1 / 17

The Well-being of Children of incarcerated Mothers Preliminary Results of a Dutch cohort

This study examines the well-being of children with incarcerated mothers in the Netherlands, assessing psychological, social, and attachment aspects through interviews, observations, and behavioral checklists.

cspenser
Download Presentation

The Well-being of Children of incarcerated Mothers Preliminary Results of a Dutch cohort

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Well-being of Children of incarcerated Mothers Preliminary Results of a Dutch cohort Menno Ezinga Sanne Hissel Anne-Marie Slotboom Catrien Bijleveld

  2. Introduction • Growing number of incarcerated women (400  800) • Little knowledge of their family: • Do they have children? • No check of civil registrations. • However, knowledge is important for possible necessary interventions by the government before, during, and after mother’s detention.

  3. Previous research • Netherlands: almost no empirical research on the well-being of children of incarcerated mothers. Some research on the contact facilities between mothers and their children. • Anglo Saxon: growing number of attention • Review Murray and Farrington (2008): • Incarcerated mothers possibly more damaging for the well-being of the child than incarcerated fathers.

  4. PROBLEM • Children separated from their mothers • Risk factor for problem behavior and decreased well-being (Murray & Farrington, 2008). • Separation between child and parent by incarceration could act as supplementary risk factor for problem behavior and decreased well-being. • Maternal deprivation creates most likely an even more vulnerable situation, as mother often is primary caregiver.

  5. PROBLEM (2) • Signals for sharp decrease in Quality of Life and well-being (psychological and physical) • Economical deprivation • Delayed/stagnated psychological development • Attachment problems (Poehlmann, 2005) • Social problems (stigmatization, bullying, deviant peers, taboo).

  6. Purpose • Study on well-being of children of incarcerated mothers in the Netherlands • Well-being is studied in general • How is caregiving organized now mother is in detention? • What is well-being of the children? • Is there any sign of internalizing or externalizing problem behavior? • More specifically: do the children experience anxiety problems, mood disorders or aggression problems?

  7. Sample • Children • 0-18 • Incarcerated mothers • Caregivers (fathers, family, foster home) • Teachers

  8. Instruments (1) Interview & Observations • Semi-structured Interview with mother and caregiver. • Semi-structured interview with the child (when possible). • Observation of the child and its environment.

  9. Instruments (2) • Child Behaviour Checklists: CBCL • Youth Self Report: YSR problem behavior • Teachers Reports Form: TRF • Personality-/behavioral questionnaires on traits, aggression, depression and anxiety.

  10. Preliminary Results Quantitative

  11. Preliminary results quantitative • Norms of the behavioral checklists: 7% borderline score of being problematic. • Mothers and care givers score overall > 7%. • Example: Almost 40% of the mothers score their child(ren) as borderline or clinical problematic on the anxiety and depression scale. • Also: care-givers rate the children as showing more behavioral problems than the mothers rate.

  12. Self-report & Short summary • Self-report: children report less problems than the grown ups. Still problems are reported on levels of • Anxiety • Aggression • No reports of mood problems/depression • So… • More problems than the norm population would score • With the exception of affective problems and emotional problem mothers are low on reporting problem behavior of their children • Care-givers score higher on (externalizing) problem behavior than mothers do. • The children report anxiety problems and aggressive behavior

  13. Preliminary Results Qualitative • Mothers • The prison climate and regime are not contributing to maintaining contact with the children • Concerns about the pedagogical climate of the child now mother is incarcerated

  14. Preliminary Results Qualitative • Children • They realize the seriousness of the situation (by observing mother in jail). • Missing their mother  Finally a break for the constant tension at home • Visits have enormous impact  logistically and during visit

  15. Discussion • Mothers are sometimes unrealistic about future care giving when they are released, and about the upbringing of their child = Incongruent with children’s vision • Children are often far from positive about the possible return of their mother. The same opinion is found at the care givers. • Care-givers worry about upcoming return of mother “Foster care or remaining parent?”

  16. Discussion • Externalizing problem behavior: often seen by care-giver, not as much by mother • Not visible, while not in daily routine • “Keeping up appearances”. Afraid of Youth Care • Internalizing problem behavior reported by mother in affection and emotions • Visits create tension en forced feeling of happiness. Children are experiencing complex feeling and emotions  causes behaviors (tantrums or sadness) that reflects on mother

  17. End • Future • Start of PhD project on female detention and parenting (S. Hissel) • Fine tune analysis of the complete dataset • Expansion of the project by searching for similar European projects Feel free to comment me or ask any questions in this matter! m.ezinga@rechten.vu.nl www.rechten.vu.nl/nsmv

More Related