250 likes | 380 Views
Re-engineering: It Ain’t Easy!. Lorne A. Phillips, PHD 2004 NAPHSIS/NCHS Joint Annual Meeting June 6-10, 2004 Portland, Oregon. Last Year in NYC. Herding Cats Chaos organized results Start – Wait – ? Last Year – Accomplishments dramatic. Less dramatic but with closure and completion
E N D
Re-engineering: It Ain’t Easy! Lorne A. Phillips, PHD 2004 NAPHSIS/NCHS Joint Annual Meeting June 6-10, 2004 Portland, Oregon
Last Year in NYC • Herding Cats • Chaos organized results • Start – Wait – ? • Last Year – Accomplishments dramatic
Less dramatic but with closure and completion Completed: Common/national use cases Structured walkthrough – EDRS/EBRS/”Fresh eyes” Movement to state/jurisdiction application of EDRS/EBRS This Year’s Accomplishments
NAPHSIS NCHS SSA Re-engineering Oversight Committee EBRS Committee EDRS Committee Reports/Files/Outputs Committee Improving Cause of Death Committee Certifications/POS Committee Data Analysis Committee IT Committee National Re-engineering Committee Structure
Lorne Phillips, Co-Chair (KS) Charlie Rothwell, Co-Chair (NCHS) Alvin Onaka (HI) Bob Anderson (NCHS) Brian Cronin (SSA) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) Dorothy Harshbarger (AL) Edward Hunter (NCHS) Garland Land (MO) James Weed (NCHS) Joanne Harris (SSA) Ken Beam (NAPHSIS) Mike Lavoie (GA) Patricia Potrzebowski (PA) Rajesh Virkar (NCHS) Rose Trasatti (NAPHSIS) Stephanie Ventura (NCHS) Steven Schwartz (NYC) Re-engineering Oversight Committee
EBRS National Team Michael Lavoie, Chair (GA) Jill France (Iowa) Kathy Humphrys (MI) John Burks (OK) Sharon Leinbach (TN) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) Rajesh Vikar (NCHS) Tony Zanfardino (Northrop-Grumman) Kumar Batra (Northrop-Grumman) Leslie Lewis (Northrop-Grumman) Brandon Mitchell (Northrop-Grumman) EBRS Current Team Michael Lavoie, Chair (GA) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) Joann Gooding (SC) Ken Jones (FL) Kumar Batra (Northrop-Grumman) Cathy Molchan (AL) EBRS Committee
EDRS National Team Steven Schwartz, Chair (NYC) Rod Palmieri (CA) Cathy Molchan (AL) Teresa Jennings (WA) Ken Jones (FL) Peter Carucci (NY) Rose Trasatti (NAPHSIS) Rajesh Virkar (NCHS) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) Joanne Harris (SSA) EDRS/NYC Current Team Cathy Molchan (AL) Rose Trasatti (NAPHSIS) Abe Grund (NYC) Rosalyn Williams (NYC) Flor Betancourt (NYC) Steven Schwartz (NYC) EDRS Committee
Data Analysis Committee • Patricia Potrzebowski, Chair (PA) • Dorothy Harshbarger (AL) • Gary Sammet (FL) • Ron Hyman (CO) • Garland Land (MO) • Linda Caniglia (PA) • Stephanie Ventura (NCHS) • Joyce Martin (NCHS) • Donna Hoyert (NCHS) • Delton Atkinson (NCHS) • Rajesh Virkar (NCHS) • George Van Amburg (NCHS)
Certifications/POS National Team Dorothy Harshbarger, Chair (AL) Donna Calabrese (KS) Chuck Hardester (PA) Michael Rodrian (CA) Barbara Carter (NM) William Apao (VT) Nicole Henderson (AL) George Van Amburg (NCHS) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) POS/Certification JAD Attendees Dorothy Harshbarger (AL) Donna Calabrese (KS) Chuck Hardester (PA) George Van Amburg (NCHS) Abe Grund (NYC) Rod Palmieri (CA) Cathy Molchan (AL) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) Rose Trasatti (NAPHSIS) Rosalyn Williams (NYC) Marta Lowalaska (NYC) Kumar Batra (Northrop-Grumman) Larry Summers (Northrop-Grumman) Certifications/POS Committee
IT Committee • Garland Land, Chair (MO) • Bob O’Doherty (CO) • Gordon Freymann (GA) • Stan Nyberg (MA) • Abe Grund (NYC) • Gabe DiGiacomo (SSA) • Delton Atkinson (NCHS) • Rajesh Virkar (NCHS) • Rose Trasatti (NAPHSIS) • Nicholas Pace (NCHS)
Reports/Files/Outputs Committee Bob Anderson, Chair (NCHS) Teresa Jennings (WA) Lou Saadi (KS) Trish Potrzebowski (PA) Mark Flotow (IL) Ron Hyman (CO) Barry Nangle (UT) David Justice (NCHS) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) Rajesh Virkar (NCHS) Improving Cause of Death Committee Bob Anderson, Chair (NCHS) Steve Schwartz (NYC) Garland Land (MO) Dorothy Harshbarger (AL) Alvin Onaka (HI) Patricia Potrzebowski (PA) Donna Hoyert (NCHS) Delton Atkinson (NCHS) George Van Amburg (NCHS)
Past Year Committee Accomplishments EBRS: • Final JAD Session • Clarify national use cases • System requirements • Glossary language • MoVERS use cases • Structured Walkthrough (NYC – September 28 – October 3/2003) • Joint EBRS/EDRS Committees and “Fresh Eyes”
Past Year Committee Accomplishments (Cont.) • Final review and publication on NAPHSIS web-site (January 26, 2004) • Use Cases/UML Designs/Artifacts • Concentration moved to state specific application
EDRS • Completed EDRS use cases • Being applied in NYC, CA and other jurisdictions • Began porting national EDRS to NYC application SSA expanded support for EDRS technical assistance • Enhanced transfer of knowledge and commitment to use of national use cases
Data Analysis Committee • Focus • Data requirements for birth, death and fetal deaths • Edit specifications – NEDSS/NCHS • Identification of optional data elements • Immunization registry • Newborn hearing • Birth defects • EVVE • Review of VSCP and non-VSCP specifications change control
Certification/POS Committee • Certification/Point of Sale (POS) ideas for state starting the re-engineering process • JAD Session (NYC November 2-6, 2003) • Linked EBRS/EDRS and certification/POS use cases for national model • Four unique certification/POS use cases • Enter request • Produce copy • Update request • Auto print • Define system requirements and business rules for software development
IT Committee • HL-7 Mapping Project • Vital Records Authentication Risk Analysis and Option Examples: • Potential fraud with any system • Risks: forged signatures vs. shared or stolen passwords • Minimum = User ID + password + 1 • Password follows NIST standards • Proposed minimum = password + digital certificate • Ideal = OD/password, digital certificate + swipe card/key fob/biometric (unfeasible)
Improving Cause of Death Committee • Research Perspective • Review and analysis of available studies • Goals • Define common characteristics • Issues • Suggested solutions to improve physician buy-in
Oversight Committee • Phase II • Project plan • Publication of separate and joint (MoVER’s) use cases models • Change control • Funding
Successes • Completion of national use cases • Artifacts identified, developed, and implemented • SSA support for state/jurisdiction re-engineering grants • SSA support for technical assistance position
Successes (cont.) • NCHS Support for oversight and NCHS support position • Additional funding for EBRS JAD sessions • Northrop-Grumman continued technical assistance related to EBRS • Cooperative Working Effort • NAPHSIS/NCHS/SSA
Unmet Challenges • Lack of funding in specific areas • No NAPHSIS based re-engineering position • Impact • Limited Technical Assistance in General Requirements and Birth Registration Specific Areas. • Federal Register (May 2004) • Communication • Lack of focal point for knowledge transfer
New Challenges • Communicate better and more often • Don’t be afraid to ask • You don’t need to be the “first one on the block” with a new system. • Don’t be afraid to answer honestly when asked what worked and what didn’t
Be prepared to ask the tough questions because we all need answers!