1 / 22

Understanding Social Influence and Bystander Apathy in Group Dynamics

Explore the phenomena of deindividuation and bystander apathy in large groups, illustrated through real-life incidents like the Kitty Genovese case. Delve into social impact theory, personality tests, Freudian theory, and social psychology experiments on helping behavior and persuasion techniques.

Download Presentation

Understanding Social Influence and Bystander Apathy in Group Dynamics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Social Influence 2

  2. Deindividuation Loss of individual identity in presence of group • Occurs in large groups • e.g., looting, rioting • Physical anonymity • e.g., Would KKK members burn crosses if they weren’t wearing hoods? • Diminished self-awareness “Jump bitch jump”

  3. Kitty Genovese • New York City, 1964 • Kitty Genovese was raped and murdered while at least 38 neighbors looked on • nobody phoned the police until after the attacker left the scene • When asked why they didn’t act, bystanders said things like, “I just don’t know,” or “I just didn’t want to get involved.”

  4. Bystander Apathy • field studies (Harold Takooshian) • New York City • bicycle theft • wallet pickpocketing • man put unconscious woman in car trunk • 20 replications, no intervention • why car alarms suck • 95-99% false alarms • few people stop thieves (1-5%) • field study (Takooshian) • 8% intervened • 15% helped thief break in • many people complain (60%) and some damage car out of aggravation • doesn’t deter real thieves • waste of police resources

  5. Bystander Apathy • Experiment (Latane and Darley, 1970) • subjects heard student in adjacent room having an epileptic seizure and gasping for help • likelihood and speed of intervention depended on how many others subject though were present

  6. Why Don’t People Help? • ambiguity • risks to self • anonymity • diffusion of responsibility

  7. Diffusion of Responsibility “I used to ask myself, ‘Why doesn’t somebody do something?!’ Then I realized I am somebody.” -- Jane Wagner

  8. Practice What You Preach • Experiment (Darley & Batson, 1973) • Princeton Theology Seminary students were on their way to give a sermon about “The Good Samaritan” • Good Samaritan: New Testament figure who takes time to help injured man at a roadside • Subjects were deliberately made to be early, on-time, or late • On their way through an alley, the seminary students found a man slumped in a doorway, coughing and groaning • What do you think they did?

  9. Persuasion • Robert Cialdini, social psychologist who trained with the best • reciprocity • Hare Krishnas’ flower power: “Please, it is a gift for you.” • preys on reciprocal altruism • lowballing • “Would you be a subject in an experiment at 7:00 a.m.?” • 24% yes • “Would you be a subject in an experiment? Yes? By the way, it’s at 7:00 a.m.” • 56% yes, 95% of them showed up • “I’ll give the car to you for $7,000. I need to discuss this with my manager. The manager says you can have it for only $7,300.” • door-in-the face technique • foot-in-the-door technique

  10. Social Impact Theory Convergence of social forces Diffusion of social impact

  11. Personality Test Scores • How would you rate the accuracy of your personality test score (available on the main course web page)? 0 = very poor, no relation to my personality 1 = poor, not very close 2 = more wrong than right 3 = more right than wrong 4 = pretty close 5 = describes me almost perfectly

  12. Freud in a Nutshell

  13. Sigmund’s Greatest Hits See text, Ch. 15, FQ 26-32 • Psychoanalysis • Id, Ego, Superego • Psychosexual stages of Development • Freudian slip • Oedipal Complex (and Electra Complex) • Defense Mechanisms • Interpretation of Dreams • Penis Envy • Influence on later psychologists • Cocaine

  14. 1. Psychoanalysis • hysterical women in Vienna • the “talking cure” • catharsis = explosive release of pent up emotions • hypnosis • free association • Anna O.

  15. Superego Id Ego 2. Id, Ego, Superego • unconscious • driven by libido • pleasure principle • conscience • reality principle

  16. genital 3. Psychosexual Stages of Development oral anal phallic latent

  17. Fixation • Example: Anal retentiveness

  18. Sigmund’s Greatest Hits 4. Freudian slip • subconscious, often sexual, thoughts lead to misspeaking 5. Oedipal (Electra) complex • boys (girls) are in love with their mothers (fathers) 6. Defense Mechanisms • e.g., repression 7. Interpretation of Dreams • latent vs. manifest content 8. Penis envy 9. Later psychologists • Carl Jung, Erik Erikson, Anna Freud, Karen Horney 10. Cocaine

  19. Three Revolutions in Human Thought(… according to Freud himself) Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1543) • the earth is not the centre of the universe Charles Darwin (1809-1882) • humans are not special, they are just a species like any other animals Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) • humans are not motivated only by their conscious thoughts but largely by unconscious (and often unpleasant) motives

  20. Praise for Freud • most influential psychologist ever • psychoanalysis has been very popular • huge impact on pop culture • recognized importance of unconscious influences on behavior • recognized importance of early development on adult behavior

  21. Critiques of Freud • real theories make testable predictions and can be disproved • subjective, unverified analyses • experiments have not supported theories • theories of development were not based on observing children • hysterical women in Vienna are not representative • some argue he was misogynistic

More Related