360 likes | 383 Views
Explore the impact of parenting practices on children's behavior and social outcomes. Learn about positive parenting principles, successful programs, and evidence-based strategies to foster healthy development.
E N D
Parenting programmes: What works? Some UK evidence April 2003 Stephen Scott Reader in Child Health and Behaviour Institute of Psychiatry, King’s College London
Continuity of Antisocial Behaviour from age 5 to 17 ESCAPE % of all children 1/5 1/5 1/5 1/5 4/5 4/5 Oppositional & Defiant Blamed by parents Disliked by siblings 4/5 Gets into fights Rejected by peers Low sel-esteem 4/5 Hard to control Poor school achievements Blems others Stealing & truanting Deviant peer group Antisocial attitude Career offender Unemployed Drug misuse
NEGATIVE PARENTING SCHOOL FAILURE .3 .2 .6 .6 DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOUR ANTISOCIAL BEHAVIOUR SOCIAL EXCLUSION ANTISOCIAL ‘FRIENDS’ .2 15 years 3 years 9 years PREDICTION OF SOCIAL EXCLUSION
SWITCH - REPEAT RIGHT LEFT C > CD ACC IPC CD > C OFC/ IFC OFC PL TL PCu
What is “Positive Parenting”? • Encouraging desirable behaviour & strengths (rather than just stopping undesirable behaviour) • Sensitively responding to child’s needs (rather than ignoring their signals) • Setting firm limits consistently and calmly (rather than exploding unpredictably and with venom)
Successful Programmes • Collaborate with parents: involve vs tell • Provide practical assistance • Offer specific Skills AND Support • Last at least 20 hours • Catch children before adolescence • Supervise therapists, have a manual
Principles of Trial for Conduct Problems • CAMHS clinic ordinary referrals • Reasonably broad entry criteria • Multiple sites in regular NHS clinics • Local clinicians trained as therapists
Multicentre trial of positive parenting • 141 children age 3-7 referred to CAMHS • severe, persistent antisocial behaviour • ‘Incredible Years’ parenting programme: • videotapes shown in group, 3 wks each of • Play • praise & rewards • setting limits • handling misbehaviour
Predictors of less child improvement • Child hyperactivity (.19 p.03) • Younger child (.17 p.04)
Attend Parenting Group .53 .21 .43 Maternal depression change Parenting skill change Parental criticism change .25 .05 .44 .08 Child less antisocial
DELIVERY IN EVERYDAY LIFE the SPOKES Programme in schools • Address a whole population • Get them young • Engage the most deprived • Address child behaviour AND learning • Use the most effective interventions • Make it normal and fun
PROJECT PLAN Design • Screen whole school • Take +1SD (~16% national population/~ 30% Lambeth) • Screen positive : randomise to INTENSIVE PROGRAMME CONSULTATION HELPLINE OR 3
Child Hyperactivity - PACS Interview Scores
Child Emotional problems - PACS Interview Scores
LITERACY PROGRAMME SKILLS • Orientation • PAUSE • PROMPT: meaning – picture cues -own experience read on to end of sentence start sentence again • PRAISE • There should be less sounding out of letters
Conclusions • Parenting programs can improve antisocial behaviour in the family by a substantial amount • Parents can be taught to enhance reading skills • It would be worth finding out the extent to which parents could enhance peer relationships
NEGATIVE PARENTING SCHOOL FAILURE .3 .2 .6 .6 DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOUR ANTISOCIAL BEHAVIOUR SOCIAL EXCLUSION ANTISOCIAL ‘FRIENDS’ .2 15 years 3 years 9 years PREDICTION OF SOCIAL EXCLUSION
Cognitions and beliefs Emotions and motivation Behaviour and skills
Making your local parenting programme effective for a whole population: do you: Make it available, acceptable, accessible, affordable? Use programmes independently shown to work? Supervise workers regularly using a manual? Have strong management to coordinate elements? Define population, screen risk, pursue non-attenders?
Systematic, population-based services • Level 1: universal, media-based “infotainment” • Level 2: primary care 20 min specific consult • Level 3: primary care 4 X 20 min wider skills • Level 4: group parenting, say 8 sessions • Level 5: more intensive – extra 10 sessions • Australian experience with Triple P (Sanders)