1 / 22

713 Lecture 2

713 Lecture 2. The species problem. What is a bacterial species?. Phenotypic similarity Similarity in DNA sequence Similarity in genome content Entire genome? Core genome? Frequency of recombination. Mayr ’ s biological species concept.

Download Presentation

713 Lecture 2

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. 713 Lecture 2 The species problem

  2. What is a bacterial species? • Phenotypic similarity • Similarity in DNA sequence • Similarity in genome content • Entire genome? • Core genome? • Frequency of recombination

  3. Mayr’s biological species concept • Species were once conceived by taxonomists as groups of similar organisms • Mayr introduced the need for biological cohesive forces maintaining the group • Recombination • Selection (natural and sexual)

  4. Importance of the BSC • Emphasized importance of reproductive isolation • Focused studies of underlying mechanisms (not physical but evolutionary) • Identified distinct species within phenotypically similar groups and lumped other groups

  5. Does the BSC work for prokaryotes?

  6. Strategies for speciating bacteria • Phenotypic similarity • FAME • Biolog/API • DNA-DNA hybridization • 16s ribosomal DNA sequence similarity

  7. Bacterial classification strategies • Problem: lacks fundamental principle • 1st, cluster on basis of phenotype • 2nd, find DNA:DNA hybridization values that fit phenotype clusters • New method: average nucleotide identity, or ANI • 3rd, find value for 16s sequence similarity that fits DNA:DNA hybridization value

  8. Does the BSC work for prokaryotes?

  9. Prokaryotic population genetics • Population sizes (N) are usually huge, so genetic drift is typically ineffective • Mutation rates are typically low, but N is large, so genetic variation is abundant • Recombination rates are VERY LOW, relative to typical diploid sexual species (and even relative to infrequent outcrossing species, like plants) • How frequent is bacterial recombination?

  10. More challenges to fit prokaryotes into the eukaryotic BSC • Promiscuity of homologous recombination (not just within species) • Constraints on exchange • Ecology • Vectors • % DNA similarity:1-3% animals, 25% bacteria • Size of DNA fragment • HGT = horizontal gene transfer = nonhomologous recombination

  11. The alternative: the ecotype (Cohan) The ecotype is a lesser unit than a species that highlights niche specificity and local adaptation Motivation: apparently low recombination rates undermine the BSC

  12. Origin of ecotypes • New mutation generates new opportunity or selective advantage • Little/no recombination, so new subpopulation diverges without constraint • problem: a clean theoretical definition but realistic to find?

  13. Periodic selection • Simply: the purging of genetic diversity within a population by the selective sweep of a beneficial mutation

  14. Do ecotypes become species? (it depends on recombination)

  15. Are these ecotypes the beginning of speciation? Poltak and Cooper

  16. The relationship between ecotype and genotype • Do genotypes coincide with ecotypes? • Periodic selection should purge diversity within the lineage • Ecotypes should form single, coalescent sequence clusters • What about dispersal?

  17. MLST Sequence conserved loci (genes) Each nucleotide substitution defines a new allele Changes at each locus occur independently and randomly Similarity = identity by descent Shared changes = recombination

  18. MLST, eBURST  ecotype?

  19. “Why does MLST work so well?” • How long do ecotypes last? • Can MLST divine species barriers?

  20. What’s the best model to explain how your favorite bacterial species arose?

More Related