1 / 19

Water Resource Impacts of Low and High Density Residential Development: A Comparative Analysis

Water Resource Impacts of Low and High Density Residential Development: A Comparative Analysis. Dr. David Gallo Department of Economics and The Center for Economic Development California State University, Chico. Impacts Assessed. Cost of water-related infrastructure: water and sewer

brick
Download Presentation

Water Resource Impacts of Low and High Density Residential Development: A Comparative Analysis

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Water Resource Impacts of Low and High Density Residential Development: A Comparative Analysis Dr. David Gallo Department of Economics and The Center for Economic Development California State University, Chico

  2. Impacts Assessed • Cost of water-related infrastructure: water and sewer • Water consumption • Runoff

  3. Development Densities Compared • Low density residential: three units per acre • High density residential: ten units per acre

  4. Scale of Development • Use the Meriam Park development proposed by New Urban Builders for Chico, California • A mixed use development of 2300 homes • To be built on 272 acres for a gross density of 8.45 units per acre • 210 of those acres are to be developed for a net density of 10.95 units per acre

  5. Water and Sewer Costs: High Density • Data from American Planning Association, EPA, and other sources • Annual cost of water and sewer infrastructure: $891 per household • 30-year cost per housing unit: $26,730 • 30-year cost for 2300 housing units: $61,478,000

  6. Water and Sewer Costs: Low Density • Higher annual infrastructure cost per housing unit: $1,133 • At three units per acre the 272 acres in the Meriam Park development would only accommodate 30% of the housing • Additional housing is assumed to be 0.5 miles further from the urban core. • The added cost per unit for these more remote low density units is $21.00 annually

  7. Total Cost for 2300 Housing Units: Low Density Development Pattern • 690 units with annual water and sewer costs of $1,133 • 1610 units with annual water and sewer costs of $1,154 • Total annual cost per housing unit: $1,148 • 30-year cost per housing unit: $34,440 • 30-year cost for 2300 housing units: $79,218,000

  8. Water and Sewer Infrastructure Cost Savings: Low vs. High Density Development Patterns

  9. Per Capita Water Use • Data from a study in Envision, Utah • At 3 units per acre, per capita use is 160 gallons per day • At 7 units per acre, per capita use is 100 gallons per day • Little or no further reduction is achieved at higher densities

  10. Annual Household Water Use • Assume 2 individuals per household • Annual use for three units per acre: 116,800 gallons (.36 acre feet) • Annual use at seven or more units per acre: 73,000 gallons (.22 acre feet)

  11. Total Annual Water Use for 2300 Housing Units • High Density: 515 acre feet annually • Low Density: 824 acre feet annually • Annual savings: 309 acre feet

  12. Value of Water Use Reduction • Water Value of $120 per acre foot • Based on the price of water transfers north of the delta • Similar to the cost of water from proposed new storage projects • Annual value is $37,100 • 30-year savings of $1,113,000

  13. Watershed Impacts: Annual Runoff • Estimates based on the EPA’s SG WATER model • Basis for the estimates is the amount of impervious surface • Comparison is for four and eight units per acre

  14. Impervious Surface: Percent of Developed Land • Four units per acre: 38 percent is impervious surface • Eight units per acre: 65 percent is impervious surface

  15. Total Impervious Surface • Four units per acre and 2300 homes: 219 acres of impervious surface • Eight units per acre and 2300 homes: 187 acres of impervious surface • Also, lawn areas are more impervious than undisturbed watershed

  16. Annual Runoff per Housing Unit • Four units per acre: 6200 cubic feet • Eight units per acre: 4950 cubic feet

  17. Annual Runoff for 2300 homes • At four units per acre: 327 acre feet • At eight units per acre: 261 acre feet • Reduction in runoff for high density development: 66 acre feet per year

  18. Summary for 2300 Housing Units: Water-Related Benefits of High Density Residential Development • Reduced cost of infrastructure for water and sewer: 30-year total of $17,739,000 • Reduced water use: Annual reduction of 309 acre feet for a 30-year savings of $1,113,000 • Reduced runoff: Annual reduction of 66 acre feet

  19. Statewide Impacts • It is expected that California will add approximately 4 million households by 2025 • High density residential development patterns will achieve the following: • Reduce water and sewer infrastructure cost by $30.85 billion over 30 years • Reduce annual water use by 538,000 acre feet • Reduce annual runoff by 115,000 acre feet

More Related