130 likes | 142 Views
Discover how the complexity of the tax code affects individual taxpayers and their financial planning. Learn about common mistakes and strategies to optimize after-tax returns.
E N D
How the Tax Code Affects Planning for Individual Taxpayers Armond Dinverno, JD, CPA, CFP Co-President Balasa Dinverno & Foltz LLC Itasca, IL President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform March 16, 2005 Chicago, Illinois
Introduction • Balasa Dinverno & Foltz LLC started business in 1986 • Financial Management firm for individuals, business owners, and pension plans • 20 employees: 8 Certified Public Accountants, 2 Attorneys, 2 MBAs, and 8 Certified Financial Planners • Approximately $830 Million in assets under management
How Do We Keep up With Tax Law Changes? • Constant amount of reading and research • Specialists in our firm follow tax rules – it is too difficult for generalists to maintain a tax knowledge base • We purchase specialized tax research and software • 2 of every 3 professionals in our firm are CPAs as a result of our desire to be experts at how income taxes affect our clients
The Tax Code Makes Achieving a Simple Objective a Difficult Task • Our Objective Is Simple → Maximize after-tax dollars • Unfortunately, the complexity of the tax code makes our job very difficult • Because of the complexity, we must address numerous issues before we advise clients on the best investment alternatives. These issues include the following- • Family tax filing status (and number of exemptions) • Amount and sources of income • Nature and amount of current financial assets • Investments in taxable accounts vs. tax deferred accounts • Real Estate • Mortgage debt • Home equity loans • Rental property
Additional Planning Considerations • Asset Placement – The right investments in the right accounts to minimize the effect of income taxes • Can we maximize tax-deferred growth by using 401(k) plans, IRAs, Roth IRAs, profit sharing plans, age-weighted plans or defined benefit plans? • Place capital gain assets in taxable accounts and high-income assets in tax-deferred accounts. • Tax Loss Harvesting – Utilization of losses associated with investments that have not performed well • Match losses with gains on investments that have performed well
Navigating Complexity • Because of differing tax rates, tax treatment and favored tax status, it is difficult for taxpayers to choose the investment alternative that would maximize after-tax returns • Due to the various sunsets of tax provisions, taxpayers are challenged to plan for the future, i.e., whether the current tax treatment will stay in effect • For example, a simple decision of what to do with an additional $250 of savings creates the following dilemma driven by the tax code: • Apply it to the mortgage • Apply it to credit card debt • Save it in a 401(k) plan • Contribute it to an IRA • Contribute it to a Roth IRA • Save it for college in a 529 plan • Invest it in a taxable account • The easiest solution but maybe not the best – spend it
Common Mistakes Taxpayers Make • Due to the complexity of the tax law, taxpayers have difficulty navigating through the rules to determine the best investment alternative • Not saving enough for retirement because they don’t know whether to save in a 401(k) plan or other contributory plan • Using municipal bonds in taxable accounts • There are approximately 100 different college savings plans
Common Mistakes Taxpayers Make • Taxpayers let the tax tail wag the dog instead of making good economic decisions (the complexity of the tax law leads to poor decisions) • For example, not selling assets for fear of paying taxes when sound economics encourage a sale
Other Common Mistakes • Failing to compute after-tax performance due to the complexity of that calculation • Paying additional taxes by not increasing the cost basis by mutual fund dividend reinvestments • Forgetting about carry-over items from previous years • Not meeting deadlines for setting up qualified retirement plans • Failing to name (or naming the wrong) beneficiary to an IRA, 401(k) or other retirement plan • Converting short-term debt into long-term debt with a Home Equity Loan • Not planning for the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) • Failing to claim deductions or tax benefits due to not knowing what is deductible
Conclusions • The time and money spent on figuring out the tax code could be more productively used by taxpayers thereby making their lives simpler. • Simpler taxes and an easier application of the tax law will help taxpayers make better economic decisions. • Better economic decisions will help maintain the economic growth engine of the United States.
Tax Treatment of Income and Investments Also Creates Compliance Burdens • If a professional firm prepares a client’s return, the client must complete a 15-page data questionnaire with 150 questions. • There are at least 14 possible tax forms to collect in the preparation of a tax return: W-2, W-2 G, 1099-MISC, 1098, 1099-S, 1099-INT, 1099-OID, 1099-DIV, 1099-B, 1099-G, 1099R, 1099-E, 1099 RRB, 1042S RRB. • Even taxpayers who use a return preparer face complexity.