1 / 23

Dynamical constraints on the mass of the black hole in a ULX

No. Dynamical constraints on the mass of the black hole in a ULX. ^. Tim Roberts Jeanette Gladstone (Alberta) Andy Goulding , Mark Swinbank , Martin Ward (Durham) Mike Goad ( Leicester) Andrew Levan (Warwick ). ULX mass estimates.

bleake
Download Presentation

Dynamical constraints on the mass of the black hole in a ULX

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. No Dynamical constraints on the mass of the black hole in a ULX ^ Tim Roberts Jeanette Gladstone (Alberta) Andy Goulding, Mark Swinbank, Martin Ward (Durham) Mike Goad (Leicester) Andrew Levan (Warwick)

  2. ULX mass estimates • Wide variety of methods used to make indirect measurements of BH mass (e.g. Zampieri & Roberts 2009) • X-ray luminosity & spectra • Cool discs as IMBHs (e.g. Miller et al. 2003) • Disc-dominated spectral models giving MBH ~ 10 – 80 M (e.g. Vierdayanti et al. 2006) • Super-Eddington accretion models implying MBH < 100 M (e.g. Gladstone et al. 2009) Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  3. ULX mass estimates (2) • X-ray timing measurements • Scaling QPO, break frequencies gives IMBHs (e.g. Strohmayer & Mushotzky 2009) • But lack of variability in some ULXs argues for small BHs (e.g Heil et al. 2009) • Optical constraints • Counterpart magnitudes & colours (e.g. Patruno & Zampieri 2010) • All degenerate, reliant on assumptions Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  4. Dynamical masses: a heritage • To ‘weigh’ a BH – measure binary period and radial velocity shifts P From companion star: K* From compact object: Early Cyg X-1 data (Bolton 1975) from stellar absorption lines Radial velocity curve of GRO J1655 from He II line (Soria et al. 1998) Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  5. Extragalactic dynamical masses • Recently: two X-ray binaries outside our Galaxy with BH dynamical masses • M33 X-7 (Orosz et al. 2007) – eclipsing system • IC 10 X-1 (Prestwich et al. 2007) – WR-BH binary with MBH ~ 24 – 33 M IC 10 X-1 radial velocity curve (Silverman & Filippenko 2009) Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  6. Problems with doing this for ULXs… • Going from ~1 Mpc to several Mpc… • Faint counterparts (mv ~ 20.5 at best; typically > 24, Roberts et al. 2008) • Confused fields (stars & nebulae) • Observational challenge! HST data for Ho II X-1 (Kaaret et al. 2004) Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  7. Previous attempts • Kaaret & Corbel (2009) – NGC 5408 X-1 • 6 VLT/FORS observations in 3 days • No absorption lines from stellar companion; broad He II (face-on system?) • Pakull, Grise et al. – NGC 1313 X-2 • Early observations show Δv ~ 380 km s-1 in He II line between epochs (Pakull et al. 2006) • Follow-up in 2008/9 – no radial velocity variations(?) Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  8. Towards a ULX dynamical mass • We have been developing a programme to attempt to obtain ULX dynamical masses • 3-step process: • Identify counterparts from Chandra astrometry and HST imaging (Jeanette Gladstone thesis; Gladstone et al. in prep.) • Obtain pilot optical spectroscopy observations to identify useful spectral features • Undertake the RV measurements campaign Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  9. Best targets Luminous ULXs (> 5 ×1039 erg s-1) NGC 1313 X-2 m555 = 23.3 NGC 5204 X-1 m606 = 22.3 Ho IX X-1 m555 = 22.5 Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  10. Pilot spectroscopy results • Gemini G-MOS spectra obtained • B600 grating • Gemini-S • NGC 1313 X-2, 3 hr • Gemini-N • NGC 5204 X-1, 0.8 hr • Ho IX X-1, 1.5 hr Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  11. New programme on Gemini • GN-2009B-Q-21: Ho IX X-1 (18.6 hours) • 1.5 hours per observation • GS-2009B-Q-20: NGC 1313 X-2 (29.2 hours) • 2.5 hours per observation • Strategy: request 10 observations performed on nightly intervals (when possible) • Liu et al. (2009): ~ 6 day period in NGC 1313 X-2 • Madhusudhan et al. (2008): 1 – 10 day periods expected for small BHs in ULXs Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  12. Data obtained • NGC 1313 X-2: 1 obs. Oct, 9 in 13 nights Dec 2009 • Ho IX X-1: 5 obs. late Dec 2009, 5 obs. Feb 2010. Portion of 2-D spectrum from 26th Dec 2009 observation of Ho IX X-1 Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  13. He II 4686Å shifts relative to nebula Data from Ho IX X-1 Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  14. Periodicity? Best fit: P = 1.73 days, K = 77 km s-1 Reduced χ2 ~ 5 NOT PERIODIC Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  15. Any better luck with NGC 1313 X-2? Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  16. No. Best fit P = 3.01 days, K = 61 km s-1 Reduced χ2 ~ 4 Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  17. Is all lost? Ho IX X-1 data No – He II line profile is broad and variable on timescales of days Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  18. Similarly for NGC 1313 X-2 He II line profile broad and highly variable on timescales of days! Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  19. Implications • He II emission from very close to ULX • Solution: accretion disc reprocessing? • Broadening implies not completely face-on • Line widths consistent with location very far out in disc… • …or a small velocity component in line-of-sight • If this is from disc, can use limit from scatter in velocity shift to put lower limit on BH mass • But other possibility: emission in wind? Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  20. Mass limits 2σ upper limits: K < 97 km s-1 (Ho IX X-1); K < 182 km s-1 (NGC 1313 X-2) NGC 1313 X-2 6-day photometric period Ho IX X-1 Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  21. One more thing… • Stack all 15 hrs observations to get high quality optical spectrum • Ho IX X-1 looks featureless, very blue - dominated by accretion disc light? Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  22. NGC 1313 X-2: more interesting • Continuum less strong in 25 hrs on NGC 1313 X-2 • Possible stellar features appearing at short wavelengths? Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

  23. Conclusions • Ambitious programme to constrain the dynamical mass of two ULXs attempted • He II line centroid varies; but not periodically • Places no strong limit on BH mass • He II line is however broad and highly variable on timescales of days • Could be from the accretion disc: implying source close to face-on? Or from a wind? • Stacked spectra: very different counterparts Tim Roberts - ULX dynamical masses

More Related