150 likes | 154 Views
This article explores the dilemma faced by managers in dealing with employees' non-work-related internet usage, which leads to significant productivity losses. The article considers the perspective of stakeholders and analyzes two alternatives - enforcement and communication - to address the issue.
E N D
Thinking critically about ethics Managers & communications 林宜宣 9831008 黃瓊葦 9831051 管理學 管科102 4-2組
Background knowledge Employees 69% spend time at non-work-related Web sites 55% send and receive personal e-mails
Background knowledge Younger employees (18~34) 72% check their personal e-mail accounts at work 77% access the Internet at work for personal reasons
Background knowledge • Personal Web surfing was the TOP method of goofing off at work. • These seemly fun and harmless technological distractions cost business. But !!!!! < 54 billion annually!!
Identify dilemma Harmless though these activities may appear to be, the accumulatedloss for business is overwhelming!!!
Consider stakeholders • Stakeholders invest businesses for the purpose of gaining returns • They are profit-minded and would be unlikely to tolerate unnecessary losses • Especially the kind that arose from technological distractions
Consider stakeholders • Managers might have to put more effort into making stakeholders happy • After all, making them happy = invested in business $
Analyze alternatives and consequences Alternatives (1) Enforcement • The most direct way • Prohibit employees for using the Web for personal uses • Punishment for violating the rule • Effective method • E.g. Deduct salary or bonus
Analyze alternatives and consequences Consequences (Enforcement) • Manager might not be liked such harsh and non-negotiable way to get things done is usually unwelcomed. • Moreover, these entertainments that are removed from the employees’ work life can lead to lower work productivity and efficiency.
Analyze alternatives and consequences Alternatives (2) Communications • Having good communication is VERY important • As stated, there is psychological benefit to be gained by letting employees do something to relieve the stress of pressure-packed jobs • By getting managers to have a good TALK with employees
Analyze alternatives and consequences • Make them understand the LIMIT of using work time for personal use or entertainment • BUT also let them know that the manager understands the NEED for such activities Likely that employees will have a better control of their personal time at work WITHOUT feeling unhappy
Analyze alternatives and consequences Consequences (Communications) • Employees might take this loose control for granted • Since there is no STATED RULE of not using the Web for personal uses during work time, employees might not change at all • After all, it does not affect their salaries
Analyze alternatives and consequences • A better way to adopt • Control employee behavior • Motivates employees • Provide release for emotional expressions • Provide information • Etc. Method 1 Communication
Conclusion Communication is a … • More friendly approach • More effective • More likely to solve this manager’s dilemma
The End 謝謝大家!