170 likes | 184 Views
Explore the benefits of using controversial topics in the EFL classroom, including medical, social, political, gender, and transcendental issues. Learn how to facilitate discussions, manage the classroom, and engage students in meaningful debates. This resource offers a wide range of materials and activities for all language skills.
E N D
DON’T LET SLEEPING DOGS LIE TEFL TABOOS CONTINUED
“Controversy equalizes fools and wise men – and the fools know it” Oliver Wendell Holmes “If it matters it produces controversy” Jay Greene “A civilization in which there is not a continuous controversy about important issues is on the way to totalitarianism and death” Robert Maynard Hutchins
UsingControversial IssueswithTeenagers in the EFL Classroom • TheWhy • TheHow • TheWhat • Conclusion
Why ? Contro + versus = “turnedagainst” Conflictnot –ve Currentcurriculumbasedonconflictavoidance and evadedtopics Missing a chance toeducatefuturecitizens Teenagerstalking / Morals / Puchta Overtoyou !
The Issues • Medical • Social and Political • Gender • Transcendental
Topics Medical Euthanasia, abortion, addiction, medical use of marihuana, mental illnesses, geneticmanipulation, contraception, sex education, tenagepregnancy, eatingdisorders, bodyimage, organ sales Social & Political Poverty , ditribution of wealth, illegalaliens, media censorship & imperialismetc, militarycoups, systems of government, globalisation, unemployment,equal access to education, health and housing, revolutions, utopias and dystopias, prisons, crime and punishment, death penalty, disabilities Gender Homosexuality, lesbianism, transvestism, transsexuals and sex-change operations. Transgender, gender violence, sexual abuse, heterosexuality, expected roles of men and women, single-parent families, same-sex marriage, gay adoption Transcendental Religion; faith & fanaticism, atheism, self-help, death, life after death
The How • Shock ! Suprise ! Inform ! • Learners’ values • Teacher’s role • Classroom Management • Discussionguidelines
Classroom Management • Classroom Management • Atmosphere of respect, responsibility and open-mindedness • Questionourown ideas and bepreparedtochangethem • No hurtingpeople’sfeelingsordiscreditingtheir ideas willynilly • Knowledgeis fundamental. Providethe data forinformedcomments • Keepthediscussionontrack (don’timmediatelydisregardspeakerscommentsbutaskthemtoexplaintheconnection) • Wholeclassparticipation • Feedbackis key
ExampleGuidelines • Always listen carefully, with an open mind, to the contributions of others • Ask for clarification when you don't understand a point someone has made • If you challenge others' ideas, do so with evidence and appropriate logic • Always criticise ideas or positions, not people • If others challenge your ideas, be willing to change your mind if they demonstrate errors in your logic or use of the facts • Explain the relevance of issues that you mention when their relevance might not be obvious to others in the class • If others have made a point with which you agree, only repeat it when you have something new or important to add • Be respectful of turn taking. Let other people talk. Participation must be even • Above all, respect the beliefs of others, even if they differ from yours
The What • Material selection • Lesson Ideas • Follow up activities
Activities • Writing - Fur Debate • Listening - Song • Speaking - Roleplay • Reading - Clockwork Orange
Conclusion • Stimulatesdiscussion • Education in real matters • Requiresknowledge,preparation and selection • Control • Clear view of teacher role • Loads of Material, adaptable foralltheskills • Real Englishfor real lifetopics
SONGS: “Sally’s Pigeons” by Cyndi Lauper“Papa Don’t Preach” by Madonna SHORT STORIES:“Hills Like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway“The Abortion” by Alice WalkerREADING Abortion: Are you pro-life or pro-choice? (from Taboos and Issues) SPEAKING Role play based on Madonna’s songDebateTalk show with assigned rolesShort Story DiscussionsLISTENING “Sex Education” http://www.elllo.org/english/ToughStuff/TS001-SexEducation.htm“Abortion in India”http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/learningenglish/news/words/general/991118.shtmlWRITINGOpinion Piece“In-Someone’s-Shoes” NarrativeResponding to the Short StoriesVIDEO “The Abortion War” (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-aAEYqGPWM) “Speak Out - Episode 11” (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EeY4r-mZXlw&feature=related)GRAMMAR AND LEXISModal VerbsVocabulary on Health and Parts of the BodyVocabulary on BabiesVocabulary on Sex Education / Contraception
Sources • http://shortandsweet09.blogspot.com Mariano Quinterno • “TeachingTeenagerstoSpeakEnglish” Herbert Puchta, La Plata, Buenos Aires 24/10/10 • UTN • http://www.esldiscussions.com/ • Youtube.com • A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess • Taboos and IssuesbyRichard MacAndrew ,Ron Martinez