130 likes | 257 Views
Now presenting….. Lee Pace & Claire Nollman. November 7 th , 2011 CCE518 Prof. Stanford Goto. ACT ONE. Starring: Lee Pace as Julius Atrayou (the student) Claire Nollman as Mrs. Franzia (the teacher). FLASHPOINT?. Activity #1. Find a partner.
E N D
Now presenting…..Lee Pace & Claire Nollman November 7th, 2011 CCE518 Prof. Stanford Goto
ACT ONE Starring: Lee Pace as Julius Atrayou (the student) Claire Nollmanas Mrs. Franzia (the teacher)
Activity #1 • Find a partner. • Share an experience you have had with this flashpoint.
Interview with Mary Obrien • Chemistry department head, EdCC • Taught chemistry in community college (EdCC) for 30+ years • The only job she has ever had
Results • Mary did not view this flashpoint as a challenge per se, but viewed it more as a part of doing business as a teacher • She feels that this situation is common to all classes and all teachers • Mary believes that this flashpoint is caused by human nature and competition for competitive professional programs • Perhaps the most significant response was to how to deal with this flashpoint, especially in front of other students • Explicitly explain grading practices • Insure students know what is expected of them • Repeat throughout the quarter
Results • Never discuss a students grade in front of other students • Insure that students are prepared for the class (pre-requisites) • Provide written solutions to exams, quizzes, and assignments • She does not give second chances to improve grades. She feels that students have had ample opportunity to practice and giving a second chance sends the wrong message • Mary has never used a pass/fail grading system • She does not think there is any difference in which students are likely to complain about grades • Mary believes that grades can promote learning. In fact, if learning hasn’t taken place by the time a final grade is given then we do have a problem!
Garcia & Hoelschersay…. “The way in which we address these difficult interpersonal situations [diversity flashpoints] can lead to outcomes that range from pain and suffering to more positive feelings of self-worth and enhanced learning.” “Successfully managing a flashpoint situation requires knowledge, skill, and compassion.”
Effective Grading: A Tool for Learning and Assessment Barbara WalvoordPh.D & Virginia Johnson Anderson Ph.D Principle 5 Listen and Observe Principle 6 Communicate and Collaborate with Students Principle 8 Seize the Teachable Moment
Activity #2 • As a class, choose one of the scenarios presented in Activity #1. • How do you minimize the negative impact of this interaction? • How can you turn this situation into a learning experience?
Resources Managing Diversity Flashpoints. Joseph E. Garcia and Karen J. Hoelscher, Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 2007 Effective Grading: A Tool for Learning and Assessment. B. E. Walvoord and V. J. Anderson. 2nd ed. Jossey-Bass, 2009.