240 likes | 258 Views
Results of an Assessment of the Quality of HIV Data in Sixteen Service Sites in the Upper East Region.
E N D
Results of an Assessment of the Quality of HIV Data in Sixteen Service Sites in the Upper East Region Dr. GiftyApiungAninanya, Mr. KyeremehAtuahene, Mr. Cosmos Ohene-Adjei, Mr. Isaiah Doe Kwao, Mr. Emmanuel TetteyLarbi, Mr. TwumasiOpoku Samuel, Mr. Samuel Efa-Quayson, Mr. MajeedSulemana, Dr. MokowaBlayAdu-Gyamfi
Outline • Introduction • Objectives • Methodology • Results • Discussion • Recommendations • Acknowledgement • Photo Gallery
INTRODUCTION I • Achieving health targets, such as the 90:90:90 targets and the post-2015 era of the SDGs will require accurate and reliable data (UNAIDS, 2014). • Quality data are the prerequisite for better information, better decision-making and better population health(WHO 2008). • Inspite of the usefulness of data, health facilities are confronted with data quality challenges (Doherty et al 2009 & Boerma 2005) • Due to poor recording, errors in processing data and lack of use of already generated data which may hinder constructive feedback to data producers (English et al 2011 & Nicol 2013).
INTRODUCTION II • Poor quality data leads to a lack of reliable data to monitor HIV programmes • Coding errors were identified due to poor quality documentations in the clinical information systems (Cheng et al 2009) • Errors led to inaccurate performance measurement & inappropriate allocation of health funding (Cheng et al 2009) • Sound and reliable RDQA is thus vital to obtain high data quality (WHO 2010, Chan et al 2010) • Assessed the quality of HIV reported data in 16 service sites
OBJECTIVES • To assess the quality of reported data for five HIV indicators • Adults and children newly initiated on ART • HIV-positive pregnant women who received ARVs • Condoms distributed • Individuals who received HTS • Babies born to HIV mothers and received test for HIV at six weeks • To develop recommendations to implement corrective measures for improving quality of HIV data
METHODOLOGY I • Retrospective Study • Site Selection • Indicators verified • Adults and children newly initiated on ART • HIV-positive pregnant women who received ARVs • Condoms distributed • Individuals who received HTS • Babies born to HIV mothers and received test for HIV at six weeks
METHODOLOGY II Clinical Sites Non-Clinical Sites Anglican Diocesan Development and Relief Organization PPAG West Africa Program to Combat AIDS and STIs ActionAid Ghana Community AID Through Sustainable Establishment Community Dev’t and Advocacy Centre Community Integrated Dev’t Initiative Rural Initiative for Self-Empowerment • Paga Hospital • GaruTempane • Talensi Hospital • Sirigu Health Centre • Mirigu Health Centre • Tempane Health Centre • Chiana Health Centre • Rabito Clinic
METHODOLOGY III • Routine Data Quality Assessment tool • Assessed strengths and weaknesses in data collection and reporting • Verification enabled comparison of recounted and reported quantitative data
METHODOLOGY IV Data Analysis • RDQA had a dashboard with various proportions, graphs and tables • Interpretation was done by a verification factor (VF) • VF is a measure of the accuracy of data collected • Numbers reported from a facility were re-aggregated from available source documents and compared to what was reported1 • VF = Recounted numbers/reported numbers
METHODOLOGY VI • VF over 100% indicates an under reporting as more information was found at the site than was reported • VF below 100% indicates an over-reporting as less data was found at the time of the audit than was reported • A VF of 100% represents accurate reporting
DISCUSSION • Results portrayed an average performance • Inadequate data verification exercises • Poor data archival system resulted in data inconsistencies • CSOs showed outstanding performance • Data accuracy reported elsewhere (Uganda MOH, 2015)
RECOMMENDATIONS • Ghana Health Service should ensure that sub-districts establish data validation staff purposely for monthly data validation • Ghana Health Service should procure and distribute flat files to all facilities to improve archival practice • Data documentation in primary sources should be monitored and supervised by both facility staff and unit heads on monthly basis • Data management processes should be given the needed attention and support by the entire leadership of Ghana Health Service
AKNOWLEDGEMENT • Ghana Health Service • National AIDS Control Program • Regional Coordinating Council • Civil Society Organizations • All implementing partners