40 likes | 204 Views
C2 MG Review Process for C2-led Projects. CG Editor/Managing Editor requests full methods review for a protocol or review. MG Associate Editor/Managing Editor scans for specialized peer reviewer needs. MG Managing Editor solicits methods peer review. 1-7 days. 1-2 days. 2-4 weeks.
E N D
C2 MG Review Process for C2-led Projects CG Editor/Managing Editor requests full methods review for a protocol or review MG Associate Editor/Managing Editor scans for specialized peer reviewer needs MG Managing Editor solicits methods peer review 1-7 days 1-2 days 2-4 weeks MG Associate Editor/Managing Editor notifies CG of veto 2 weeks CG Editor/Managing Editor requests in-house methods review for a protocol MG approves CG in-house review MG receives methods peer review 1 day MG vetoes CG in-house review 1-2 weeks MG Editor/Associate Editor sends peer review & action letter to CG Managing Editor
Current C2 MG Review Process for CDPLPG-led Projects CDPLPG Managing Editor requests methods review from MG Editor/Associate Editor 2 weeks MG Editor/Associate Editor sends peer review to CDPLPG Managing Editor
Proposed C2 MG Review Process for C1-led Projects C1 Editorial Team solicits at least one methods/statistics peer reviewer Authors R&R document based on peer review C1 provides C2 MG a copy of revised & original document & peer review comments 4 weeks C2 MG notes methods flaws: sends action letter to C1 Editorial Team & C2 CG C2 MG approves C1 methods review C2 MG notifies C1 Editorial Team & C2 CG of approval