1 / 12

EU perspectives on enforcement of environmental law

EU perspectives on enforcement of environmental law. Dublin, 18 October 2012 Ludwig Krämer k ramer.ludwig@skynet.be. Context. Prognostics are difficult , in particular , when they concern the future

daktari
Download Presentation

EU perspectives on enforcement of environmental law

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. EU perspectiveson enforcementofenvironmental law Dublin, 18 October 2012 Ludwig Krämer kramer.ludwig@skynet.be

  2. Context • Prognosticsaredifficult, in particular, whentheyconcernthefuture • The pointofdeparturecanonlybethepresentstateofaffairs, andtheattempttoprolongpasttrendsandtendenciesintothefuture • Time horizon: 25 years /2030

  3. Climatechangeachievements • Attemptstokeeptemperatureat 2° abovepre-industrial time (1750). • EU: stop CO²-emissions by 2000 at 1990 levelsachieved reduce CO²-emissions by 8 per centby 2012 (achieved) . Reduce CO²-emissions by 2020 by 20 per cent . Emission trading (2003/87) Energyefficiency: 20% by 2020 Emission limits: cars, vans, trucks Renewablesourcesofenergy: 20% by 2020 Accessorymeasures

  4. Climatechange - problems • Is 2° temperatureincreaseenoughtostopclimatechange? • EU measuresare not followedworldwide - no international EU initiative - USA, China, Brazil, Russia, Japan, etc - no post-Kyoto - environmental refugees 3. Emission tradingsuffersfromtoomanyallowances Housing: not affected Transport: weakobjectives; not forexport Renewables: EU divided (nuclear-non nuclear) coaland gas remainsupported 4. Enforcementproblems 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 GHG emissionsIreland (allowed +13%) 55 59 68 69 61 (+10,3%) GHG emissions Spain (allowed +25%) 283 314 381 435 356 (+25,8%) 5. Sanctions: -

  5. Climatechangelaw– enforcementperspectives • The environmenthasnovoiceandcannotprotest • The EU is not able – not willing? – totakethedriver‘sseatforstopping global warming. Ithas not adoptedinstrumentsforthat. • The detailsoflegislationbecomemoreandmore open tomanipulation (averagecaremissions; referenceyearchangingfrom 1990 to 2005; coalfired power plants; issuingoftoomanyallowances) • Neithercriminalnor privat lawenforcementorsanctionswork. • We will achievethe 2030 targets in Europe; but not enforcethestopofclimatechange.

  6. Waterprotection - achievements • Waterframeworklegislationforfreshwater (Dir.2000/60) • Waterframeworklegislationfor marine waters (Dir. 2008/56) • Canalizationand urban wastewatertreatment (Dir.91/271) • Drinkingwater (Dir.98/83) • Groundwater (Dir.2006/118)

  7. Waterprotection - problems • The EU hasmoved back from an integratedwaterpolicyto a coordinatedwaterpolicy. • Inbuiltprolongationproblems • Legislationand „greenspeak“ (averageof 5 yearforbathingwater; drinkingwaterderogations; classificationofwaterstretches; „goodquality“; ) • Thresholdvaluesforgroundwatervarybetween 1 and 300 forarsenic; 1 and 1200 forcadmium; 1 and 1500 forleadandmercury. • Waterscarcityanddroughts • Agricultureandwater

  8. Waterprotection– enforcementperspectives • The frameworklegislationservedmainlytobuy time. We will have a statusofwaterby 2030 (marine waters 2020) andpublicauthorities will declarethewaterstobeof „goodquality“. In themeantime, noenforcement • Withregardto marine waters, not much will havechangedwithregardtotoday. Noenforcement • Effectivelegislationneedstolimittheemissions - whichisnothingelsethanthelimitationofdischargesofpollutantsintowaters • (New) Enforcementprovisionsarenecessary • Measurestoadapttoclimatechange will benecessary (waterconsumptionofhouses;products; irrigation)

  9. Enforcement - achievements • Transposition of EU environmental directives – not regulations! – into national lawisenforced, thoughnormallywithdelaysandoftenwithdifficulties. • Thereis a certainsensitivitiywithinthe EU institutions – Commission, European Parliament - asregardstransposition. • A numberof Member States havesetupenforcementagencies; theirdependency on policymakers – „hismaster‘svoice“ - varies

  10. Enforcement - problems • Applicationofexistingprovisionsisinsufficient. Environmental protectionis all toooftenonly on paper. 2. International environmental provisionswhicharebinding on the EU, are not enforced, not eitherat national level. 3. The enforcementproceduresat EU levelaresecret (Commission-Member State). Civilsocietyis not involved. Wheretheprocedureis open in Member States, resultsarebetterand (mental) corruptionissmaller. 4. The Commissionis not evenusingthefewinstrumentswhichareatitsdisposal (transparency, studies, comparisons). Itseffortstoensuregoodrelationshipwith Member States prevailsoveritseffortstoensurecompliancewiththelaw. At national leveltheeffortistokeepgoodcontactstoeconomicoperators. 5. Member States enforcementbodiesact national andhardlycooperate. IMPEL is an enforcementflop.

  11. Enforcement - perspectives • Thereis a needtobetternetwork in environmental enforcementissues, transnationallyas well aswithcitizensandcivilsociety. • Thereis a needto break administrative secrecyofenforcement. • Thereis a needtorecognizethatgood environmental enforcementis an asset, not a threat. • Enforcementagencies must avoidthatenvironmentprotectionsharesthefateofreligion: goodand vital in theory, but largelyignoredandsetaside in daytodaypractice. • Wemayovercomethefinancialcrisis; but we do not overcomeclimatechange.

  12. „But thisis a pessimisticpresentation“ • No. But nobodyshouldbelievethat environmental protectioncanbeobtainedwithoutfighting. • „Onlywhenthe last treehasbeenfelled, the last riverpoisonedandthe last fishcaught, man will knowthat he cannoteatmoney“. Shouldweletthe last rivergetpoisoned? 3. Ifprogressexistsat all, itistobemeasured in fractionsofmillimeters. Andanyprogressrequires strong efforts.

More Related