1 / 55

Best Employment Practices to Avoid EPLI Claims

Learn about FBOR application, effective hiring, supervision, performance evaluations, investigations, discipline, reporting claims/litigation. Topics include employee coverage, background checks, communication, evaluations, proper investigations, and more. Essential for avoiding employment practice liability claims. Presented by expert Morin I. Jacob.

cmckeever
Download Presentation

Best Employment Practices to Avoid EPLI Claims

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Best Employment Practices to Avoid EPLI Claims Presented by:Morin I. Jacob

  2. Agenda • Section 1 – FBOR Application • Section 2 – Effective Hiring & Background Checks • Section 3 – Effective Supervision and Performance Evaluations • Section 4 – Proper Investigations • Section 5 – Properly Imposing Discipline • Section 6 – Reporting Claims & Litigation

  3. Section 1 – FBOR Application

  4. Employees Covered by FBOR • Firefighters • Not specifically defined by FBOR- Gov’t Code § 3251(a). • “…any firefighter employed by a public agency, including, but not limited to, any firefighter who is a paramedic or emergency medical technician, irrespective of rank.”

  5. Employees Not Covered • Employees Not Covered • Probationary firefighters • Probationary promotions? • Arson investigators who are peace officers • Regularly assigned to arson-investigating unit, or • Primary duty is arson investigation • Penal Code §§ 830.37(a), (b) • Inmate firefighters • Volunteer firefighters

  6. Section 2 - Effective Hiring And Background Checks

  7. Background Checks • Why conduct them? • Applicants exaggerate • Applicants cover up important gaps or omit problem experiences • Applicants manipulate employment dates • In some cases, the law requires it

  8. Background Checks • Internet searches • Google • Megan’s Law website • Social Media • 70% of employers use social media to research candidates. (source: careerbuilder.com) • Labor C ode section 980 • Reference checks

  9. Internet Searches • Options if your agency conducts online reference checks: • Provide notice; or • Access without notice but give applicant the opportunity to respond; or • Access without notice and do not provide an opportunity to respond.

  10. Internet Searches • Recommendations: • Verify that the information found is true and reliable; • Only consider information that relates to the applicant’s ability to perform the job; and • Only consider information that could legally have been elicited from the applicant during an interview.

  11. Reference Checks • A comprehensive, signed, written waiver and authorization is essential to any successful reference check.

  12. Section 3 – Effective Supervision and Performance Evaluations

  13. 3 Keys to Effective Supervision • Communication • Evaluation • Discipline (last resort)

  14. Effective Communication • Concrete, direct, accurate. • Focus on conduct, not person. • Respectful, constructive tone. • Explain impact of conduct on agency/public service. • Communicate expectations and strategies to achieve them.

  15. Make a Record • Make a record – memories fade and may need as proof later on (progressive discipline, litigation) • Notes • Meeting log • Memo or email to employee

  16. Performance Evaluations • Importance of performance evaluations: • Creates official agency record of performance. • Puts employee on notice of agency’s view of his/her performance. • Also important during probationary period • Tool for developing employees. • Progressive discipline • Not discipline but provide notice to EE • Litigation defense.

  17. Performance Evaluations • Ongoing process. • No surprises. • Covers entire review period. • Identifies positive and negative aspects. • Provides specific examples. • States measurable goals and benchmarks that can be assessed the following year.

  18. 7 Deadly Sins of Performance Evaluations • Not doing them at all. • Doing them late. • Not citing examples. • Not accurately assessing performance. • Not following agency/rules guidelines re evaluating performance. • Watering down criticism. • Mentioning specific instances that you never previously discussed with the employee (deadliest!!).

  19. Section 4 – Proper Investigations

  20. Investigations • Starting an Investigation – Status of the Subject Firefighter: • Administrative leave. • Paid or unpaid?

  21. Investigations • Selecting an Investigator • Selection criteria: • Rank; • Neutrality; • Disposition; • Training. • MUST be trained in FBOR. • Complexity of issues: • Outside investigator may be better if issues are complex or legal or the investigation involves a high ranking firefighter. • Clearly delineate the role of the investigator.

  22. Statute of Limitations • One Year Statute of Limitations • Gov’t Code § 3254(d). • Starts with discovery by “employing fire department”. • Ends with notification to firefighter of “proposed disciplinary action.”

  23. Interrogations • Gov’t Code § 3253 is FBOR’s interrogation statute. • When does it apply? • Firefighter is under investigation. • Contact may lead to punitive action. • Does NOT apply to routine or unplanned contact. • CAUTION: This is very gray area!

  24. Interrogations • Subject Firefighter Has Right to Representation – Gov’t Code § 3253(i) • Right is subject to reasonableness limitation- Upland Police Officers Assn v. City of Upland (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 1294. • The role of the representative is to facilitate, not disrupt, the interrogation.

  25. Interrogations • When Should an Interrogation be Scheduled? Gov’t Code § 3253(a). • Strategy decision • At a reasonable hour • On duty • Firefighter entitled to reasonable notice

  26. Interrogations • Who Else May Attend? – Gov’t Code § 3253(b). • No more than two interrogators. • Legal counsel. • No Threats. • The firefighter under interrogation shall not be subjected to offensive language or threatened with punitive action. • Gov’t Code § 3253(e)(1).

  27. Interrogations • Recording the Interrogation – Gov’t Code § 3253(g). • Best practice is to record; best practice is to get accurate record of interview. • Firefighter has right to record as well. • Include in written notice of interrogation. • Avoid going on and off tape. • Transcribe the interrogation if discipline is contemplated. • Consider using CSR for serious discipline.

  28. Pre-Interrogation Notice • Information that Must be Provided to the Firefighter Prior to Interrogation: • Name and rank of person in charge. • Who will conduct Interrogation. • Others present. • Nature of the investigation: • Date of action under investigation. • Factual allegation(s) of misconduct. • Rules potentially violated. • Recording of firefighter’s own prior interrogation, if any.

  29. Interrogations • Criminal Misconduct: • Gov’t Code § 3253(h). • If it is contemplated that a firefighter may be charged with a criminal offense, Mirandize.

  30. Interrogations • Criminal Misconduct: • If firefighter does not waive Miranda rights, employer must provide employee with a written grant of immunity from criminal prosecution to compel the firefighter to respond to incriminating questions. • Gov’t Code § 3253(e)(1). • Use immunity is probably sufficient.

  31. Investigation Report • Maintaining the Report • Firefighter has a right to see and sign the report before it is placed in file – Gov’t Code § 3255. • Firefighter may submit written response within 30 days of entry in file – Gov’t Code § 3256.

  32. Section 5 –Properly Imposing Discipline

  33. Types of Employees • Probationary • At Will • Permanent/For Cause

  34. Importance of Discipline • Why discipline? • PERFORMANCE • Last motivational tool. • If doesn’t result in improved performance, it’s a tool to separate employee. • MISCONDUCT • Investigation is complete and there are sustained findings. • Now, agency must determine appropriate penalty.

  35. Basic Discipline Rules Common Types of Progressive Discipline: • Verbal/Written Reprimand. • NOTE: Verbal/Written Counseling is NOT discipline. • Suspension. • Reduction in Pay. • Demotion. • Termination

  36. Steps Leading to Discipline • Determine what rules implicated. • Conduct investigation. • Determine appropriate penalty. • Provide due process.

  37. Basic Discipline Rules • Discipline must be: • Established and supported by provable facts. • Usually preponderance of the evidence standard. • Proportionate (penalty fits misconduct). • Total personnel history of EE should be considered. • Consistent (agency treats similar misconduct the same for all employees).

  38. Factors to Consider • How solid is the evidence supporting findings? • What is impact of conduct on agency? • Was the employee on notice of agency expectations/rule violated? • Is the rule that was violated clear? • Is the rule that was violated evenly applied?

  39. Factors to Consider • Are there mitigating factors? • No prior discipline over long tenure? • Stressors in personal life? • Are there aggravating factors? • Repeat offender. • Prior discipline, counseling, perf. evals. • Employee is a supervisor. • Employee trained (e.g., harassment) and does it anyway.

  40. Best Practices for the Pre-Discipline (Skelly) Process • The Skelly Notice (Notice of Intent) • The Skelly Meeting • Final Notice of Discipline • Once final decision on discipline is made, the Department has 30 days to notify the employee of that decision (Gov. Code § 3254(f)). • Date of discipline to be imposed must be at least 48 hours after service of final notice.

  41. Alternatives to Discipline • Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) • Can be established at any time as part of or in lieu of discipline. • Often necessary prior to disciplining an officer with performance issues. • Needs to be in writing, with specific guidelines, objectives, and timelines. • Critical to follow through and document outcome of PIP.

  42. Alternatives to Termination • “Last Chance” Settlement Agreement and Stipulated Discipline • Best to explore after Skelly meeting, but before issuance of Final Notice of Discipline. • Have the employee’s labor representative or attorney involved in discussions and signatory to any agreement. • Structure alternative as stipulated discipline in exchange for waiver of right to post-discipline appeal. • Should also try to negotiate general waiver and release.

  43. Alternatives to Termination • Resignation in Lieu of Termination • The law views resignation as a contract with offer and acceptance. • Results in loss of right to post-discipline appeal. • Must be voluntary and in writing. • Should be accepted immediately - in writing. • IMPORTANT: Should also try to negotiate general waiver and release.

  44. Section 6 – Reporting Claims And Litigation

  45. You Have Been Sued – Insurance Issues General Best Practices: • Know when and how to report a claim • Know who to call when lawsuit has been served 

  46. You Have Been Sued – Insurance Issues • Understand Coverage • Is there primary insurance coverage for the causes of action and damages alleged? • What claims or damages, if any, are excluded from coverage • Does the policy cover arbitration in addition to civil lawsuits? • What is the self-insured retention? (determines out of pocket costs) • Understanding a reservation of rights letter  

  47. Who Is In Charge of the Litigation? • Understand the role and objectives of each stakeholder in the litigation: • Board • Fire Chief • HR • Individual defendants • Insurance Company • Defense Counsel • Who is in charge? • Keep control group small and under control • Maintain attorney-client privilege

  48. Communication Strategy • Develop strategy for communicating with community • Consider use of PR firm • Develop talking points • Community will ask about litigation at Board meetings • Media requests will come in • Emphasize District’s core values in messaging

  49. Time Commitment for Litigation • Significant time commitment required • Document and email searches • Witness preparation for depositions and trials • Regular strategy meetings • Mock juries • Trial attendance and publicity • Can go on for years • Institutional distraction from mission • Emotional toll

  50. Settlement Considerations • Reality check: over 95% of all cases settle • Settlement is the only way to completely control the outcome • Mediation is usually required

More Related