180 likes | 363 Views
The Big Bang: Creating an Evaluation Program From the Beginning. Kelly R. Brantley Health Assistance Partnership 13th Annual SHIP Director's Conference. Why Program Evaluation?. Why Program Evaluation?. Basic SHIP Grant for FY 2007
E N D
The Big Bang:Creating an Evaluation Program From the Beginning Kelly R. Brantley Health Assistance Partnership 13th Annual SHIP Director's Conference
Why Program Evaluation? • Basic SHIP Grant for FY 2007 • Provide locally-based individual counseling services to a greater number of individual beneficiaries unable to access other channels of information, • Increase targeted outreach to diverse and hard-to-reach populations, • Increase and enhance the counselor workforces • Increase local and State participation in CMS education and communication activities
Informs program planning and delivery Involves stakeholders Supports learning Respects community Test a theory Tell a story Be accountable Inform the field Support fundraising Understand and improve program Why Program Evaluation?
What Does Program Evaluation Look Like? • Forms and Reports: CCFs, PAMs, Resource Reports, State database • Surveys or Interviews: Client satisfaction, training, outreach, presentations • Performance Review: Top-down and bottom-up strategies • Effectiveness or cost-effectiveness studies
Evaluation Myths • It is too complex. • We did it once before. • We don’t have enough resources. • We don’t know if we will do it right. • I already know what we need to do.
What Do You Do With Your Numbers? • Tabulate • Report to CMS • Draw trend lines • Decide where to focus • Ask and answer questions • Develop agenda items
Implementation Evaluation • Answers who, what, when, where, why • Also called process evaluation • In SHIPs, implementation evaluation is most common
Implementation Evaluation • An example: Evaluate a presentation to the public • Who was the audience? • How many people were there? • When was the presentation? • How long was the presentation? • What were the topics? • What did people think of the presentation?
Outcomes Evaluation • Measures changes in knowledge, skills, attitudes, behavior, motivation, decisions, policies, and conditions • Often asks a vague, immeasurable question • So must use an indicator to capture a value
Outcomes Evaluation • An example: Evaluate a counselor training session • Do counselors understand the topic sufficiently to provide needed information to clients? • Indicator: Eighty percent of trained counselors should pass a post-test with a score of 80% or higher.
Components of Outcomes Evaluation • Inputs • Activities • Outputs • Outcomes • Outcome targets • Outcome indicators
Planning Evaluation • Answer basic questions: • What do you want to be able to decide from your results? • Who is the audience for the results? • What information should be gathered? • When do you need this information? • Where and how do you get the information? • What resources are available to get, analyze, and report the information?
Resources • Basic Guide to Outcomes-Based Evaluation for Nonprofit Organizations with Very Limited Resources:http://www.managementhelp.org/evaluatn/outcomes.htm • Evaluation Activities in Organizations:http://www.managementhelp.org/evaluatn/evaluatn.htm • Volunteer Program Evaluation:http://www.energizeinc.com/art/subj/prog.html • Innovation Network:http://www.innonet.org/ • Outcome Measurement Resource Network:http://national.unitedway.org/outcomes/library/ndpaper.cfm
Thank You • Kelly R. Brantley • Senior Education and Training Associate • Health Assistance Partnership • Contact Information • shiphelp@hapnetwork.org • (202) 737-6340