460 likes | 630 Views
IST IP NOBEL Next generation Optical network for Broadband European Leadership Munich WP4 meeting ( 13th – 15th June 200 5 ) Monika Jäger T-Systems. Munich Meeting Overall Agenda. We are always in room 3, including VPN TF meeting together with WP1 WP4 meetings are
E N D
IST IP NOBEL Next generation Optical network for Broadband European Leadership MunichWP4 meeting (13th – 15thJune 2005) Monika Jäger T-Systems
Munich Meeting Overall Agenda • We are always in room 3, including VPN TF meeting together with WP1 • WP4 meetings are • Monday 1 pm – 6.30 pm • Tuesday 8.30 am – 4.30 pm (possibly also during board meeting up to 6 pm • Wednesday 8.30 am – 12 am • There is a social event on Tuesday starting 6.15 pm
WP4 Meeting Participants • T-Systems Monika, Ute • TILAB Roberto • Alcatel CIT Bela • Alcatel Italia Massimo, Andrea • Ericsson Annikki • Lucent Nederland Abdel • Marconi Comm SpA Filippo • Siemens Martin, Guillaume, Andreas • Telefonica Javier • TeliaSonera Olle Acreo Loa Sant‘Anna Piero, Barbara Telenor Hakon CTTC Carolina, Ricardo, Raul
WP4 meeting agenda • 13th June 1 pm – 6.30 pm room 3 • Introduction 1 pm – 2:30 pm (Monika) • Agenda Bashing • Report Board Meeting • Task Forces and Distribution of Work • Action Items and Open Issues • Planning of III and IV of NOBEL I • Publications • Standardization • Final Report • NOBEL II • Coffee Break 2:30 pm – 3 pm
WP4 meeting agenda • 13th June 1 pm – 6.30 pm room 21 • Signaling Framework TF 3 pm – 4:30 pm (Bela) • Bela: Introduction and status of the TF (5 min) • Monika: MPLS-GMPLS Interworking Issues (20 -30 min) • CTTC: GMPLS-based bidirectional lightpath provisioning in transparent networks • Javi: Signaling Performance and DCN dimensioning (10 min) • Olle: Inter-Carrier E-NNI requirements and solutions, following also discussion in Inter-area and inter-AS routing (with discussion stimulating slide from Hakon) (45 min) • Coffee Break 4:30 pm – 5 pm
WP4 meeting agenda • 13th June 1 pm – 6.30 pm room 21 • Signaling Framework TF 5 pm – 6:30 pm (Bela) • Bela: Policy Based Management for TE • Monika: PCE open issues (5 min) • N.N.: ML TE problem statement and concepts (from IEEE ComMag paper) • ASON - GMPLS convergence requirements document (all) • Discussion D25
WP4 meeting agenda • 14th June 8:30 am – 6 pm room 21 • Implementation TF 8:30 am – 10 am (Martin) • Presentation Partner contributions (60 min) • CTTC: current status of the implementation of the hybrid performance monitoring employed in the OPM task force • Coffee Break 10 am – 10:30 am • Implementation TF 10:30 am – 11 am (Martin) • Discussion D25 (30 min) • Use Cases TF 11 am – 11:30 (Massimo) • Status and next steps • Abdel: fault localization and correlation for transparent network • Discussion D25
WP4 meeting agenda • 14th June 8:30 am – 6 pm room 21 • Information Modeling TF 11:30 am - 12 am (Hakon) • TMF MTNM/MTOSI presentation by Andrea/Massimo (50 min. including Q&A) • Lunch Break 12 am – 1 pm • Information Modeling TF 1 pm – 2:30 pm (Hakon) • Discovery, LMP etc. related attributes and MOCs (20 min) • Routing related attributes and MOCs (20 min) • SCN/DCN related attributes and MOCs (20 min) • Signalling and call related attributes and MOCs (10 min) • Contribution to standardisation (10 min) • Workplan, action points, summary (10 min) • Discussion D25 • Coffee Break 2:30 pm – 3 pm
WP4 meeting agenda • 14th June 8:30 am – 6 pm room 21 • VPN TF 3 pm – 4:30 pm (5 pm) (Javi) • VPN_TF status and overview (5 min) • VPN_TF results at WP1 and WP4 deliverables (10 min) • Broadcasters scenario (30-35 min) (Joachim) • Storage scenario (30-35 min) (Andrea) • GRID scenario (30-35 min) (Annikki) <-- may be moved to parallel session • Conclusions/next steps (5 min) • Discussion D2 • Coffee Break 4:30 pm – 5 pm • Board Meeting 5 pm – 6:00 pm • Social Event 6:15 pm
WP4 meeting agenda • 15th June 8:30 am – 12 am room 21 • Service Issues TF 8 am – 9 am (Piero) • Piero: ASTN enhancement for improved service support (30 min) • Hakon: need for service platform, comparison with NGN • Discussion D25 • Lunch Break 12 am – 1 pm • Closing Plenary 1 pm – 2:30 pm • There may be meetings in the afternoon
Introduction – Goal of this Meeting • NOBEL only 6 months to go • We need to reach the goals • Reach valuable results • According to contract • Document them properly in deliverables • Implement and provide them for tests and demonstrations in WP8 • Disseminate them in publications and standarization
Report on Board Meeting • Status of the project • Deliverables ok • Publications ok • Standardization contributions needed • Training needed • Demonstrations needed • NOBEL book (mainly WP5&6, driven by Alex Stavdas) • Document exchange with PROTAGON (UK Project) • Closing the project • To be continued tomorrow • Tool reporting monthly reports • Meeting colocated with workshop • Delay in financial audit reports earlier next time
Review of D18 and Task Force Activities • D18 (“Conclusions on NM and CP functional scope and standardization approaches; NM and ASON prototype functional scope”) had some small delay because of change of responsibility (Marconi <-> ACIT) • Overview without going into details
D18 - Functional Architecture and Modelling Concepts • Description of general functional architectural issues and modeling concepts • Future work • Might be extended in next deliverable if required or if there are missing topics?
Use Cases TF • D18 contribution to status of UC • Switched connection service • Highly dynamic • Transport oriented • Hybrid • MPLS/ GMPLS migration • ??? Something else? • Future work - what to do next with them? • New contribution from Abdel • fault localization and correlation for transparent network • Other contributions • E.g. resilience?
Centralized versus distributed path computation TF • D18 contribution to concepts and descriptions of pure (centralized and distributed) solutions of path computation • Future work • New contributions? • Next step should be hybrid solutions • PCE is not regarded as hybrid since it is fully integrated into the CP • However, PCE is an important topic for further work • Currently elaborated under SF TF
Signaling Framework TF • DCN Dimensioning • UNI TF • PCE • Inter-carrier E-NNI • ASON-GMPLS interworking • MPLS-GMPLS interworking and convergence/migration • Planned • Vertical integration and ML TE • GMPLS control of Ethernet networks
Control Plane support – CP Dimensioning • Contribution by TID to D18 has not really been discussed • This meeting • Collaboration with WP2? • Further work planned?
Control Plane support – PCE • Originally started in centralized vs. distributed TF • D18: Description of current IETF definition and draft application scenario description • Relevant topic for further work – currently discussed in SF TF
Control Plane support – UNI • Had been separate TF – closed • Had originally different scope • D18: Comparison of different UNI definitions • D18: Description of GMPLS UNI • D18 started: ASON – GMPLS interworking issue • Relevant for further work – discussed in SF TF • Contributions from ACREO and T-Systems • Requirements document
Control Plane support – other contributions • The following topics had been not included in D18 • Vertical and horizontal integration • ML TE • L2 LSPs • Further contributions planned ? • MPLS – GMPLS interworking • ASON – GMPLS convergence • E2e path setup in transparent networks • Contribution on inter-carrier E-NNI will be provided for next deliverable • Problem statement in D18
VPN TF • D18: Problem statement • Management and control solutions for 3 VPN scenarios are being worked on • TV broadcast • Grids • SAN • Will be elaborated in collaboration with WP1
Information Modeling • D18: General objectives • State of the art • Open issues • First contribution on NOBEL IM • Further work on NOBEL IM ongoing • CP enabled NOBEL scenarios TP entities • Scope of this TF for the rest of NOBEL?
Integrating Physical Constraints into the Overall Control and Management Plane • Problem description • Physical parameter monitoring methods and state of the art • High level Management and Control requirements in transparent optical networks • Application example of performance monitoring (CTTC testbed) • Further work planned? • Further work • Fault management use cases in UC TF
NM and ASON Prototype Functional Scope • Description of ongoing implementation activities at partners • Will be continued • Needed • WP8/test and testbed transition of implementations
Open Issues – ASON support for NG-SDH TF • Scenario description • No contribution in Munich • Further work? • Scope of this TF in rest of NOBEL?
Drivers and Architectural Issues for Improved Service Support • Problem statement in D18 • Work is being continued • Separate TF?
Other Issues • Policy Based Management • State of the art • Open issues • In which TF?
Next Deliverables • Title of D25: • “Solutions for inter-domain and multi-layer NM & CP and service management concepts; NM and ASON prototype functional and design specification and test plan” (M21) • Editor TILAB • Deadline end of September • Title of D33 • D33 “Conclusions on Network Management and Control solutions supporting broadband services for all” (M24) • Editor T-Systems
Activities • 5 activities according to NOBEL contract • Check the coverage and match of current work to activities
Activity A4.1 - Network Management (NM) and Control/Protocol (CP) requirements and functional scope • Already there • High level functional requirements in D2 • Being worked on • All TF work on this • Missing • Functional scope of MP and CP
Activity A4.2 - Performance, fault management, fault localization and QoS monitoring requirements and solutions • Already there • Collaboration with WP5 had taken place – closed • Performance monitoring parameters have been studied • Implementation of OPM system (CTTC) • High level requirements of CP and MP requirements of optically transparent layer identified • Being worked on • Missing • Correlation between OPM parameters and high-level requirements • Conclusion missing • Feasibility • Usability • problems
Activity A4.3 - Inter-domain, multi-layer NM and CP and Service Management aspects • Already there • UNI • Being worked on • ASON-GMPLS • MPLS-GMPLS • E-NNI • Service plane • VPNs • ML TE started • Missing • ML issues covered?
Activity A4.4 - Standardization approaches, especially centralized vs. distributed implementation of NM and CP functions • Already there • Path computation centralized – distributed • PCE • Being worked on • Missing • Review of standardization • Scope and conclusions of centralized vs distributed
Activity A4.5 - NM and CP prototype function and design specification, implementation and test • Already there • Description of implementation scope per partner • Being worked on • implementations • Missing • Description of WP8 interaction • Conclusions
Missing • From WP description: • d. Service Management: Issues for tariffing and pricing, billing and accounting of dynamic services in cooperation with WP2. • e. For the management requirements of resilience and TE in multi-layer networks, as specified in WP1 and WP2 • Describe optimised solution for simplified and collaborative Network Management and Control • Final conclusions and recommendations for all activities
WP4 in remaining Year II • 2 open deliverables • D24, 0905 (TILAB, Roberto) • D31, 1205 (T-Systems) • What we need • Results • An overall M&C picture • Final conclusions • Migration recommendations • Publications • Standardization
Task Forces and Work Distribution • Signaling TF • Overloaded? • Information Modeling TF • Keep as is • Use Cases TF • Keep as is • Implementation TF • Keep as is • ASON support for NG-SDH • Keep as is • UNI TF • closed
Task Forces and Work Distribution • OPM TF • Seems closed • VPN TF • Keep as is • Service Issues TF • Kick off new TF?
Standardization • The commission requests especially contributions from IPs to standardization bodies • ITU-T • IETF • OIF • TMF • We have problems with common contributions • Will we have some? • However, all big partners contribute to standardization • Collect per partner (internally) contributions which were made related to WP4 topics, which received internally input from WP4 results • Build a map • Editor?
Status Publications • NOC 2004 • ONDM 2005 B. Berde, M. Canali, P. Castoldi, A. Iselt, M. Jaeger, L. Levreau, H. Lonsethagen, A. Mazzini, M. Nathansen, Javier G. Ordas, "Network Management and Control for Intelligent and Agile Optical Networks", Optical Networks Design and Modeling (ONDM 2005), Milan, Italy, February 2005, ISBN: 0-7803-8957-3 • G.Juillot, M.Nathansen, C.Margaria, and A.Iselt. Emulation in GMPLS-controlled Optical Transport Networks. ITG-Fachtagung "Photonische Netze", Leipzig, 2005 • IEEE ComMag July 2005 • G.Juillot, C.Margaria, M.Nathansen, and A.Iselt. Emulation in GMPLS controlled Networks. 10th European Conference on Networks & Optical Communications, London, 2005 • ECOC CTTC
Planned Publications • Invited paper ECOC • Poster at ECOC • Other contributions planned? • Please make proposals
NOBEL Phase II • Status of project proposal • Hearing May 24 • Results of ranking in June • Negotiations (hopefully) in July
WPx Interaction • WP1 • LCAS • VPN • WP5 • OPM TF closed • WP6 • NE RFI closed? • WP3 • Requirements ? • WP2 • CP dimensioning? • ML TE