180 likes | 193 Views
This article explores the land application of landscape waste, food scrap composting, wood mulching, and the legal definitions and regulations surrounding leaf mulch. It also addresses questions and interpretations regarding waste management.
E N D
Landscape Waste & CompostingNuts, Bolts, & Other TidbitsNovember 1, 2018 Derek Rompot Illinois EPA
Derek Rompot Illinois Environmental Protection Agency 217-524-3262 derek.rompot@illinois.gov
Today’s Topics • Land Application • Food Scrap Composting – Recent Conversations • Wood Mulch • “Leaf Mulch”
Definition of Landscape Waste • Section 3.270 of the Act • All accumulations of grass or shrubbery cuttings, leaves, tree limbs and other materials accumulated as the result of the care of lawns, shrubbery, vines and trees
Land Application of Landscape Waste • Allowed under 21(q)(2) of the Act • Application of landscape waste and/or compost at agronomic rates • By definition, agronomic rate is 20 tons/acre/year • Approximately a ¾” layer of materail
Land Application of Landscape Waste • Pollution Control Board to approve application at higher rates • 21(q)(2) does not address allowable storage times of material prior to land application • Permit required to store material prior to land application
Food Scrap Composting • Not much new • Lots of landscaper waste composters permitted to allow food scrap composting • Minimal amount of food scrap being received composted
Food Scrap Composting • Multiple recent conversations • In Vessel Composting • Partnering with food manufactures to compost off-spec food products • No post consumer food scrap received • Several discussions, no permit applications yet
Wood Mulching • Illinois EPA allows the slanging of clean, uncontaminated clean woody material, and sizing (shredding) into mulch without a permit • Materials may include pallets, wood scrap from lumber mills, and trees • Illinois EPA can address problem sites via speculative accumulation and littering
Wood Mulching • Clean, uncontaminated woody materials may be salvaged from landscape waste • Branches 2” in diameter or larger • Tree trunks • No Leaves
Leaf Mulch • Same principle as wood mulch • Get material, size, sell and apply • Legitimate Product? • Historically not commonly used in Illinois, use increasing in recent years • Not Regulatory defined/addressed in Act
Leaf Mulch • Problem: Definition of landscape waste • All accumulations of grass or shrubbery cuttings, leaves, tree limbs and other materials accumulated as the result of the care of lawns, shrubbery, vines and trees • Pile of leaves is an accumulation of leaves, is landscape waste by definition
Kramer Tree Service • Kramer Tree Service • Illinois Pollution Control Board • AS14-2 • Adjusted Standard for 830 (Landscape waste Composting); relief from finished compost standards • Why regulated as a composter?
Kramer Tree • Decision August 12, 2014 • Order: Leaf Mulching is not composting and is not to be regulated as such (heavily paraphrased)
Leaf Mulch • How to regulate “Leaf Mulch” • Illinois EPA believes 35 IAC Part 807 – Solid Waste regulations apply and permit is needed • No exemption from the definition of pollution control facility (Section 3.330 of the Act) for leaf mulch operations, so local siting review (Section 39.2 of the Act) applies. • Regulated Community disagrees
Leaf Mulch • American Tree Service (PCB 94-43) • Definition of “waste” includes all other specifically denied wastes • Alternate Fuels (Supreme Court of Illinois No. 90671, 10/21/04) • Discussion of when a “waste” is discarded
Definition of Waste • Section 3.535 of the act defines “Waste” as any garbage, sludge from a waste water treatment plant, or air pollution control facility, or other discarded material…. • Note the terminology “other discarded material”
Questions/Further Legal Interpretations • Per American Tree, “landscape waste” is a subset of “waste”; is does landscape waste have to be “discarded” or does the definition of landscape waste (any accumulation) apply? • If landscape waste must be discarded, how does the Alternate Fuels ruling apply?