40 likes | 189 Views
Kidnappings: Social Protest or Criminal Enterprise?. Eric Gutierrez 8 December 2011 . Sections of the Paper. Part 1 – Frameworks for analysis Part 2 – Application of frameworks on government responses to the problem Part 3 – Why Chinoys are the ‘proper’ targets
E N D
Kidnappings:Social Protest or Criminal Enterprise? Eric Gutierrez 8 December 2011
Sections of the Paper • Part 1 – Frameworks for analysis • Part 2 – Application of frameworks on government responses to the problem • Part 3 – Why Chinoys are the ‘proper’ targets • Part 4 – Rogues gallery – Kidnappers and key incidents from 1986 • Part 5 – Policy response – a whole-of-government approach
Status of sections • Part 1 – Framework – first draft completed • Part 2 – Application of framework – first draft started. DoJ, police reports, SC rulings compiled. Seeking info on ‘task forces’. • Part 3 – Chinoys as ‘proper’ targets. Materials collected (Hau essay; some AngTulay issues). Waiting for older AngTulay ‘Kidnap Watch’ info • Part 4 – Rogues gallery – need to sort materials collected, fill gaps • Part 5 – Policy response – outline done, first draft started. Need to do more readings.
Part 1 - Framework • Kidnapping as social protest • Kidnapping as a tool against social protest. • Kidnappers rely very strongly on others. • But kidnappers also serve a purpose for others, who rely strongly on them. • Kidnapping can be a community activity. • Kidnappers emerge when pools of armed men become ‘orphaned’ and unemployed. • Myth-making around kidnapping happens, and distorts understanding. • Kidnap groups are not conventional organisations; they are better described as dark networks.