1 / 19

Torts and Damages

Torts and Damages. Up to now, everything discussed has related to contract liabilities - voluntary assumptions of obligation and risk Tort duties are legal liabilities independent of contract standing- apply to involuntary assumption of liability and risk

chib
Download Presentation

Torts and Damages

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Torts and Damages • Up to now, everything discussed has related to contract liabilities- voluntary assumptions of obligation and risk • Tort duties are legal liabilities independent of contract standing- apply to involuntary assumption of liability and risk • Tortfeasor- party who breaches a tort duty • Victim-party suffering loss due to breach

  2. Torts and Damages • Types of torts (Names differ by jurisdiction- many types not listed, all are civil matters • Negligence- unreasonable actions • Fraud- misrepresentation for value • Libel- untrue written statements causing loss • Slander- untrue spoken statements causing loss • Battery- touching without consent • Assault- threatening to touch without consent

  3. Torts and Damages LAW Criminal Civil Reasonable Doubt Government prosecutes Jury system Punishment Contract Tort Preponderance of Evidence 2-Party suits Voluntary No punishment Involuntary Punishment

  4. Torts and Damages • Intentional torts carry punitive damages • Intent is to make people pay for injuries resulting from their unreasonable acts • Four general categories of tort common in construction • Negligence • Intentional tort/ Fraud • Strict liability • Deceptive practices

  5. Torts and Damages • Negligence- failure to act reasonably causing injury to others (most common tort) • Must prove all of the following • Existence of duty to be reasonable • Breach of that duty • Damages incurred as a result of that breach • Causation between breach and damage is direct

  6. Torts and Damages • We all have a duty to act reasonably in certain situations (driving, public gatherings, professional relationships, manufacturing and selling) • Duty must be based on a specific act- can’t sue for “general unreasonableness” • Arch/Engr has no duty to contractor, can’t sue for tort (in general) except for things such as safety, injury from design flaw, etc.

  7. Torts and Damages • Breach- prove that the specific act was unreasonable for the conditions (speeding, yelling fire). Harder to prove than duty • Damages- injured person must prove loss- no loss-no tort • Causation- loss caused directly by breach (aggravating condition can be included, but not original condition) can be hard to prove

  8. Torts and Damages • Making a mistake is not the same as negligence. Reasonableness standard protects to some degree • Misrepresentation of fact is a special form of negligence when no reasonable grounds for believing a statement can be found • Statement issued as fact (“this drug is safe”) • Statement is false (drug causes heart problem) • No reasonable grounds for belief (drug wasn’t tested) • Party justifiably relies on statement (party takes drug) • Damages result (Party has heart damage)

  9. Torts and Damages • Negligence per se- violation of statute, no proof of duty or breach required • Valid ordinance was violated • Injured party is member of protected class • Harm suffered is prevented by the ordinance • Violation of statute caused harm or damages • Party suffered loss • OSHA, ADA, EEO, building codes, etc • Currently undergoing re-interpretation

  10. Torts and Damages • Liability of designers to subsequent users- duty exists to subsequent users of a product. Remodeling industrial sites • Liability of designers to subcontractors and contractor differs by jurisdiction • Majority rule- no duty exists, so no damages can be collected from designer except for personal injury

  11. Torts and Damages • California Rule • Balance test under theory of negligence • Degree of certainty of harm • Foreseeability of harm • Closeness of connection between conduct and injury • Advancing policies to prevent future harm • Assignability of moral blame • Difficult to enforce

  12. Torts and Damages • Intentional Tort (Fraud)- presence of intent to cause injury or harm makes tort intentional (difficult to prove intent) • Fraud (deceit, misrepresentation, false claim) is the most common intentional tort in construction

  13. Torts and Damages • Fraud • False representation or nondisclosure of material fact • With intent to deceive • Misleading statement was relied on by complainant • Actual damages result

  14. Torts and Damages • Deceptive practice laws- discourage fraud and make it easier to bring the case (no longer need to prove intent) • Deception is inherent in the act covered by the statute • Contorts- claiming a contract breach as a tort.

  15. Torts and Damages • Contorts • Torts carry higher awards than contract cases • Lawyers “prefer” tort claims • Try to claim some specific action under contract is actually a tort • Historic reluctance by the court to allow breach of contract to be turned into a tort • Mostly for personal contracts (not construction)

  16. Torts and Damages • Strict liability-only applied in very limited situations such as manufacture of defective products or practice (blasting) • Manufacturers of defective products are strictly liable for injury IF • Flaw is present at time of sale AND • Flaw causes injury OR • Manufacturer fails to warn of risk OR • Product has correctable design defect

  17. Torts and Damages • Strict Liability of product manufacturers is why we have so many warning labels on products • Construction contractors are not considered manufacturers of products • Assumption of risk- common defense against tort in construction (and elsewhere) • Injured parties are responsible for their own injury if they have voluntarily assume risk inherent in the activity (sign a risk assumption to go bungie jumping)

  18. Torts and Damages • Proximate cause damages- tort damages are generally greater than contract damages because they include foreseeable AND unforeseeable damages (proximate cause) • Pain and suffering- compensation for experience of pain and suffering over a specified time. Difficult to assess, usually per diem award. Includes emotional pain

  19. Torts and Damages • Punitive damages- intentional torts allow exemplary awards used to “make and example” out of offender. Frequently reduced by the court • Tort cases- McDonalds coffee, Toro mowers, Philadelphia hospital • Calls for tort reform, resisted by trial lawyers. Tort does allow for eliminating the incompetent, but can be abused. Key is to find the best balance

More Related