250 likes | 350 Views
Field Performance of Nutrient Loaded Red Oak and White Oak Seedlings on Mine Lands in Southern Indiana. By K. Francis Salifu Douglass F. Jacobs and Zonda Birge. What to Expect.
E N D
Field Performance of Nutrient Loaded Red Oak and White Oak Seedlings on Mine Lands in Southern Indiana By K. Francis Salifu Douglass F. Jacobs and Zonda Birge
What to Expect • Poor seedling quality, severe competition and low site fertility are key factors that may limit restoration success on mine sites • Nursery fertilization can be used to produce high quality seedlings to improve restoration success • Discuss how nursery treatments affect seedling field performance on a mine site in Indiana
Nutrient Loading Building nutrient reserves in seedlings during nursery culture to promote retranslocation and growth when out-planted in the field
Simplified N Cycle in Forest N2 EXTERNAL INTERNAL Fertilizer Denitrification N fixation Litter Organic N M I U NH4+ NO3- NO2- M= Mineralization I= Immobilization Nitrification Le
Annual N Demand Met by Retranslocation N retranslocation (%) Tree species (Turner 1975; Miller 1984; Lim and Cousens 1986; Salifu and Timmer 2003)
Exponential vs. Conventional Fertilization N applied (mg/seedling) Weekly application (Ingestad & Lund 1986; Timmer 1997)
How Much Fertilizer Do Plants Need? Biomass Nutrient content Nutrient concentration Nutrient Sufficiency Optimum loading Seedling N content Dry mass or N concentration Luxury Deficiency Toxicity consumption n l f e Nutrient supply (Timmer 1997)
Bareroot Production Week 4 Red oak White oak 0-3.4 g N plant-1
Week 18 Red oak
Growth and N Storage End of Nursery Phase Red oak White oak Birge et al. 2006
Methods Evaluated: Deer Fence Species at 2 levels Nursery fertility at 10 levels Design = Split-plot design Replications = 5 blocks Blocks separated by 2m buffers Trees Planted at 1m within rows and 2m between rows
Schematic of Field Study N B5 B4 B3 B2 B1 42m Species RO WO 21m 5 1 10 2 9 3 4 7 6 8 Nursery Fertility 6 9 1 2 5 3 4 7 10 8
2500 trees on 5 ha Planted 2004
Field Sampling • At Planting • Basal diameter • Height • Nutritional analysis • Year-1 • Basal diameter • Height • Survival • Nutritional analysis • Year-2 • Basal diameter • Height • Survival
Field Survival White Oak Red Oak * * Percentage survival Nursery Treatments
Field Survival vs. Conser. Plantings Percentage survival Plantings /Species Jacobs et al. 2004
Red Oak Height * * * Height (cm) Nursery Treatments
Red Oak Diameter * * * Diameter (mm) Nursery Treatments
White Oak Seedling Response: N Status Conventional vs. Exponential regimes Year-One Pre-Plant N content (mg component-1) Nursery Fertility Treatments
Conclusions • Nutrient loading improved seedling field performance on mine sites • The nutrient loading model is a useful tool for quantifying fertility targets, and may help improve nutrient diagnosis in tree seedling culture • Vallonia nursery and ArborAmerica have adapted the proposed protocol
Future Directions • Rigorously test nutrient loading using balanced fertilizers and with more species • Weekly applications could benefit production systems • Increases uptake efficiency and minimizes leaching losses • Controlled-release fertilization at outplanting • Weed control measures
Acknowledgements • USDA Forest Service State and Private Forestry • van Eck Forestry Foundation • HTIRC at Purdue University • IN-DNR Division of Reclamation • Ron Overton, Area Regeneration Specialist, USDA Forest Service • Don Carlson, Extension Forester, HTIRC, Purdue University • Jim Wichman, Nursery Manager, IN-DNR Vallonia and Jasper Pulaski State Nurseries • Jim McKenna , Operation Breeder, HTIRC, Purdue University
Thank You! QUESTIONS?