290 likes | 458 Views
Organization for EUC. Practices for managing an architecture in which programmers do not report to IS. Business Within a Business. Most firms manage IT as a business within the business, with IT having its own career paths job descriptions personality profiles. Aligning IT with the Business.
E N D
Organization for EUC Practices for managing an architecture in which programmers do not report to IS
Business Within a Business Most firms manage IT as a business within the business, with IT having its own • career paths • job descriptions • personality profiles
Aligning IT with the Business Technology Excellence (Systems) IT User Business Profitability (Applications)
Organization Structures • Contractor Formal agreements for services • Utility Reliable information in standard form • Vendor IS recommends solutions for business problems • Partner IS and Line share responsibilities for success
Organizational Structures Technology Need Partner Vendor Utility Contractor Non technology need
Contractor The traditional organization for IS units in the mainframe era. • Service level agreements • Negotiated services • Formal separation between users and technical personnel
Contractor IT Business Users Negotiation
Contractor Example: outsourcing. While this model describes the internal structure for many firms, it is the model for any functions that are outsourced. (See: Clermont, ‘Outsourcing without guilt’, MoIS, #5.4).
UtilityHopper, HBR, 1990 IS provides common interface among business units. Common structure in client/server architectures. • Is responsible for standard data or software; users responsible for business use. • IS monopoly • Business units are the innovators
Utility Business User IT Support
Utility Example: cost centers. IS units set up as standard interfaces among relatively independent business units.
VendorQuinn & Paquette, Sloan MR, 1990 IS competes with outside services for resources. Acts as internal consultants. • IS responsible for understanding business tactics • User accepts IS proposals
Vendor Business User IT Sell
Vendor Example: profit centers. Organizations that emulate consulting firms and set up their IS organization as a separate profit center do this. IS competes for funding dollars against outside organizations. (See: Allen, Make IS pay its way, MoIS #5.7)
PartnerHenderson, Sloan MR, 1990 IS tightly integrated with business strategy. Most common in high tech businesses. • Users and IT consult on both technology and business solutions • Shared rewards for business success or failure.
Partner IT Business User Share
Partner Example: distributed resources. Many companies have distributed IT personnel into business units so that the IT function would report directly to the business unit manager.
Relationship Choice • Contract • Utility • Vendor • Partner The appropriate relationship depends on the business strategy of the company, the maturity of the organization and the experience with IT
Business Strategy • Type A: seeks to obtain business advantage from the use of technology • Type B: uses technology for business advantage, although possibly not IT, and is comfortable paying for quality • Type C: seeks to compete on a commodity or cost containment basis
Four Stages of EDP GrowthGibson & Nolan, Managing the four stages of EDP growth, HBR, 1974 1. Initiation: new concept, exploring ways to use the technology. No control. 2. Expansion: some applications found, need to get people on board. 3. Formalization: costs become and issue. Effective controls developed. 4. Maturity: technology well integrated and managed.
Managerial Tactics • Laissez Faire • Monopolist • Acceleration • Marketing • Operations Alavi, Nelson, Weiss, JMIS,
Organization: Centralization, Decentralization or Distribution • Centralization • Consolidation of functions • Career paths for IS professionals • Information control • Economies of scale
Organization: Centralization, Decentralization or Distribution • Decentralization • Closeness to local problems • Responsiveness to operational requirements • User ownership of costs and problems
Organization: Centralization, Decentralization or Distribution • Distribution • Separation of IS and user functions • Identification of corporate data and functions • User ownership of user applications
People • IT Motivational Profile • Recruiting and Retention • Teams and Projects
Rational Retention Strategies • Recruit and Retain • Recruit and Replace • Outsource • Entrepreneur Support • Control and Limit • Raid for experience
Reorganization Trends • Outsourcing • Purchased systems • Core competencies • Reengineering • Downsizing and flattening • Global competition • Reduced margins • TQM
Critical Success FactorsBoynton & Zmud, An assessment of critical success factors, HBR, 1984 Those few things that must go well to ensure success • Require continued monitoring • Measurable • Cover business requirements
IT Business