110 likes | 342 Views
Background to the Case. Argument14th AmendmentEqual ProtectionChief Engineer of the CaseCharles Hamilton HoustonSpecial Counsel, 1934Lawyer as Social EngineerQuoteLegal Realist. How to Kill Jim Crow. Questions in the 1930'sWhat strategy should be used?Direct or Indirect AttackShould legalism be used?StrategyNathan MargoldDirect AttackProsConsHouston's PlanAttack Education3 Tiered AttackProblem.
E N D
1. The Road to Brown The NAACP’s Attack on
Plessy v. Ferguson
2. Background to the Case Argument
14th Amendment
Equal Protection
Chief Engineer of the Case
Charles Hamilton Houston
Special Counsel, 1934
Lawyer as Social Engineer
Quote
Legal Realist
3. How to Kill Jim Crow Questions in the 1930’s
What strategy should be used?
Direct or Indirect Attack
Should legalism be used?
Strategy
Nathan Margold
Direct Attack
Pros
Cons
Houston’s Plan
Attack Education
3 Tiered Attack
Problem
4. How to Kill Jim Crow Why Legalism?
W.E.B Du Bois
Economic Nationalism
Ignoring other Problems
Should focus on Equal Opportunity
NAACP as a Roots Organization
Ella Baker
Highlander School
Growing Support
An American Dilemma, 1944
Assimilation & Integration
Post War America
5. A Change in Direction Economy of the ’30s
Depression
Economy of the ‘40s
Boom
Move North
?
Move to Direct Attack
AAs = Political Force
More Clients
More Lawyers
Legal Defense Education Fund, 1939
Thurgood Marshall
6. Legal Road to Brown American Apartheid
Roberts v. Boston, 1849
Nat’l Issue
States Rights
Plessy v. Ferguson, 1895
Harlan’s Dissent
Harlan’s Bigotry
Acceptance of Plessy
Gong Lum v. Rice, 1927
Stigma of Race
States define Race
Salary Equalization Abandoned
7. Legal Road to Brown Nibbling @ Plessy
Pearson v. Murray, 1936
MD Law School
Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada, 1938
Sipuel v. Oklahoma Board of Regents, 1948
Make Shift Schools
Still Segregated
Direct Attack
Sweatt v. Painter & McLaurin v. OK Board of Regents, 1949
Failed, but
Inherent Inequality
Psychological Evidence
Restrictive Covenants
Other Support
Howard McGrath
Harry Truman
8. Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, KS Briggs v. Elliott, Davis v. Prince Edward Co, Belton v. Gebhart, & Bolling v. Sharpe
Briggs v. Elliott
Clear Denial of Funding
Damaged Psyches
Ken & Mamie Clark
White Dolls & Black Dolls
Changes in the Court
Earl Warren for Vinson
Decision had to be unanimous
Arguments
Initial Stages…Intent of the 14th
The Decision …
Brown II
9. Reaction to Brown
10. Reaction to the Decision