160 likes | 172 Views
Explore the history of FDA-regulated dermatologic drugs withdrawn for safety reasons in the past 40 years. Delve into the complexities, inconsistencies, and improvements in science, with a focus on cancer-related risks and regulatory judgments. Discover the impact on public health and the challenges in understanding the clinical relevance of drug assays. This informative study examines the withdrawn drugs and their associated health risks, shedding light on the evolution of dermatologic drug safety.
E N D
TOX LESSONS LEARNED: FOUR DECADES FDA DERMATOLOGY DRUGS WITHDRAWN HOWARD I. MAIBACH, M.D. PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF DERMATOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94143 – 0989
BIG PICTURE • COMPLEXITY ! • INCONSISTENCY • SCIENCE IMPROVING • CANCER : - ASSAYvsDISEASE
DISCLAIMER NEITHER SUPPORT NOR DENY THESE REGULATORY JUDGEMENTS
THEORY • PERCIVAL POTTS & SCROTUM - SCROTUM – HIGHLY PERMEABLE • SKIN PAINTING ASSAYS – 100 YRS • HUMAN SKIN TUMORS – OBVIOUS • INTERNAL ORGANS? - BLADDER ? (DYES) - BLOOD ? (BENZENE)
WITHDRAWALS 1) BITHIONOL – 1967 PHOTOACD 2) HALOGENATED SALICYLANILIDES – 1975 PHOTOACD 3) *CHLOROFORM – 1976 CANCER 1976 – NCI – ORAL HEPATIC & RENAL 4) AZARIBINE – 1976 THROMBOEMBOLISM
WITHDRAWALS – con’t. 5) ZIRCONIUM – 1976 GRANULOMA *K ARSENITE 1980 CANCER J. HUTCHINSON (100 YRS.) BENOXAPROFEN 1982 RENAL & HEPATIC 8) CHLORHEXIDINE 1984 BURNS
WITHDRAWALS – con’t. 9) TEMAFLOXACIN – 1992 RENAL & HEPATIC 10) ASTEMIZOLE – 1999 DRUG - DRUG INTERACTION 11) TERFENADINE – 1997 DRUG - DRUG INTERACTION 12) ETRETINATE – 2002 TERATOGENIC
WITHDRAWALS – con’t. EFALIZUMAB – 2009 PML (PROGRESSIVE MULTIFOCAL LUEKOENCEPHALOPATHY) CANCER: 2/13
BLACK BOX • METHOTREXATE LYMPHOMA • TACROLIMUS LYMPHOMA • PIMECROLIMUS CLINICALRELEVANCE – SUBJUDICE
“PACKAGE INSERT LABEL” PHOTOCARCINOGENICITY - RETINOIC ACID - BENZOYL PEROXIDE CLINICALRELEVANCE: SUBJUDICE
DERMATOLOGIC DRUGS ORAL / PARENTERAL ~ HALF – ANIMAL ASSAY + CLINICALRELEVANCE: SUBJUDICE
CONCLUSIONS SIGNIFICANT PROGRESS: - PHOTOIRRITATION - ALLERGIC CONTACT DERMATITIS - PHOTOALLERGIC CONTACT DERMATITIS - DRUG - DRUG INTERACTION - CLINICAL TRIAL DESIGN MUCH REMAIN TO BE UNDERSTOOD: - CLINICAL RELEVANCE OF CARCINOGENICITY ASSAY
WEAK LINKS • PHARMACOVIGILENCE • COSMETIC VIGILENCE • CONSUMER PRODUCT VIGILENCE
POWER • IARC ! • NEW COMPUTER DATA BASES • FUTURE - BRIGHT ! - SKIN – BIOMARKER
REFERENCE M. MARTIN & H. MAIBACH: DERMATOLOGIC DRUGS WITHDRAWN BY THE FDA FOR SAFETY REASONS MARZULLI & MAIBACH: DERMATOTOXICOLOGY,8THED, INFORMA, 2012, p. 500-509
HOWARD I. MAIBACH, MD TELEPHONE: (415) 673 - 9693 0700 – 0800 Hour SAN FRANCISCO TIME MaibachH@derm.ucsf.edu