80 likes | 239 Views
Does quality matter for innovations in low income markets? The case of the Kenyan mobile phone sector. Christopher Foster Oxford University christopher.foster@oii.ox.ac.uk (work undertaken during PhD research in IDPM, University of Manchester). Research focus.
E N D
Does quality matter for innovations in low income markets?The case of the Kenyan mobile phone sector. Christopher Foster Oxford University christopher.foster@oii.ox.ac.uk (work undertaken during PhD research in IDPM, University of Manchester)
Research focus Innovations and low income groups • What is an ‘inclusive innovation’? • more than innovation • impact; process inclusion • Is quality a key element in this? Heeks(2013)
Innovation and quality Low income markets = unclear 1) Extent of quality and effects in low income markets? • BoP view vs Empirical cases 2) Innovation in/for low income markets is different. • Interlinked stages; Intermediaries; User appropriation 3) What is effective policy around quality (if any)? • Policy as a process; Public/private standards
Mobile phone sector in Kenya Scaled and low income focussed: • Operator coverage: 92% • Handset access: 70% • Mobile money: 83% Quality Issues at the fore…
Quality concerns • Short term: Difficult to evaluate. • Medium term: Trust, cost, intermediaries • Long term:Risk of ‘big bang’ “close to 2.4 million mobile phones in the market are counterfeit, representing 9.39 % of the active mobile devices” (CCK 2013)
Drivers of quality declines • New lead actors • Partnerships; manufacturers • New intermedaries • Adaptation • New users • Appropriation, use
Policy • Existed in cases • Unclear implementation • Existence of extended intermediaries
Conclusions Quality becomes key concern in how innovations are inclusive…. • Recommendations • More focus on innovation and quality • Responsivity to appropriation • Lead firms and low income focus (USF, support) • Policy is crucial • Firms: Low income entrance vs guarding quality • Policy Making + Implementation • Intermediaries: Policing and policy