: T = 180 ps  counter: r= 3 cm MDC: xy = 220 m BSC: E/E= 22 % z = 5.5 cm dE/dx= 8.5 %  = 7.9 mr B field: 0.4 T p/p=1.78%(1+p2) z = 3.1 cm

  6. World J/ and (2S) Samples (106) Largest from BES J/ (2S) 2002 2001

  7. Motivation • The enhancement near the ppbar mass threshold observed by BESII in could be interpreted as a ppbar bound state (multi-quark meson). • The new observation of BESII as well as new resonances observed by other experiments makes the searches for multiquark states become a very hot topic of high energy physics field. • It is of special importance to search for possible baryon-antibaryon resonances or bound states.

  8. Strong enhancement near the threshold of Data MC (Phase Space) 11 Data Data

  9. S-wave BW fit results • M = (2075 +/- 12) MeV Γ = (90 +/- 35) MeV BR = (1.18+/- 0.28)*10**(-4) • About 7σ statistical significance

  10. Features of signal and event selection

  11. Features of signal (I) Signal means • Λ signal (very strong constraint) After selection, the clear Λ signal in data shows high purity of signal. Data MC

  12. Features of signal (II) • Four charged tracks, no photon, no pi0 • Three heavy particles: p, pbar, Kaon • So kinematics (with correct mass assignment) provides very strong constraint in the event selection, and in thekinematic fit can reject most background events.

  13. Key points in event selection Keep • High purity of signal ( Λ mass as a control) • Efficiency as high as possible • Systematic uncertainties from selection criteria as small as possible Low momentum feature should be considered

  14. Event Selection • Four good charged tracks ( Pxy>50 MeV) • PID: Kaon-ID and at least one proton-ID • 4-C kinematic fit PID information is used in the mass assignment • Remove events with combined information of Emiss and Mpk_miss no requirement on Λ vertex reconstruction

  15. High Purity of Signal after Selection • It can be shown by the clean Λ signal • MC background study: only 1~2% Dominantly from  Data Data/MC

  16. Strong enhancement near the threshold of Phase Space

  17. Observed in both ofand

  18. S-wave BW fit results P-wave BW fit results • M = (2075 12  5) MeV • Γ = (90  35  9) MeV • BR = (1.18  0.28  0.4) 10-4 • M = (2044 17) MeV • Γ = (20  45) MeV • 2/d.o.f = 32.5/26 • 2/d.o.f = 31.1/26 • ~ 7σ statistical significance high L hypotheses fail The systematic errors are carefully studied in S-wave case.

  19. Reliability of the result Extensive and careful checks!

  20. Similar enhancement also observed in Fix the parameters, 4 away from phase space.

  21. Is the enhancement from N* or Λ*? • Hard to understand why N* or Λ* only contribute to very small phase space

  22. Other checks • Can the enhancement be interpreted as known PDG particles? NO • MC Input/Output test: check systematic uncertainties of fitting bias – is small. • Other fits (L=1, 2, 3): P-wave fine, other failed

  23. The distribution is consistent with S-Wave • MC (phase space) also show non-uniform and asymmetric distribution of . • The enhancement is consistent with S wave. Err: Data His: MC

  24. 重要科学意义 • 这一研究成果与新发现的质子－反质子奇异结构具有同样重要意义：有可能是一个多夸克态粒子（六夸克态）。 • 自然界已发现的由夸克组成的粒子中的夸克数均为两个或三个，因此发现（多于三个夸克组成的）多夸克态粒子对检验和发展量子色动力学QCD 理论具有非常重要的意义。也将是新的物质存在形式。 • 两个 PRL Referee 均对该文章给予好评。（文章被直接接收） • 被高能所作为重要科研成果对外宣传

  25. PRL Referee 给予好评 • Referee A: … 由于 BES 等实验的多个新发现的共振峰，以及关于五夸克态粒子的争论，使得存在重子－反重子束缚态及多夸克态粒子的问题再次引起极大关注。… • Referee B: 这篇文章研究了关于重子－反重子质量阈值共振结构的重要课题…。BES 是第一个报道质子－反质子阈值增长结构的实验。而这篇文章观测到类似的 质量阈值增长结构，支持了前面的发现结果。…

  26. Summary • We observed an enhancement at 2.08 GeV in the invariant mass spectrum of • Various checks show that the result is robust. • It has been fitted with S-wave B-W function successfully: mass = 2075+/-12+/-5 MeV width=90+/35+/-9 MeV Br=(1.18+/0.28+/-0.40)x10E-4 • It is very unlikely that the enhancement is from pure N* and Λ* interference, although they contribute to Dalitz plot. • A possible multi-quark state candidate

  27. THANK YOU!

  28. Why Dalitz plot not uniform for events DATA MC • This is due to acceptance • It can be shown in distribution, where is the decay angle of p in

  29. Mathematical fit • W/o any constrains, PWA withN* and Λ* can fit data: (S= -997) • However, it needs many unexpected big BRs and many large destructive interferences to cancel these big BRs. • Keep in mind: Ndata=5433

  30. Big BRs Fraction of NdataNevent N*(1900) 3/2+ 108% 5900 N*(2050) 3/2+ 33% 1800 Λ*(1890) 3/2+ 21% 1100 Λ*(1810) 1/2+ 9% 500 Λ*(1800) 1/2- 34% 1900 (1/2- is P-wave decay, which should be suppressed )

  31. Physics constrains (I) • Typically, BR(J/psibaryon anti-baryon) ~ 2x10-3 e.g., BR(J/psi  p pbar) =2.2x10-3 • So, if there is no suppression, the typical number of observed events for one decay mode is: BR(J/psi ΛΛ *)BR(Λ *pK) BR(Λpπ) ε N J/psi = 2x10-3 x0.1 x0.1 x0.6 x5.8x107 ~ 700 events

  32. Physics constrains (II) – near threshold suppression • Phase space ~ p • Angular momentum barrier ~ (p / M J/psi) 2L+1 • If the width is large, some fraction of N* or Λ* cannot be produced. • Global efficiency may be lower.

  33. Physics constrains (III) – from other channels • E.g., Since Λ* decays both to pK and Σπ, and most BRs of them are of the same order, so this channel can provide constrains on Λ*(1520), Λ*(1600), Λ*(1690) production rate. • No clear evidence for strong production of Λ*(1800), Λ*(1810), Λ*(1890). Near threshold suppression is a reasonable estimation.

  34. Estimated Nevent in Ndata Nevent/2 (each decay mode, not include c.c.) N*(1900) 3/2+ ~ 300 -400 N*(2050) 3/2+ ~ 100 -150 Λ*(1890) 3/2+ ~ 100 -150 Λ*(1810) 1/2+ ~ 150 -200 Λ*(1800) 1/2- ~ 20 - 30 (1/2- is P-wave decay, which should be suppressed near threshold)

  35. PWA with constrains and w/o X(2075) • Constrain the Neventof near threshold states ~ 100-200 • The PWA fit cannot reproduce the enhancement near pΛ threshold (S=-900).

  36. PWA with constrains and with X(2075) • Adding X(2075), PWA fit can reproduce the enhancement near pΛ threshold. • Significance of X(2075) >> 5 sigma. (S=-952)

  37. Interference of excited baryons? • PWA fits with pure N* and Λ* can hardly reproduce the enhancement. (with reasonable constrains production rate for excited baryons) • PWA fit with X(2075) can easily reproduce the enhancement with high significance. (independent of constrains) It is unlikely that the enhancement is purely from * and N* interference.

  38. Fit the enhancement in • Fit the similar enhancement in with the same parameters of X(2075) as in J/psi. • The significance of X(2075) in psi’ data is ~4.0 σ. • The similar enhancements in the psi’ data and in the Belle data ( in BpΛπ process ) CANNOT be from N*(2050), Λ*(1890) … interference.

  39. Summary of PWA studies • Reproducing the pΛ threshold enhancement with pure N* and Λ* interferences needs many unexpected big BRs and large destructive interferences. • PWA fits with pure N* and Λ* and with constrains can hardly reproduce the enhancement. • PWA fit with X(2075) can easily reproduce the enhancement (independent of constrains) with high significance. • The similar enhancements in the psi’ data and in the Belle data ( in BpΛπ process ) CANNOT be from N*(2050), Λ*(1890) … interference.

  40. Systematic uncertainties

  41. 被高能所作为重要科研成果对外宣传

More Related