1 / 18

Key issues in CBRM

Key issues in CBRM. Why – objectives: Community based or top down? What is the community’s involvement Who is involved How / When - process design and methods. What is participation? Or how are people involved?. Any ideas?. What is participation?. Consultation Information

dale
Download Presentation

Key issues in CBRM

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Key issues in CBRM • Why – objectives: Community based or top down? • What is the community’s involvement • Who is involved • How / When - process design and methods

  2. What is participation?Or how are people involved? Any ideas?

  3. What is participation? • Consultation • Information • Meetings • Awareness raising • “Preach” or lecture • Practical or “learning by doing” • “Look and learn” • Sharing • Taking part • Involve • Story together

  4. What is participation?Levels of participation - exercise Write on individual post it notes - What kinds of participation might communities carry out to manage their resources?

  5. How are communities involved?Levels of participation • Community decisions and actions 2. Consultation 1. Information sharing

  6. 3 Levels of public participation “Ladder of participation” 1 Adapted from Arnstein 1971, Wilcox 1994, Inglis 1994, Pretty 1994, SPI 1997, Govan et al. 1998

  7. What is participation?Levels of participation - exercise Go into groups

  8. What is participation?Levels of participation - exercise In your groups discuss the individual post it notes and rank the kinds of participation according to the ladder previously discussed Report back from groups and discussion

  9. Key issues in CBRM • Why – objectives: Community based or top down? • What is the community’s involvement • Who is involved • How - process design and methods

  10. Who participates?Who should be involved – “stakeholders” • People, groups, institutions that are involved or possibly affected by the intended project • May include different people, women, youth, fishermen, families, clans, NGOs, religious organizations, local government, national ministries, commercial interests etc. etc.

  11. Stakeholder exercise – Who should be involved • Write down a list of possible people who should be involved in resource management (stakeholders) in a village you know well. • Please go back in your groups and compile a joint list of the people who should be involved in resource management

  12. Who / Stakeholders Put a * or ** next to most important stakeholders

  13. Stakeholders Just choose * and ** stakeholders from your list

  14. Enforcement Who enforces? • In top down or state management? • In bottom up or community based management?

  15. For what reasons would fishermen change their ways or obey community decisions?

  16. Key issues in CBRM • Why – objectives: Community based or top down? • What is the community’s involvement • Who is involved • How - process design and methods

  17. Community Based Management • Groupmaker – birth months • Please read “Why Community Based Management (Lambeth and Watt 2004)” • Discuss in the group what are the reasons for the 8 rules in the “philosophy for CBM workers box” [20 mins] • Plenary report back

  18. Philosophy for CBM workers • CBM workers must never take an action that reduces the community’s’sense ofownership. • CBM workers must become goodfacilitators. • Suggestions for action must comefrom communities,not CBM workers. • Community undertakings decided quickly may be abandoned equally quickly. • The project does not give things to people. • The project does not do things forpeople. • The project assists people to do thingsfor themselves. • The CBM process will only proceed in a community if the community wants it.

More Related