1 / 18

The Global Gag Rule

The Global Gag Rule . By: Sameen Farooq and Grace-Marie Ottomanelli Pre-med GHLI 2008 11/9/08. Outline. Origins of the Global Gag Rule Historical Precedents Social and political impact around the globe Future Implications. Origins . Roe v. Wade (1973)

calum
Download Presentation

The Global Gag Rule

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Global Gag Rule By: Sameen Farooq and Grace-Marie Ottomanelli Pre-med GHLI 2008 11/9/08

  2. Outline Origins of the Global Gag Rule Historical Precedents Social and political impact around the globe Future Implications

  3. Origins • Roe v. Wade (1973) • The Helm’s Amendment (1973) • Placed a block on any direct use of USAID funds for abortion related services by both governments and NGOs • Established anti-abortion US policies as national precedents • The provisions of this amendment were further reasserted by the “Global Gag Rule”

  4. History • 1984-Big Brother? • Reagan Administration- Executive Order • World Population Conference in Mexico City

  5. 1990s-2000s • The Gag Rule was rescinded in 1993 by the Clinton Administration. • Smith Amendment (1999): • The amendment remained in affect for a year, and required foreign NGOs to comply with the Gag Rule restrictions for one year • Under the George W. Bush administration the Gag Rule was fully reinstated via executive order, and today is still a policy directive of the U.S.

  6. Stipulations • NGOs would be ineligible for US foreign aid through USAID and the US Family Planning Association if they received funds from other sources and engaged in the following activities: • Performing abortions • Providing counseling or referral for abortions • Lobbying for increased funding for abortion rights and accessibility in their home countries

  7. Implications • The Gag Rule did not implicate governments or US based NGOs unless they were in defiance of its policy directives • It did not apply to non-family planning US assistance, such as “child survival” • It did not ban abortions in cases of: • Rape • Incest • Endangerment of Women’s Health

  8. Concerns • The Global Gag Rule undermined: • Women’s reproductive health issues • The importance of family planning • Population control • Comprehensive access to women’s medical services • The fight against: • STIs • HIV/AIDS • TB • Malaria

  9. NGOs Non-governmental Organizations provide: • Contraceptives for both males and females • Provides pre- and post-natal care • Family Planning education • Controlling the spread of STIs • Fighting global disease epidemics • Working with national governments and international organizations

  10. Adverse Effects of Policy Directives • Degrading the autonomy of NGOs by restricting monetary funds • Failing to prevent abortions, and possibly increasing the rate of illegal and unsafe abortions • Resulting in a great level of confusion about: • Contraception • Education • Medical Services

  11. Ethics and Morality • Is it ethical for the US to impose its moral values through restrictions placed by the Global Gag Rule? • For instance: • In Kenya about 20,000 women per year are brought into local hospitals due to ill-performed abortions3 • Globally 20 million unsafe abortions occur each year mostly in underserved countries3 • 70,000 women die annually due to abortion complications throughout the world3

  12. Effects of the Loss of NGO support • Drastic slashes in social services • 2005-2006, Ghana saw decreased involvement of its national Planned Parenthood Association when: • 697,000 Planned Parenthood Association clients lost access to: • Sexual education • HIV testing • Contraceptives • Family planning services • The International Planned Parenthood Association of St. Lucia cancelled a 218 person “peer-helpers” program: • Designed to teach 12,000 school-aged children about reproductive health and methods of prevention for HIV/AIDS and STIs

  13. Global Gag Rule ≠Social well being • No condoms, Oh My! • Contraception: • Who? • Where? • How much?

  14. The Basket of Life • Department for International Development (DFID) • Bilateral aid known as the “The Basket Fund” • Purpose • USAID is the only bilateral aid that does not support “The Basket Fund.”

  15. What’s going on? • H.R. 2674 also known as the 2008 Foreign Operations Appropriations bill • Eases the restrictions placed by the Global Gag Rule • Approved in the House of Representatives and the Senate • Unfortunately, this “bill will remain a bill, and not become a law” for now • There are positive indications of its reversal under the Obama Administration

  16. ΣGlobal Gag Rule

  17. AMSA in Action • Main goal for AMSA is to repeal the Global Gag Rule in Barack Obama’s first 100 days as President. • AMSA members can organize events on campuses including: • Call-ins • Rallies • Information sessions • Moderated Panels

  18. Bibliography 1) Global Gag Rule & Contraceptive Supplies from the Access Denied website: http://www.globalgagrule.org/ 2) The Global Gag Rule & HIV/AIDS from the Access Denied website: http://www.globalgagrule.org/ 3) The Global Gag Rule & Maternal Deaths Due to Unsafe Abortion from the Access Denied website: http://www.globalgagrule.org/ 4) H.R. 2674 information: http://www.sierraclub.org/population/global_gag_rule/ 5) Crane, Barbara B. & Dusenberry, Jennifer. Power and Politics in International Funding for Reproductive Health: the US Global Gag Rule. Reproductive Health Matters Journal 6) www.globalgagrule.org 7) http://www.amsa.org/global/aids/wad.cfm

More Related