70 likes | 166 Views
Analysis of Feebate Design In Rhode Island. Revenue Neutrality Average sales tax revenues should be 7% feebate from 0-14%, –7% to +21% (assuming uniform sales) or some other combination such that weighted mid-point is 7% Feebate=(Vm)*(M-Mo) Correct for administrative costs. Design (cont.).
E N D
Analysis of Feebate Design In Rhode Island • Revenue Neutrality • Average sales tax revenues should be 7% • feebate from 0-14%, –7% to +21% (assuming uniform sales) or some other combination such that weighted mid-point is 7% • Feebate=(Vm)*(M-Mo) • Correct for administrative costs
Design (cont.) • Only GHGs or GHGs and CAPs? • Rationale • How to weight each • Caps onfeebates? • Cheap highly efficient vehicles or equity concerns • Feebates separated by weight class? • Perverse impacts
Design (cont.) • Leakage, consumer equity, legal issues, etc. • How to prevent buyers from moving across the border to purchase their vehicles? • How to ensure fairness? • Maryland proposal withdrawn on the basis of federal challenge; legality untested.
Feebate Comparisons for Some Representative Vehicle Choices Class Vehicle City Gas Mileage in mpg Typical Retail Price in $ Fee or rebate (-) in $ Wagon Compact Toyota Prius (1.5L) 52 20,475 -1,262 VW Jetta (2.0L) 22 18,125 33 SUV Small SUV Toyota RAV4 (2.0L) 25 16,365 -272 Jeep Wrangler (2.5L) 16 15,475 511 Saturn LW300 (3.0L)--79 cu.f cargo capacity 20 22,105 -141 Ford Explorer (4.0L)—79.8 cu.f cargo capacity 16 25,810 128 Highest Rebate: Medium Pickup Ford Ranger Electric n.a. ~30,000 -1,845 GMC C2500 Sierra 11 28,219 1875 Highest Fee: Large Pickup